Iliman Ndiaye

[Doc_Testosterone]

He’s better then Marmosuh and Savinho

He is not better with 6 goals. He is a mid-table football player.

 

[Matt.D]

Send them Grealish. If the £60m rumoured fee is correct then surely Jack would offset around a half or third of that?

Absolutely dreaming there mate. Said it before, we will have to let him go on a free if we want him off the books.

Well known alcohol problem. injury back end of last season. Had an ok few months for Everton but was poor for 2 years before that. 300 grand a week wages. Absolutely zero chance we are getting 20-30m.

 

[Uglyassin]

Wasn’t Akliouche on his way here after the Detourbet loan to Monaco ?

 

[City_Sean]

Would be a really bizarre and poor use of funds. There are miles better options. He's a tidy player but little to no end product.

Keeping Savinho makes more sense than signing Ndiaye.

 

[bluethai]

Yes, please! He's definitely better than Savinho and exactly what we need. He has the technical quality we've been missing since Bernardo, David Silva, and Mahrez, and he always works hard to help the team defensively as well.

 

[Tevez City]

Better winger than Semenyo & Marmoush

 

[ALDN_Ko]

Better winger than Semenyo & Marmoush

Very low bar. If that’s what we’re aiming for, we’ll be like United in no time at all. He’s not even the right profile, again

 

[Willo the Wisp]

Everton fan I know doesn't make much of him. When he wants to be he's great.....it's that not that often

Absolutely, brilliant match against us, but I've looked out for him in other Everton matches and he is not to be seen, I would have Grealish back above signing him

 

[Gray]

Absolutely, brilliant match against us, but I've looked out for him in other Everton matches and he is not to be seen, I would have Grealish back above signing him

Yes so would I, if only he could stop being a dick and acting like Ben Stokes when away from football,

 

[eastmanc]

No he's not.

Yes he is.

 

[sk3ptical]

Better winger than Semenyo & Marmoush

Nonsense.Give me 17 goal in the pl this season semenyo over 6 goal ndiaye any day

 

[Jugger]

Yes he is.

good joke

 

[Master-Lotus]

Better winger than Semenyo & Marmoush

Semenyo is the top scoring winger in the PL this season and also our top scoring winger despite only joining in January. This Semenyo slander seriously needs to stop. Not to mention the fact he won us the FA Cup.

 

[bell_mcfc]

Wasn’t Akliouche on his way here after the Detourbet loan to Monaco ?

That would be nice.

It’s come out recently we had him lined up last year incase Savio left. Then lots of talk is PSG in for him. I hope we get him.

 

[Quinny851]

…have you ever watched Ndiaye play?

Yes and he looks to be exactly what Grealish was like when he was at Villa

 

[Craig]

Yes and he looks to be exactly what Grealish was like when he was at Villa

Far better dribbler and natural talent than Jack ever was.

 

[01cravend]

He's an average winger with poor output but he works his bollocks off and is an elite ball carrier so could be a good wingback if that's a route we go down under Maresca.


Will say, we do need to stop with this constantly signing players from midtable teams that havent won anything, with no title contending experience, no European experience, no playing 3 games a week experience. It's making us worse year on year. There are exceptions of course, Anderson, for example, best player at his club and doing it for England too but we cant keep pulling almost exclusively from the midtable talent pool especially as our experienced players are leaving en masse.

 

[eastmanc]

He's an average winger with poor output but he works his bollocks off and is an elite ball carrier so could be a good wingback if that's a route we go down under Maresca.


Will say, we do need to stop with this constantly signing players from midtable teams that havent won anything, with no title contending experience, no European experience, no playing 3 games a week experience. It's making us worse year on year. There are exceptions of course, Anderson, for example, best player at his club and doing it for England too but we cant keep pulling almost exclusively from the midtable talent pool especially as our experienced players are leaving en masse.

Sorry but with your argument we would never of signed John Stone or Ake, Mahrez, I know he won the league with Leicester but he didn't have loads of experience in Europe or with playing three times a week also Jack Grelish had no trophy winning experience. And with your logic we should definitely not be in for Elliot Anderson. It doesn't mean you aren't a good footballer if you are not playing for a top side.

 

[Tugay One Cup]

also Jack Grelish had now trophy winning experience

In the main I agree with you and disagree with the whole "don't sign players from midtable teams" thing but the example you've given above doesn't exactly help our case.

 

[eastmanc]

In the main I agree with you and disagree with the whole "don't sign players from midtable teams" thing but the example you've given above doesn't exactly help our case.

I meant to say no experience, which he didn't have, he'd played a lot outside of the Premier League. The list is endless through out history, of top sides buying players from mid to lower league sides.