Ilkay Gundogan - 2017/18 performances

[Cheadle_hulmeBlue]

He's not very good and is similar to Yaya in the sense he slows our attacking fluency and offers nothing from a central position.

fair enough thats your opinion. as I said though, other then today we haven't lost a game with him in the team. pep seems to disagree you swell.

 

[Mr HJ]

Thought he was decent. Preferred the ball going to him when we are pressured than anyone else.

I think folks are just looking for someone to pick on. There wee many worse. But in general, they just had more energy than we did.

Agreed Dax - he also took his goal really well and his one two with Sergio for Bernardo's goal was excellent. It was just one of those games, I can't believe we will play a game with three terrible errors again this season and I don't think you will see the likes of Kyle just boot the ball out so many times again. Some on here always look for a scapegoat and post accordingly. I prefer to think today will turn out to be the kick we need to finish this remarkable year well, and as I say perhaps it's best to get all those errors out of the way in one!

 

[blue wang]

Agreed Dax - he also took his goal really well and his one two with Sergio for Bernardo's goal was excellent. It was just one of those games, I can't believe we will play a game with three terrible errors again this season and I don't think you will see the likes of Kyle just boot the ball out so many times again. Some on here always look for a scapegoat and post accordingly. I prefer to think today will turn out to be the kick we need to finish this remarkable year well, and as I say perhaps it's best to get all those errors out of the way in one!

I thought he was the best out of our midfield, the only one who showed the slightest bit of composure besides KDB.
Sterling and Fernandinho were costing us the position in a big way, thus making the team look average. Consistently chalking up assists and goals.
looked fairly decent in the tackle too. He was not the problem today.

 

[MarsLlama]

Had a bad game. Nice goal though.

 

[BlueTG]

He has moments of quality in him, I'm just not sure what he's supposed to be doing exactly whenever he's on the pitch.

 

[shemnel]

i have to agree with the above, whenever i see him play i have no real idea as to where he supposed to be playing.

really want him to improve, nice player when he's on it

 

[mmc]

Pretty hard to replace silva tbh, was obv he wasn’t up to standard yesterday but I wouldn’t be so quick to forget his performance against Barca and how his form was before his last injury. Silva should be starting without a doubt and I hope gundogan is content playing second fiddle whilst his form improves.

 

[borassic]

Potentially great, just needs to find his place in this team.

 

[kevin horlocks wand]

He is the best in the team at passing the ball back 5 yards to the guy who has just passed to him (often more than once).

We need more from him.

 

[r.soleofsalford]

Had a bad game. Nice goal though.

and a nice assist