Ilkay Gundogan - 2018/19 performances

Status
Not open for further replies.
Not true at all. He was always pretty steady.

He has been anything but,hence the criticism.

Hopefully,from here forwards,he will be exactly that and maybe more......but i'm baffled that people are now making things up and refusing to acknowledge that previously he hasn't shown up.
 
The only hole is the wrong one you're talking out of......i'm one of a few on here who appraises him accordingly and not through bifocal blue lenses.

For some bizarre reason you want to focus solely on the negative aspect of my comments.

I am sure pep points out his failings, and like the other players, he works on his weaknesses.
I read and remember your posts about his lack of ability, this summation of yours is clearly contradictory to the one the Coach has, because he continually picks him for Mcfc.
I can see the odd weakness in many of our players, as can the Manager, but like him I see the strengths far outweigh those weaknesses.
I always respect that posters have a right to their opinion as you have, I just feel the need to tell them when they are wrong.
As an example @meeesh needed telling about Sterling(and others) and plenty of others about Gabby.
These players do not get picked by Pep Guardioala if they are not good enough.
 
I am sure pep points out his failings, and like the other players, he works on his weaknesses.
I read and remember your posts about his lack of ability, this summation of yours is clearly contradictory to the one the Coach has, because he continually picks him for Mcfc.
I can see the odd weakness in many of our players, as can the Manager, but like him I see the strengths far outweigh those weaknesses.
I always respect that posters have a right to their opinion as you have, I just feel the need to tell them when they are wrong.
As an example @meeesh needed telling about Sterling(and others) and plenty of others about Gabby.
These players do not get picked by Pep Guardioala if they are not good enough.

Still have a split opinion all the same,no matter who "tells me" or tries to,especially on here
 
I am sure pep points out his failings, and like the other players, he works on his weaknesses.
I read and remember your posts about his lack of ability, this summation of yours is clearly contradictory to the one the Coach has, because he continually picks him for Mcfc.
I can see the odd weakness in many of our players, as can the Manager, but like him I see the strengths far outweigh those weaknesses.
I always respect that posters have a right to their opinion as you have, I just feel the need to tell them when they are wrong.
As an example @meeesh needed telling about Sterling(and others) and plenty of others about Gabby.
These players do not get picked by Pep Guardioala if they are not good enough.

He's picked loads of players who aren't good enough throughout his career.
 
I still don't trust him.

He is playing very well right now, but I am hoping, rather than expecting it will continue.

Might be at cross purposes here mate,we were talking about Sterling,(unless that's what you mean as well), as for Ilkay,I can't work him out,sometimes he plays like a world star,other games like a fanny,no consistency in his game whatsoever.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.