It's Quiet thread 14 - 'do one' edition

[Neville Kneville]

David Brightwell didn't play in that game.

Was it his brother who played the Garcia role in that one ?

 

[Gingers Dad]

No

Great full back but hasnt got the discipline, awareness, concentration or reading of the game to make a centre half -not a leader either.

Totally disagree with you on that one. I think you're describing the player we bought not what he is now.

 

[Sky Blue]

Was it his brother who played the Garcia role in that one ?

Yep, think so.

 

[Gingers Dad]

I feel as if it might be too late in his career, for his brain to adapt. Also, for some reason, he doesn't seem to dominate headers like you would expect.

It would take him about 2 days training to be better than the current level though, I imagine.

If Pep goes back 3 maybe ?

I actually think he'd make a better DM than anyone we've got there now apart from a fully switched on Fernandinho.

 

[Sky Blue]

How would he excel? He could not pass, he had absolutely no intelligence, he could not control a football. He ran about like a headless chicken. We some how inexplicably made him the most expensive full back there was, yet his performances no where near justified the fee we paid. There is a reason he did not ever play for a top team and that is because he was no where near good enough. He was flavour of the month for a Wimbledon team that just went about kicking lumps out of everyone.

I remember him playing against Nayim and it was embarrassing. It was like a dog chasing a tennis ball.

Now he was fast, but the best thing about him was his song. I fail to see what traits he had which would make him successful in our current team.

Same player I remember.

 

[Neville Kneville]

I actually think he'd make a better DM than anyone we've got there now apart from a fully switched on Fernandinho.

We play with a Divot though (or a double Divot)

 

[yerwot?]

We play with a Divot though (or a double Divot)

Very down to earth player,needed replacing....

 

[Zin 'messiah' Zimmer]

Not sure where all this Phelan love in has come from as he was crap. He was fast and that was about it. He was way over priced and came absolutely no where near justifying the 2.5 million we paid. He was the 90's version of Wan-Bissaka. I have never seen a footballer have less control over the football. A real headless chicken.

deary me....... although entitled to your opinion that is one of the craziest player analysis I’ve read on here!

 

[simon23]

Totally disagree with you on that one. I think you're describing the player we bought not what he is now.

He loses concentration all the time - especially at the back post - he is not a centre half by a long chalk

 

[HorlocksWalk]

We play with a Divot though (or a double Divot)

Divot Origi?