James McAtee

He's a good player, but I don't see him as a Pep player, Pep wants players who keep the ball, he has a tendancy to run with it too much, and then lose possession.

I hope he does well, but I don't see it being with City.
The flip side to that is that he's surrounded by inferior players at Sheffield United so may feel a need to go it alone; Grealish exhibited a similar tendency at Aston Villa. Not saying McAtee's future is with us, just that good players can adapt their game to fit our system.
 
It is certainly a weird choice to go back to a team that doesn't play to his strengths and lacks technical ability.

If they were still in the championship yep be a good loan! In the premier we know they'll be cannon fodder with Hardly any of the ball! Bad choice by McAteer..
 
Fair enough. I think we could have accommodated him but it’s probably too late now.
As a club, yes probably, I like him as a player, but what I like and what Pep wants are probably worlds apart, so I can see why he was allowed out on loan, it remains to be seen if he'll ever play here again, and I don't think this loan is going to help that much.
 
As a club, yes probably, I like him as a player, but what I like and what Pep wants are probably worlds apart, so I can see why he was allowed out on loan, it remains to be seen if he'll ever play here again, and I don't think this loan is going to help that much.
If Guardiola was going to accommodate him, then I think he would have had to have started on the wing and done his learning from there. However, he probably saw Palmer was ahead of him in that regard and the arrival of Doku would have been another warning sign. I can understand his wanting to return to Sheffield, but it’s just a great pity that we couldn’t have arranged something with Brighton.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.