Jerome Boateng.

For certain he should not be played as a fullback again anytime soon,he should only be employed as a centrehalf,whether that be 2nd,3rd or 4th choice,i'm not sure.

We have to be very careful with Boateng as his confidence already looks to be fragile,i still believe he'll be a very good player for us as he does have ability,we all saw it at the WC,however,my main concern with him is his attitude and commitment,he seems to be missing that of a winner.

Maybe even taking him out of the first team picture,in an effort to (re)discover that confidence and mentality,by playing him in the stiffs would be best for all.

We would be covered by Boyata,who is back from injury and certainly no worse an option.
 
LoveCity said:
Boateng was very good at LB for Germany in the World Cup, he looked more confident and whipped in some excellent crosses. Why he isn't doing that for us, I'm not sure. Maybe he hasn't settled in or maybe club football is harder than the World Cup when you're not playing a team like Spain or Holland. If he continues to have no effect as a full-back he should be used exclusively as a centre-back even if he has to drop to the bench regularly.

Only because he was playing against Milner!

I posted it on a thread the other day: Please tell me how this guy is better than Nedum.
 
Player in 'Good In World Cup But Shit In Premier League' shocker!!!

Where are we getting that he's good at centre-half?

I'm not mad keen on slagging off new players but he is nowhere near good enough to get in the first team. Those charity collectors on Market Street show more agression; I can't believe how soft he is for such a big lad.

Luckily he has time on his side so might come good but he is looking like a Tournament Tim at the moment.
 
liamctid said:
Only because he was playing against Milner!

I posted it on a thread the other day: Please tell me how this guy is better than Nedum.

To be fair Liam,he played very well at fullback(especially right) at the WC regardless of who he was opposing.

On present form,you are right,he is worse than Nedum.The same can be said for Kolarov in regards to Bridge.
 
Since I like my predictions and I have a penchant for being right. I called Micah owning the Right back position early in the season when most were enamored by the new Boateng and the hot Zabaletta.

And I will call it now. Boateng will own the CD position next to Vincent Kompany. It might not happen this season. But next season the Boateng/Kompany partnership will start off in earnest and they will be a beauty!

However, I have looked at it a thousand and one ways, but unless City becomes United or Arsenal cohesive in the next year, Kolarov will most likely always be poor for us. I felt this way in the summer when we were chasing him and hoped and prayed we didn't get him. And after we did, I prayed he wasn't the player I thought he was, but the more I watch him play, the more of the player I thought i knew, is what I see.

Without any doubt in my mind, Kolarov is the Bosnian Taye Taiwo. ANd there is nothing more frustrating than having one of those players on a team that is not cohesive. Which we are not yet. Coz they have the tendency to disrupt what little cohesion the team has with there often self centered decision making.

Unlike most, I am actually not too worried about his defending, it is slightly below Zabs, and on par with Micah and better than Boateng's. This is not much of a problem for me. Defending is a team activity. You get enough of your players willing to join in and squeze space and it matters little how great any individual one is. Especially when you have a rock like Komps or Vidic in the mix.
More comparisons here. He is certainly better than Marcelo who plays for Madrid, as good as Maxwell who now starts at Barca on the left, as good if not better than Leighton Baines who in my opinion has been the best LB in the Premiership.

The actual ability to tackle is not as important in my opinion. The ability to play however is of utmost importance! Kolarov often does not play for the team, and relies too often on his individual talent indiscriminately. I.e he shoots too much! And even when he doesn't shoot, he is often thinking of it ( I know this coz I am in his head :p) And this for me is not acceptable. I have never liked none team players. I don't care how talented they are. Didn't like Ronaldo (outside of the fact that he was a rag), Don't like Walcott, Don't like Marcelo, Taiwo, Tevez, Ibrahimovic, Robihno, Nzogbia, Adam Johnson (originally), Chavez, DIego, Robben, Van Persie e.t.c.

As you can see, some are amongst the best in the world and others are just good players. But that individualistic quality at the expense of the team drives me nuts. Those types of players bring the extra that super cohesive teams need to top each other. But they also often are detriments to teams who are not cohesive. And generally speaking, i'd rather not have them.

Unless that is, my team already has them and they are often carrying us inspite of their individual approach :P

Which is unfortunately the case with ..... :P

Oh yes, back to topic- Yeah Boateng will be solid--
 
Hahaha no way do you think that Kolarov is better than Marcelo?!?!?

Shurely not? I mean you've said your piece and fair play to your opinion which you've sort of backed up.

But Kolarov better than Marcelo? Madness!
 
Spiros said:
Hahaha no way do you think that Kolarov is better than Marcelo?!?!?

Shurely not? I mean you've said your piece and fair play to your opinion which you've sort of backed up.

But Kolarov better than Marcelo? Madness!
Sorry if I didn't make i clear. I don't think he is a better player. I meant as a tackler. As you can see I said he was also better than Baines (who I think is the best LB in the PL this season) clearly if I meant that Kolarov was just better, then I'd be nuts to say he is better than the best LB in the PL, when he too plays in the PL.

I meant as tacklers or pure defenders, he is better or just as good. I am quite sure he is better than Marcelo who is horrendous defending often!
 
20sbc07 said:
stonerblue said:
He was beaten by the winger so many times yesterday that i lost count. Also regularly shits out of challenges when he should be going in a full throttle. If he continues to wave his foot around he will pick up injuries. I've seen little, if any, improvement in his game since he arrived.

Finally someone who actually pays attention to the game.

Boateng is our weakest player in defence where ever he plays. He cant pass, tackle or mark players properly, Hes been given plenty time to settle in and hes still shocking. This is not the same player from the world cup.

I wouldn't mind but you don't even have to look very closely to see that every winger he's played against when at RB has beaten him, and easily.

Getting two quality full-backs in for this season was top prority and i think we've failed spectacularly. Thankfully Micah has got his form back or we would've been fucked. In all seriousness i'd rather have SWP at right back than Boateng.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.