joe hart or kolo toure?

Prestwich_Blue said:
Hart's fault 100%.

If he'd stayed put, Kolo could have headed it back to him quite easily. You can see on the replays that Kolo is about to do something then either gets distracted by Hart or leaves it because he calls.

Well, that's WHY it's Kolo's fault!!

He's experienced. Do what experienced defenders do, regardless of the inexperienced keeper who is halfway in his own half!!
 
Toure was under the ball and would have dealt with it by heading it towards Kompany.
Hart called it, Toure put his faith in "England's number 1 goalkeeper" and Hart missed the ball.
When Hart gave Kolo the shout, Kolo will have thought "if I try and deal with this now, I'll get clattered by Hart and we both may miss the ball." So he stepped aside.
Without a doubt, entirely Hart's fault.

It raises a couple of other questions though on blame.

If Toure had tried to deal with it after Hart giving him the shout, Hart ran into the back of him and Blackburn scored, who would we blame?

If Toure had dealt with it and we had got away with what was a potential disasterous mix up, would we be praising Toure or saying he should have left it after he was given a shout?
 
Bigga said:
Prestwich_Blue said:
Hart's fault 100%.

If he'd stayed put, Kolo could have headed it back to him quite easily. You can see on the replays that Kolo is about to do something then either gets distracted by Hart or leaves it because he calls.

Well, that's WHY it's Kolo's fault!!

He's experienced. Do what experienced defenders do, regardless of the inexperienced keeper who is halfway in his own half!!
Complete rubbish. with two defenders covering, Hart had no right whatsoever to be there as he denied those defenders the chance to play it back to him.
 
The Pink Panther said:
Toure was under the ball and would have dealt with it by heading it towards Kompany.
Hart called it, Toure put his faith in "England's number 1 goalkeeper" and Hart missed the ball.
When Hart gave Kolo the shout, Kolo will have thought "if I try and deal with this now, I'll get clattered by Hart and we both may miss the ball." So he stepped aside.
Without a doubt, entirely Hart's fault.

It raises a couple of other questions though on blame.

If Toure had tried to deal with it after Hart giving him the shout, Hart ran into the back of him and Blackburn scored, who would we blame?

If Toure had dealt with it and we had got away with what was a potential disasterous mix up, would we be praising Toure or saying he should have left it after he was given a shout?

Defenders always put themselves in harm's way. Why would this be any different? Touré was in a position to head or kick the ball out. That is all what Hart was going to do. He was waiting for it to drop to boot it.

That area was Touré's area to patrol.


Prestwich_Blue said:
Bigga said:
Well, that's WHY it's Kolo's fault!!

He's experienced. Do what experienced defenders do, regardless of the inexperienced keeper who is halfway in his own half!!
Complete rubbish. with two defenders covering, Hart had no right whatsoever to be there as he denied those defenders the chance to play it back to him.

"Complete rubbish", but you merely emphasize my point for me. Cheers!
 
Harts fault by far. Toure couldnt do fuck all as soon as Hart came flying out like a mad man. If Kolo would of went to clear the ball Hart would of taken him out. If Kolo would of headed back towards the goal Hart would of taken him out so Hart called for it he should of got the ball simple really. Make stupid mistakes like that and its a fall from grace.
 
completely harts fault

if he hadnt of been there toure would have dealt with it....by either passing back to hart or by turning and knocking it out.

hart had no reason to be there.....kolo had it covered until he got in the way
 
50-50 TO BLAME lady lucks not there Tevez miss sunderland plus richards pen give away and johnsons invisable pen lol same old city
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.