Joe Hart or Willy Caballero

[forevermancity]

Willy isn't as bad as he has shown so far, I'm sure he will get better. He's far the better keeper than pants.

 

[sir baconface]

I don't like his attitude and top keepers save more points than hart does - its a fact.

Having made the comment, would you like to back it up?

 

[Mr Ed (The Stables)]

Willy isn't as bad as he has shown so far, I'm sure he will get better. He's far the better keeper than pants.

If he is I haven't seen it.

 

[Laertes]

Willy isn't as bad as he has shown so far, I'm sure he will get better. He's far the better keeper than pants.

If he is I haven't seen it.

Out of curiosity, how many times have you actually seen him play?

He's played about four times for us, it's ridiculous to definitively judge any player after four matches.

 

[Mr Ed (The Stables)]

Willy isn't as bad as he has shown so far, I'm sure he will get better. He's far the better keeper than pants.

If he is I haven't seen it.

Out of curiosity, how many times have you actually seen him play?

He's played about four times for us, it's ridiculous to definitively judge any player after four matches.

Well I can only judge a player on what I've seen. He was awful the other night and should have saved both goals imo, he was terrible in the charity shield.

Obviously if Joe breaks a bone is out six weeks then he'll have my support but as of now I'm not particularly looking forward to seeing him play anytime soon. Only my opinion of course!!

To answer your question I've seen him play in the four games he's played for us.

 

[Ray78]

I am not completely writing off Willy just yet.

 

[Laertes]

If he is I haven't seen it.

Out of curiosity, how many times have you actually seen him play?

He's played about four times for us, it's ridiculous to definitively judge any player after four matches.

Well I can only judge a player on what I've seen. He was awful the other night and should have saved both goals imo, he was terrible in the charity shield.

Obviously if Joe breaks a bone is out six weeks then he'll have my support but as of now I'm not particularly looking forward to seeing him play anytime soon. Only my opinion of course!!

To answer your question I've seen him play in the four games he's played for us.

Thanks for answering. I'm not trying to say people aren't allowed to have negative opinions of him or anything like that - he has been pretty awful so far - I just find it absurd that so many people on here are so willing to write him off as a player based on all of four matches. It's just not enough time to properly judge somebody.

I'd probably share your opinion by the way, I'm no fan of Joe Hart but he look more secure than Caballero at the moment.

 

[Mr Ed (The Stables)]

Out of curiosity, how many times have you actually seen him play?

He's played about four times for us, it's ridiculous to definitively judge any player after four matches.

Well I can only judge a player on what I've seen. He was awful the other night and should have saved both goals imo, he was terrible in the charity shield.

Obviously if Joe breaks a bone is out six weeks then he'll have my support but as of now I'm not particularly looking forward to seeing him play anytime soon. Only my opinion of course!!

To answer your question I've seen him play in the four games he's played for us.

Thanks for answering. I'm not trying to say people aren't allowed to have negative opinions of him or anything like that - he has been pretty awful so far - I just find it absurd that so many people on here are so willing to write him off as a player based on all of four matches. It's just not enough time to properly judge somebody.

I'd probably share your opinion by the way, I'm no fan of Joe Hart but he look more secure than Caballero at the moment.

I think thats the key, the OP is about Joe Hart or Willy.

Hart is streets ahead at this moment of time and that includes his frailties like distribution etc.

Now if the discussion included Manuel Peter Neuer and you take the old debate to another level, but there's a snowballs chance in hell that he'll ever play for us.

 

[kaz7]

Great save joe

 

[Davs 19]

I am not completely writing off Willy just yet.

Entirely your prerogative Ray but he'll never get past Hart.

Well done yet again Joe.