Joe Hart

[The Fixer]

Will he ever be our number 1? Shay is 32 and will probably end his career at city so will be here for another 5/6 years and tbh i can't ever see Joe dislodging shay out of our nets. I think it's a shame because he's very talented but no way will he wait around for the odd game here and there.

Thoughts?

 

[Corky]

Maybe we loan him out until he is 34 then he can come back to be our Hillario. What a class 3rd keeper he was for Chelsea ('was' as he seems to be number 2 now).

 

[Freestyler]

I personally can't see him being at the club after this season, he will either leave or be loaned out again, i think we should keep shay given on as staff once he retires, would be a superb goalkeeping coach and his experience is massive.

 

[BlueLlama]

Based on the limited exposure I have seen of him at Birmingham he will not make it as a top first choice keeper. In fact I would not be surprised to see him on the bench at Birmingham before Christmas.

 

[sam the drummer]

Be fair to the lad, Birmingham have the 2nd best defensive record I think. Hes just made one or two cock ups which led to goals

 

[Scottyboi]

never rated him not commanding enough, prefer kasper.


*hides in panic room

 

[dannybcity]

He's a good keeper with one or two kinks that need ironing out. Loan him out until he's learnt his trade then bring him back.

 

[JoeMercer'sWay]

The same Kaspar who become the English game's 2nd greatest mercenary after Sol Campbell after signing for Notts County when he had clearly potential to be a decent premier league/good championship keeper? no thanks.

 

[Anonymous]

everyone knows keepers careers dont start until 27. before that and you have someone very special. ie casilles.

 

[Scottyboi]

The same Kaspar who become the English game's 2nd greatest mercenary after Sol Campbell after signing for Notts County when he had clearly potential to be a decent premier league/good championship keeper? no thanks.

no one wanted to take the chance on him. I dont blame them the prem is alot of money and you cannot afford to gamble on a young keeper. Still prefer kasper. I use to look away when hart came out for corners.