You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Kalidou Koulibaly
- Thread starter Matt Diablo
- Start date
After winning his first 43 of 50 Premier League games with John Stones or Otamendi as his main partners,
He now needs a "world class" CB partner so we can challenge for the Premier League again.
Eric Garcia meanwhile will be happy to sit as 3rd choice while Laporte's new world class partner delivers us 3 to 4 years of top level performance.
But oh dear god are we failing our academy & Phil Foden if we bring in someone to replace David Silva.
He now needs a "world class" CB partner so we can challenge for the Premier League again.
Eric Garcia meanwhile will be happy to sit as 3rd choice while Laporte's new world class partner delivers us 3 to 4 years of top level performance.
But oh dear god are we failing our academy & Phil Foden if we bring in someone to replace David Silva.
We ended up champs last year because a world class cb did partner Laporte. KompanyAfter winning his first 43 of 50 Premier League games with John Stones or Otamendi as his main partners,
He now needs a "world class" CB partner so we can challenge for the Premier League again.
Eric Garcia meanwhile will be happy to sit as 3rd choice while Laporte's new world class partner delivers us 3 to 4 years of top level performance.
But oh dear god are we failing our academy & Phil Foden if we bring in someone to replace David Silva.
SatOnTheWall
Well-Known Member
The club isn't there to serve the academy. The academy is there to serve the club.But oh dear god are we failing our academy & Phil Foden if we bring in someone to replace David Silva.
After winning his first 43 of 50 Premier League games with John Stones or Otamendi as his main partners,
He now needs a "world class" CB partner so we can challenge for the Premier League again.
Eric Garcia meanwhile will be happy to sit as 3rd choice while Laporte's new world class partner delivers us 3 to 4 years of top level performance.
But oh dear god are we failing our academy & Phil Foden if we bring in someone to replace David Silva.
Ridiculous analysis, if you are saying we have enough quality at centre back to win this league, against this Liverpool side and the sides below us who are improving then you either haven’t watched enough of us or need to look at us more objectively. No chance we would have won the league last year if Vinny didn’t come back in to the team for the last third/ quarter of the season.
Garcia will get plenty of games but he’s not yet good enough to be first choice and probably won’t be for a couple of years.
JimmyGrimble10
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 28 Sep 2011
- Messages
- 728
After winning his first 43 of 50 Premier League games with John Stones or Otamendi as his main partners,
He now needs a "world class" CB partner so we can challenge for the Premier League again.
Eric Garcia meanwhile will be happy to sit as 3rd choice while Laporte's new world class partner delivers us 3 to 4 years of top level performance.
But oh dear god are we failing our academy & Phil Foden if we bring in someone to replace David Silva.
so you’re saying we want him? Those 3 and Fernandinho and as emergency option is perfect. Sell Stones and Otamendi.
We need to buy a player that bosses the defence if laporte isnt playing.
We can’t buy a partner for laporte that isn’t capable of being the main man himself.
No point buying a replacement/slight upgrade on otamendi or stones as we’ll be in the same position we were this season when the defence wasn’t good enough for the relentlessness of the league.
If koulibaly is the only available player of that quality then make it happen and don’t worry about an extra 10-20m amortised over 4-5 years.
Wage demands is a different matter and must fit the structure.
We can’t buy a partner for laporte that isn’t capable of being the main man himself.
No point buying a replacement/slight upgrade on otamendi or stones as we’ll be in the same position we were this season when the defence wasn’t good enough for the relentlessness of the league.
If koulibaly is the only available player of that quality then make it happen and don’t worry about an extra 10-20m amortised over 4-5 years.
Wage demands is a different matter and must fit the structure.
Kokonut1307
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 21 May 2013
- Messages
- 1,650
Media saying Liverpool are looking to bid for him. Seems like we might be interested in him after all.
Kokonut1307
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 21 May 2013
- Messages
- 1,650
After winning his first 43 of 50 Premier League games with John Stones or Otamendi as his main partners,
He now needs a "world class" CB partner so we can challenge for the Premier League again.
Eric Garcia meanwhile will be happy to sit as 3rd choice while Laporte's new world class partner delivers us 3 to 4 years of top level performance.
But oh dear god are we failing our academy & Phil Foden if we bring in someone to replace David Silva.
Just two questions:
1. Are you suggesting we are now interested in signing him?
2. Wouldn’t Aouar be replacing Silva?
After winning his first 43 of 50 Premier League games with John Stones or Otamendi as his main partners,
He now needs a "world class" CB partner so we can challenge for the Premier League again.
Eric Garcia meanwhile will be happy to sit as 3rd choice while Laporte's new world class partner delivers us 3 to 4 years of top level performance.
But oh dear god are we failing our academy & Phil Foden if we bring in someone to replace David Silva.
There's a big difference between Garcia being third choice CB and Foden potentially being 5th choice CM behind KDB, Bernardo, Gundogan and Aouar, pushing him to play in other positions like LW where he isnt as good.
I think even Garcia will consider himself deluded if he thinks he's going to take the mantle as a starting CB at 19 years old in one of the best squads in football. Even as a 4th choice he would get plenty of game time, if he enters next season as our 3rd choice he's laughing.
Foden has had Pep gushing over him for two seasons saying he's the heir to Silva. Going out and buying another player to play in his position when we already have multiple other options (and other academy talents ready to take up a back up role) would be so ridiculous after all the things Pep's said about him.
Super Joey Hart
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 23 Nov 2015
- Messages
- 214
Media saying Liverpool are looking to bid for him. Seems like we might be interested in him after all.
don’t worry about them they don’t have a pot to piss in. Couldn’t even afford the fee for Werner
1. NoJust two questions:
1. Are you suggesting we are now interested in signing him?
2. Wouldn’t Aouar be replacing Silva?
2. Yes
You cannot rotate Centre-Backs like you do Midfielders or Forwards.
Burtonblue
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 7 Nov 2010
- Messages
- 5,886
This is a fundamental signing for us.
He is probably the in the top 5 central defenders in the world and the nearest I’ve seen to VK to date in the way he bullies strikers. He is a natural leader.
We didn’t sign VVD and certainly cannot afford to pass over the opportunity of missing out again.
I think the dippers interest is probably a smokescreen to inflate his market value but if he did end up joining them it wouldn’t be good for the rest of us.
Please get your cheque book out and sign him Txiki!
He is probably the in the top 5 central defenders in the world and the nearest I’ve seen to VK to date in the way he bullies strikers. He is a natural leader.
We didn’t sign VVD and certainly cannot afford to pass over the opportunity of missing out again.
I think the dippers interest is probably a smokescreen to inflate his market value but if he did end up joining them it wouldn’t be good for the rest of us.
Please get your cheque book out and sign him Txiki!
What is he not good enough at yet? I think most posters say stuff like that because of his age, when he plays with far more maturity than some defenders who are 29/30. He can still improve like anyone but to say he's not good enough to be first choice for a couple of years is complete bollocks in my opinion.Garcia will get plenty of games but he’s not yet good enough to be first choice and probably won’t be for a couple of years.
Most posters were wanking themselves into a cross-eyed abyss last summer in the hope we would sign De Ligt. The stand out traits to Garcia's game are his ability to read play, sniff out danger early and communication; all those which would usually be aimed at younger players to improve upon, especially defenders.There's a big difference between Garcia being third choice CB and Foden potentially being 5th choice CM behind KDB, Bernardo, Gundogan and Aouar, pushing him to play in other positions like LW where he isnt as good.
I think even Garcia will consider himself deluded if he thinks he's going to take the mantle as a starting CB at 19 years old in one of the best squads in football. Even as a 4th choice he would get plenty of game time, if he enters next season as our 3rd choice he's laughing.
Foden has had Pep gushing over him for two seasons saying he's the heir to Silva. Going out and buying another player to play in his position when we already have multiple other options (and other academy talents ready to take up a back up role) would be so ridiculous after all the things Pep's said about him.
Last edited:
Most posters were wanking themselves into a cross-eyed abyss last summer in the hope we would sign De Ligt. The stand out traits to Garcia's game are his ability to read play, sniff out danger early and communication; all those which would usually be aimed at younger players to improve upon, especially defenders.
De Ligt has been incredible since the turn of the year.
Almost like he's a world class defender who just needed a couple of months to get used to a new country/league/coach.
richards30
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 20 May 2009
- Messages
- 31,779
It would be a hell of a statement of intent to get this done early.
No way it will be anywhere close to €90m imo. We definitely need Koulibaly though! Hope we get him ASAP!
Some journalist on twitter is claiming its €72 mill up front with €15 mill in possible add ons and his medical will be next week.
Got the link broski?Some journalist on twitter is claiming its €72 mill up front with €15 mill in possible add ons and his medical will be next week.