Kalvin Phillips

[jim tolmies perm]

This is the guy who gets all the early team news every week

We really shouldn't be helping these cunts....ever

 

[Vester]

This is the guy who gets all the early team news every week

I see no point in LOANING Kalvin to a direct rival in the league. We cant be that desperate for money we are willing to help our rivals just to not pay his salary. If they want him they would have to buy him.

 

[JWCH-99]

Surely no loan to the scousers though, that wouldn’t make any sense?

Maybe with a buy option?

 

[Tugay One Cup]

I can see us going for a proper 4231 this season with Lillo back and the signings of Kovacic and Nunes.

If that's the case then I'm not too worried about replacing Phillips if he leaves. Still feel like we're short on numbers though.

 

[Burtonblue]

This is the guy who gets all the early team news every week

Liverpool!
I wouldn’t give those fuckers Mangala let alone Phillips.
Sod’s law he’ll do a job for them.

 

[Vester]

Maybe with a buy option?

A buy option has no upside whatsoever to us, only to the club that has the option.

 

[5 Hit Gibbon]

I see no point in LOANING Kalvin to a direct rival in the league. We cant be that desperate for money we are willing to help our rivals just to not pay his salary. If they want him they would have to buy him.

Not really "helping" our rivals though are we? He's been bobbins for us.

I don't see them as serious rivals this year either. (despite their miracle on Tyneside at the weekend!)

 

[Ric]

I can see us going for a proper 4231 this season with Lillo back and the signings of Kovacic and Nunes.

If that's the case then I'm not too worried about replacing Phillips if he leaves. Still feel like we're short on numbers though.

Ironically that would probably be the formation that would suit Phillips best.

 

[sd33]

honestly just sell him,pep doesnt care about him and will not use him next year when he comes back from loan

 

[Keeper!]

This is the guy who gets all the early team news every week

 

[5 Hit Gibbon]

This is the guy who gets all the early team news every week

Let's hope he does go somewhere before the window closes. He clearly isn't in our plans and is adding no value.

 

[Keeper!]

I see no point in LOANING Kalvin to a direct rival in the league. We cant be that desperate for money we are willing to help our rivals just to not pay his salary. If they want him they would have to buy him.

For any of our normal players I would agree 100% but for Kalvin Phillips?

It would be the perfect end to a very successful window.

 

[LangleyBlue1970]

He’s not even being talked about on their Liverpool transfers thread on RAWK.

 

[Tugay One Cup]

Ironically that would probably be the formation that would suit Phillips best.

I thought that as I typed it. Would have been interesting to see if his performances would have been better but I think that ship has fully sailed.

 

[Protein Junkie]

This is the guy who gets all the early team news every week

Got his info from Tront as he sees things others don’t.

 

[JWCH-99]

A buy option has no upside whatsoever to us, only to the club that has the option.

Obligation I meant sorry

 

[balotelli's back pocket]

Loaning him to the scousers when we know they have the money to buy him is just stupid IMO.

 

[JWCH-99]

I can see us going for a proper 4231 this season with Lillo back and the signings of Kovacic and Nunes.

If that's the case then I'm not too worried about replacing Phillips if he leaves. Still feel like we're short on numbers though.

Although it feels that way we currently have 22 players, which is the exact number we’ve had for the last 5 seasons (in which we’ve won 4 prems- to me that’s not coincidence

 

[manimanc]

I see no point in LOANING Kalvin to a direct rival in the league. We cant be that desperate for money we are willing to help our rivals just to not pay his salary. If they want him they would have to buy him.

Liverpool are not a direct rival. Not anymore.

 

[Vester]

For any of our normal players I would agree 100% but for Kalvin Phillips?

It would be the perfect end to a very successful window.

Unless he would fit in their system and look decent, then it would be an absolutely awful piece of business. Why risk helping our rivals just to save a small amount, we are not poor. Very little upside and a big downside. They just offered 115m for Caicedo, they can afford to buy Phillips. We should not be doing them any favors.