Kalvin Phillips

Now, I wished Phillips well in his attempt to make it at City and, unfortunately, it's not turned out at all for him.

With that said, unless someone can post criticisms he's had of our club and or fans, I don't understand the vitriol he's getting from so-called 'Blues' for a player that's still one of us.

Like I said, unless he's said something detrimental towards us, you should be ashamed of yourselves for this barrage of insults on a kid that has suffered a lack of confidence that could easily lead to depression.
 
Cannot believe how his career has sunk since he joined us as he is clearly a good player but he must have run over a black cat as his luck is totally out.
 
He needs to drop down a league or two, to give himself a chance at rebuilding his confidence and form, If that fails then he needs to change career.
 
Paul1970 said:
Cannot believe how his career has sunk since he joined us as he is clearly a good player but he must have run over a black cat as his luck is totally out.
Click to expand...

Is he clearly a good player?

He's had one decent season in the Premier League. His second season with Leeds was mostly injuries and mediocre performances, then he joined us and did nothing. Before that one decent season he was a championship player. You could really say all this about Patrick Bamford, he had one good season too. I don't see Champions League teams wanting him.

There's also the myth he had a great euros, which isn't true either. He was OK against the teams we should beat and was anonymous in the latter stages. Something I pointed out on here even before he signed him.

I really just think his level is around where he's mostly been, somewhere between championship and lower PL level. Couldn't understand the signing when it occurred.

But obviously people at the club saw something in him, these are people who have forgotten more than we will ever know so you have to trust them. I just don't know what they were seeing. Seems Pep sussed out quite quickly he wasn't much good though, or at least not good enough for us.

This isn't having a dig at the lad though, just an observation. You can't be something you're not and he's not the level of player to be playing at our level. There's no shame in that, very few are.
 
Crooked_rain said:
Is he clearly a good player?

He's had one decent season in the Premier League. His second season with Leeds was mostly injuries and mediocre performances, then he joined us and did nothing. Before that one decent season he was a championship player. You could really say all this about Patrick Bamford, he had one good season too. I don't see Champions League teams wanting him.

There's also the myth he had a great euros, which isn't true either. He was OK against the teams we should beat and was anonymous in the latter stages. Something I pointed out on here even before he signed him.

I really just think his level is around where he's mostly been, somewhere between championship and lower PL level. Couldn't understand the signing when it occurred.

But obviously people at the club saw something in him, these are people who have forgotten more than we will ever know so you have to trust them. I just don't know what they were seeing. Seems Pep sussed out quite quickly he wasn't much good though, or at least not good enough for us.

This isn't having a dig at the lad though, just an observation. You can't be something you're not and he's not the level of player to be playing at our level. There's no shame in that, very few are.
Click to expand...
Good post mate and yes it’s opened my eyes abit more
 
Crooked_rain said:
Is he clearly a good player?

He's had one decent season in the Premier League. His second season with Leeds was mostly injuries and mediocre performances, then he joined us and did nothing. Before that one decent season he was a championship player. You could really say all this about Patrick Bamford, he had one good season too. I don't see Champions League teams wanting him.

There's also the myth he had a great euros, which isn't true either. He was OK against the teams we should beat and was anonymous in the latter stages. Something I pointed out on here even before he signed him.

I really just think his level is around where he's mostly been, somewhere between championship and lower PL level. Couldn't understand the signing when it occurred.

But obviously people at the club saw something in him, these are people who have forgotten more than we will ever know so you have to trust them. I just don't know what they were seeing. Seems Pep sussed out quite quickly he wasn't much good though, or at least not good enough for us.

This isn't having a dig at the lad though, just an observation. You can't be something you're not and he's not the level of player to be playing at our level. There's no shame in that, very few are.
Click to expand...
I am still amazed we signed him and agree with all the above.
 
I think he's eventually going to go down as our worst signing ever, pound for pound. The guys usually thrown into this bracket often have contributed something, but we're prone to hyberbole. I honestly can't remember Kalvin playing a single decent game in his limited minutes here.
 
I suspect there aren't many places who will take a player on his wages on loan next year, Leeds being the only option I think.

We may just have to accept him being a squad player over the next few years, almost like Scot Carson, just be a happy fella in training, and if ever needed, atleast try to be useful.
 
WallyA said:
I suspect there aren't many places who will take a player on his wages on loan next year, Leeds being the only option I think.

We may just have to accept him being a squad player over the next few years, almost like Scot Carson, just be a happy fella in training, and if ever needed, atleast try to be useful.
Click to expand...
Not a chance he is anywhere near our club next season, he would be freed before that option.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top