You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Kompany red card and appeal SUCCESSFUL
- Thread starter SuperYaya
- Start date
lionheart
Well-Known Member
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
Apparently Gary Neville, Roy Kean and Rio Ferdinand have been summoned to appear as expert witnesses.alib said:ancoats said:we should win the a appeal if you look at the video its clear that jack wilshere slips well before kompany made the tackle and does not even touch wilshere and gets the ball first
ah but the independent appeal tribunal conisists of Gill , Crerand and Macari
citytill1die84
Well-Known Member
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
Lol it's worth a try.
alib said:citytill1die84 said:Have a feeling we won't appeal.
lol
within seconds of you saying that it's confirmed we have appealed!!!!
Lol it's worth a try.
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
in that case kompany will end up with a 12 month ban and the premier league taken off man city and rub out of Premier League record books
lionheart said:Apparently Gary Neville, Roy Kean and Rio Ferdinand have been summoned to appear as expert witnesses.alib said:ancoats said:we should win the a appeal if you look at the video its clear that jack wilshere slips well before kompany made the tackle and does not even touch wilshere and gets the ball first
ah but the independent appeal tribunal conisists of Gill , Crerand and Macari
in that case kompany will end up with a 12 month ban and the premier league taken off man city and rub out of Premier League record books
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
Not seen it mentioned btw but when is the decision made?
I don't think a tribunal would use a photo as evidence in an appeal as they can easily be edited to suit. There's plenty of video camera angles to choose from though.Trollsmoan said:The photo is all the evidence yer need, either remove sliding tackling altogether or just hand the title to cartel at the start of the season!
Not seen it mentioned btw but when is the decision made?
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
It's so pathetic. How are you supposed to make a tackle in a full blooded contact sport, running at full tilt without taking your feet off the floor at some point? I bet for every running tackle in the PL this weekend you could find a photo of it where the tacklers feet were off the ground.
It's so pathetic. How are you supposed to make a tackle in a full blooded contact sport, running at full tilt without taking your feet off the floor at some point? I bet for every running tackle in the PL this weekend you could find a photo of it where the tacklers feet were off the ground.
sam-caddick
Well-Known Member
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
Just said on SSN that if the appeal is unsuccessful Kompany will miss 4 games instead of 3.
The club are taking a huge risk with the thought he could potentially be out for Liverpool.
Just said on SSN that if the appeal is unsuccessful Kompany will miss 4 games instead of 3.
The club are taking a huge risk with the thought he could potentially be out for Liverpool.
SWP's back
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 29 Jun 2009
- Messages
- 89,078
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
SSN are incorrect on this.sam-caddick said:Just said on SSN that if the appeal is unsuccessful Kompany will miss 4 games instead of 3.
The club are taking a huge risk with the thought he could potentially be out for Liverpool.
vonksbignose
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 1 Sep 2008
- Messages
- 1,676
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
No he won't!
It's only if the appeal is deemed as being "frivolous" that they will consider adding a 4th match onto the ban.
There is no way on earth, even if we don't win the appeal, that this appeal could be deemed as being frivolous.
Stop watching Sky!
sam-caddick said:Just said on SSN that if the appeal is unsuccessful Kompany will miss 4 games instead of 3.
The club are taking a huge risk with the thought he could potentially be out for Liverpool.
No he won't!
It's only if the appeal is deemed as being "frivolous" that they will consider adding a 4th match onto the ban.
There is no way on earth, even if we don't win the appeal, that this appeal could be deemed as being frivolous.
Stop watching Sky!