I agree. That front 3 formation is incredibly physically demanding. There's no chance that we could expect the same front 3 to play all of the CL games nearly all of the PL games and their international commitments. That's not even taking into account the domestic cup games.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Kylian Mbappe
- Thread starter domalino
- Start date
- Status
- Not open for further replies.
I agree. That front 3 formation is incredibly physically demanding. There's no chance that we could expect the same front 3 to play all of the CL games nearly all of the PL games and their international commitments. That's not even taking into account the domestic cup games.
Whoever is saying Attack is not a problem, Liverpool,Chelsea & Arsenal scored more goals than us so far this season.
Yup. Pretty much in all of Peps press conferences he mentions how we're not clinical enough. I'll be surprised if we don't get at least 2 strikers (assuming aguero's gonna leave)
Gareth Barry Conlon
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 5 Sep 2014
- Messages
- 15,946
I agree. That front 3 formation is incredibly physically demanding. There's no chance that we could expect the same front 3 to play all of the CL games nearly all of the PL games and their international commitments. That's not even taking into account the domestic cup games.
However we have Jesus to come back in and Nacho could be used more often as striker or on the left. When all are fit we are fine and that is assuming the clearout of Navas and Nolito happens. Diaz and Sancho woll come into the equation at some point as well.
Than Mbappe?dele alli has more league goals this season doesn't he?
2 more, but he's played over twice the number of minutes.
In fact Mbappe has more goals and assists in all competitions in just over half the amount of time on the pitch as Dele Alli.
If we were to sell Aguero for a large sum, i'd be in favour of going for Mbappe, it'd end up a net cost of 20m or something for possibly the best young talent of a generation.
But, if we keep Aguero i think Mbappe is too much for this Summer.
Tevez City
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 9 May 2010
- Messages
- 15,171
Sometimes its now or never.
So are you saying we should save or money and. Keep Kelechi?Mbappe - STRIKER, 980minutes(11 starts), 12 goals, 5 assists(17 chances created), 74% pass accuracy, 9 take-ons, 6 headers won, 3 tackles, 1 interception, 3 clearances
Iheanacho - STRIKER, 1238minutes(12 starts), 12 goals, 4 assists(27 chances created), 76% pass accuracy, 20 take-ons, 18 headers won, 16 tackles, 3 interceptions, 8 clearances
By the way are those Kelechi's stats from when he was 18?
BlueDeadHead
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 26 Jul 2014
- Messages
- 2,999
Mbappe - STRIKER, 980minutes(11 starts), 12 goals, 5 assists(17 chances created), 74% pass accuracy, 9 take-ons, 6 headers won, 3 tackles, 1 interception, 3 clearances
Iheanacho - STRIKER, 1238minutes(12 starts), 12 goals, 4 assists(27 chances created), 76% pass accuracy, 20 take-ons, 18 headers won, 16 tackles, 3 interceptions, 8 clearances
I was wondering when someone would point out to Tevez City that Sterling is not a striker.
Tevez City
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 9 May 2010
- Messages
- 15,171
I was wondering when someone would point out to Tevez City that Sterling is not a striker.
Sterling is playing as a right forward in 4-3-3
Mbappe is not playing Centre forward, they have Falcao filling this position.
Metalartin
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 15 Jul 2015
- Messages
- 12,442
Great stat, should temper some of the over the top hype for Mbappé. If we could have got him for £40m great, any more than that(and it will be much more than that now) and we'd be paying far too much of a premium on the hype alone, he's obviously got something about him but lets stop pretending we have a crystal ball or that anything is guaranteed in this game, otherwise buying young players would not be a risk(all big clubs would have their Messi story) when everyone knows it's hit and miss.Mbappe - STRIKER, 980minutes(11 starts), 12 goals, 5 assists(17 chances created), 74% pass accuracy, 9 take-ons, 6 headers won, 3 tackles, 1 interception, 3 clearances
Iheanacho - STRIKER, 1238minutes(12 starts), 12 goals, 4 assists(27 chances created), 76% pass accuracy, 20 take-ons, 18 headers won, 16 tackles, 3 interceptions, 8 clearances
I also think if Jesus was still fit with the way he started his stats would be better than Mbappés at a higher level than Ligue1 right now. Stats are overused by clubs and agents to bump up prices lets not encourage it, Mbappé is a very good player advanced for his age but just because he has better stats than Henry at the same age now it's absolutely NOT a guarantee that his stats will finish up that way. He's flavour of the month right now because he did well in the champions league against us let's remember the same hype overload happened when Rashford left Demichelis for dust, ageing defenders can make anyone with pace look great at times. We didn't do the same with Iheanacho, even when his stats were incredible were we saying best in Europe, definite shoe in for the Ballon d'Or? No because we're not looking to make money off him, we'd want to keep the pressure off even if we thought that to be the case because he'll be staying at our club not sold on at any point if he reaches those heights.
Since the price is so high on him already, we'd not even be saving any money buying him early and we're not the only club with our eye on him either lets not fool ourselves(it's not a case of buying him before anyone else notices him they are already in for him if he's available). There's not much reason to take such a high gamble on him as it stands, may as well wait it out with him he'll stay where his is for now and if he turns out to be half as good as he's being hyped up to be he'll be worth his current asking price some day.
Last edited:
Do you think we tried to sign him last summer based on this seasons stats?Great stat, should temper some of the over the top hype for Mbappé. If we could have got him for £40m great, any more than that(and it will be much more than that now) and we'd be paying far too much of a premium on the hype alone, he's obviously got something about him but lets stop pretending we have a crystal ball or that anything is guaranteed in this game, otherwise buying young players would not be a risk(all big clubs would have their Messi story) when everyone knows it's hit and miss.
I also think if Jesus was still fit with the way he started his stats would be better than Mbappés at a higher level than Ligue1 right now. Stats are overused by clubs and agents to bump up prices lets not encourage it, Mbappé is a very good player advanced for his age but just because he has better stats than Henry at the same age now it's absolutely NOT a guarantee that his stats will finish up that way. He's flavour of the month right now because he did well in the champions league against us let's remember the same hype overload happened when Rashford left Demichelis for dust, ageing defenders can make anyone with pace look great at times. We didn't do the same with Iheanacho, even when his stats were incredible were we saying best in Europe, definite shoe in for the Ballon d'Or? No because we're not looking to make money off him, we'd want to keep the pressure off even if we thought that to be the case because he'll be staying at our club not sold on at any point if he reaches those heights.
Metalartin
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 15 Jul 2015
- Messages
- 12,442
We were willing to take a gamble then of £40m he was already considered a talent, it's not really changed. How much could change in so little time and so few games? We had a small window before the hype got too great where we would be saving a lot of money had they gone for it but they declined, now we'd be paying much more money, saving nothing and so an even bigger financial risk. So let me play your game, so you think because we offered £40m a season ago then surely we have to go twice that now if we were willing to pay that? Is that how it works?Do you think we tried to sign him last summer based on this seasons stats?
I added another paragraph btw which sums it up, we might as well wait a while(they're not selling this season IMO and they will make the maximum amount when he does go you can be sure of that, we'll be saving nothing rushing in) since the price is so high lets make sure he lives up to the hype and we aren't the only club interested even now so don't get your hopes up too high.
Last edited:
Think he will stay at Monaco for another season.
Good for both the player and the club. Mbappe can continue to prove himself and play more games. He will also want to stay because going to a new club/country is a big risk at such as young age especially with the World Cup coming up next summer. He will be a guaranteed starting there as well. Monaco will also want to keep him as his value will continue to grow and I doubt such a young player will force a move to the club that gave him everything.
Think he will stay and have a another great season next year. Well bring his form into the World Cup where he will continue to score goals and really announce himself on the biggest stage there is. His value will sky rocket and then when the World Cup is over, his favorite team Real Madrid will come in for him with a world record bid of 100m + and that is where he will go.
You read it here first.
Good for both the player and the club. Mbappe can continue to prove himself and play more games. He will also want to stay because going to a new club/country is a big risk at such as young age especially with the World Cup coming up next summer. He will be a guaranteed starting there as well. Monaco will also want to keep him as his value will continue to grow and I doubt such a young player will force a move to the club that gave him everything.
Think he will stay and have a another great season next year. Well bring his form into the World Cup where he will continue to score goals and really announce himself on the biggest stage there is. His value will sky rocket and then when the World Cup is over, his favorite team Real Madrid will come in for him with a world record bid of 100m + and that is where he will go.
You read it here first.
Gundogan's Moustache
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 15 Jan 2014
- Messages
- 4,543
Surely it was Mbappe or Jesus last summer ? Can't see this happening even if Aguero does leave as having 3 Strikers the age of 18,19,20 is surely too risky
BlueDeadHead
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 26 Jul 2014
- Messages
- 2,999
Sterling is playing as a right forward in 4-3-3
Mbappe is not playing Centre forward, they have Falcao filling this position.
Sterling is not a striker.
Your missing my pointWe were willing to take a gamble then of £40m he was already considered a talent, it's not really changed. How much could change in so little time and so few games? We had a small window before the hype got too great where we would be saving a lot of money had they gone for it but they declined, now we'd be paying much more money, saving nothing and so an even bigger financial risk. So let me play your game, so you think because we offered £40m a season ago then surely we have to go twice that now if we were willing to pay that? Is that how it works?
I added another paragraph btw which sums it up, we might as well wait a while(they're not selling this season IMO and they will make the maximum amount when he does go you can be sure of that, we'll be saving nothing rushing in) since the price is so high lets make sure he's lives up to the hype and we aren't the only club interested even now so don't get your hopes up too high.
We're always looking for the next big star doesn't matter if we sign this lad or not we will keep looking and trying to sign one and then another and then another......
So that's why my hopes are high
Surely it was Mbappe or Jesus last summer ? Can't see this happening even if Aguero does leave as having 3 Strikers the age of 18,19,20 is surely too risky
Where's the risk?
Tevez City
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 9 May 2010
- Messages
- 15,171
Sterling is not a striker.
I know, but both of them are playing on the side of the 4-3-3 formation.
Metalartin
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 15 Jul 2015
- Messages
- 12,442
True but this season should be all about sorting out our ageing defence, some high quality attacking fullbacks will do so much more for our team right now for me. I was thinking about this when we played Spurs, compared to most of the top 6 they all seem to have the modern attacking fullbacks, Zaba and Kolarov are somewhat attack minded but they are ageing now(if Pep got them when they were younger he could have turned them into what we need) Sagna and Clichy are more traditional fullbacks who aren't as comfortable in attack, it's been long overdue. If we strengthen where we need to this summer and he's available next summer and still doing the business and nobody else has stolen the limelight we can start getting serious about it.Your missing my point
We're always looking for the next big star doesn't matter if we sign this lad or not we will keep looking and trying to sign one and then another and then another......
So that's why my hopes are high
Last edited:
citizen_maine
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 29 May 2011
- Messages
- 18,302
True but this season should be all about sorting out our ageing defense, some high quality attacking fullbacks will do so much more for our team right now for me. If we strengthen where we need to this summer and he's available next summer and still doing the business and nobody else has stolen the limelight we can start getting serious about it.
It doesn't have to be ALL about sorting the defence
- Status
- Not open for further replies.