Corky said:
3 seasons, 2 in the second division. Didn't Richard Edgehill get in the England squad at a younger age and Richards?
How he could have been is just speculation and sentiment, and no one knows.
Of course he was a good player, but in his book he could sense a injury coming, would it only have been a matter of time anyway? Again, no one really knows.
I'm not convinced you're making much of a case. None of us knows what the future may hold? Well, duh!
That infinite possibilities exist, from Lakey accidentally driving his car into a ravine in Boggart Hole Clough to tearing his cruciates getting out of bed, doesn't prevent us from drawing reasonably informed conclusions in respect of his likely career path, based on an assessment of the abilities he had demonstrated in those three years, does it?
He was already captain of Manchester City and he'd been called into the provisional 1990 World Cup squad. The guy oozed class as a footballer, and likening him to Edgy or Micah because they also made England squads at a young age isn't a particularly compelling argument. Geoff Thomas and Paul Gascoigne both played for England, yet in terms of ability and footballing sophistication one was a Jaguar and the other was a Trabant.
No, nobody can state anything with 100% certainty, but it's not unreasonable to look back at Paul Lake's performance levels at City and believe that he was one of the best we've ever had, and would have improved further with age.