My mind is not made up on Hughes - he may indeed be out of his depth. Only time will tell -of which he may not have much left.RobbieBrewer said:Robbo. said:That was Sven who put him there
The quote you've highlighted was about Elano.We need ALL our players-especially the ones who can turn a game.The skill is to know how to use and manage them.MH does not appear to posess those skills.
And yes-Sven did put Richards at CB.The point is he looked ten times the player he does now.
So why is that?
But the difference between Richards last year and this may have nothing to do with Hughes.
Consider the situation at Everton. Last year, Lescott was generally superb, while Jagielka was regarded by many Evertonians as a waste of money. The earlier part of this season seemed to have reversed this. Lescott has generally been poor, while Jagielka is regarded by many Evertonians as the player of the season. Recently, Lescott has begun to show something of last season's form.
Everton have had the same manager throughout.
Even the best players go through periods of bad form.
It is usually pretty absurd to put all the blame for a situation on EITHER the manager OR the players. Usually both have some responsibility - as do others. Who precisely ought to receive the most flak for particular failures is known only to real insiders, and to God. I doubt if we have either on this forum.