Man City vs Reading - Post Match Discussion

This was a joke. No pace ,no penetration. Does Mancini not see what was clearly their game plan from kick off. Our forwards don't look like they have a goal in them. Having played lots of games where we trained with 5 defenders against 7 attackers its easy when they have no width. Until we can get behind defences and cut it back to an attacker running in then we will see more of the same. Pace on the wing unsettles defenders and creates space for attackers.
 
Just saw McDermott on Final Score. Not a happy bunny. He's convinced that they should have had a penalty and that the goal was a foul by Barry. However; both Kevin Kilbane and, unbelievably given his antagonism towards us in the past, Steve Claridge both said that they thought the goal was okay and that Barry simply wanted to win the ball more than Shorey did. Didn't see the goal as I was out up until 20 minutes ago, so I can't comment on the goal.
 
Yaya seemed to stroll casually around the field today. Sergio coming back to his best. Nasty was impeccable. Finally I thought Rekik did well for a first game, on those odd occasions when they actually passed him the ball.

Damn it's hard to break down 10-1 sometimes.

Enjoy your Xmas everyone!
 
Brian McDermott moaning like fuck on Sky; not sure what his point is, if you set your team up to play like he did, you shouldn't be surprised if you lose.
 
jimharri said:
Just saw McDermott on Final Score. Not as happy bunny. He's convinced that they should have had a penalty and that the goal was a foul by Barry. However; both Kevin Kilbane and, unbelievably given his antagonism towards us in the past, Steve Claridge both said that the thought the goal was okay and that Barry simply wanted to win the ball more than Shorey did. Didn't see the goal as I was out up until 20 minutes ago, so I can't comment on the goal.
I'm assuming the penalty he's referring to is the Rekik-Tabb one, if so, he can jog on.

Solid defending.

As for the goal they summed it up well, Shorey didn't wish to play the ball and Baz just wanted it more.
 
The Man With The Stick said:
Anyone else clock Milners inch perfect ball to Dzeko from right back???
who needs a deep lying playmaker in Jan? Not us i reckon... get him in the middle!

Exactly, he deserve credit for the goal also.
 
jimharri said:
Just saw McDermott on Final Score. Not a happy bunny. He's convinced that they should have had a penalty and that the goal was a foul by Barry. However; both Kevin Kilbane and, unbelievably given his antagonism towards us in the past, Steve Claridge both said that they thought the goal was okay and that Barry simply wanted to win the ball more than Shorey did. Didn't see the goal as I was out up until 20 minutes ago, so I can't comment on the goal.

I thought there was a possible handball against Nastasic in the penalty area.

He withdraw his arm but looked to me it was after it hit him.
 
So many blocks and deflections from Reading. You'd have expected at least one of them to deflect in. Then again, I was also expecting to see Pogrebnyak get a yellow at some point. Phew. Let off the embarrassment hook today!
 
jimharri said:
Just saw McDermott on Final Score. Not a happy bunny. He's convinced that they should have had a penalty and that the goal was a foul by Barry. However; both Kevin Kilbane and, unbelievably given his antagonism towards us in the past, Steve Claridge both said that they thought the goal was okay and that Barry simply wanted to win the ball more than Shorey did. Didn't see the goal as I was out up until 20 minutes ago, so I can't comment on the goal.

Definitely no foul by Barry, he was perfectly entitled to challenge for that ball.
 
Sergio for me needs a rest he is not 100%
the injury he picked up early season knock something out of him or he still not match fit
 
jimharri said:
Didn't see the goal as I was out up until 20 minutes ago, so I can't comment on the goal.

I've seen fouls given in those circumstances, but Shorey made no attempt to challenge for the ball and just got barged out of the way by Barry as he headed it. If anything, it was a foul by Shorey for backing in.
 
unlikelyfan19 said:
To those saying we looked woeful, really? Honest question. We were up their a$$es for 90+ minutes. Some days its just tough to put the ball in the net. It's the nature of the game. If you want perfection don't waste your time. I thought Silva looked great, Nastasic is going to be great, Zab does what he does, Aguero looks to be on point and in great form, sometimes it's just hard to score. We did what champions are supposed to do today, great result.

This ^
 
pudge said:
I wanted Barry off for Dzeko because I thought Garcia was playing better..

Probably why I've never gone into football management.

i seem to remember everyone calling for Garcia to stay on the pitch 'for his heading ability'








:)
 
adrianr said:
I can barely believe that game. We should have scored in the first half, couple of "How the fuck?!" chances in the second, and still came 90 seconds away from pretty much burying our league hopes until Barry of all people gets the winner. A few points in semi rant form.

Tevez and Aguero start again, we win again, and again it's pretty much nothing to do with either of them. Fuck knows how that works but keep starting them anyway.

Rekik had a fair enough game, but we heavily rely on our fullbacks for attacking and he's clearly not there yet (as he's supposed to be a centre back). Players didn't look like they trusted him even if he was in ok positions.

Some really nice passes of play THROUGH THE MIDDLE (argh!!) of a 9 man Reading built wall, carved out some fair chances but again everyone too fucking scared to shoot (One point early ish, Aguero pulled the ball back to Tevez who should have lamped it, but for some reason we still felt the need to play 5 more passes before losing possession). If Silva shot nearly half the amount of times he tries to play perfect through balls he'd probably be the leagues joint top scorer.

Yaya was often crap. Some really bad passing from him and letting Macanuff of all people skin you and nearly draw a penalty should be punishable by a night in the stocks.

Barry/Garcia wasn't nearly as bad as it could have been, but they still don't offer enough different to one another to be playing at the same time. Garcia looked like he's still on the up though, a big positive. Would like to see some more aerial threat from him ala Stoke, he has it in him. It still doesn't look as good as Barry/Milner (superb to see him even get on the pitch today), but I'm guessing he wasn't fit enough yet, so that's fair doos.

A new back line kept a clean sheet, and a pretty convincing one. Reading had a couple of half good header chances but never properly cut us open on the break. Whatever the commentators were on trying to say Rekik gave away a penalty I want some of. Against a side that put 3 past the Rags, a few past Arsenal over a few games, that's good going.

I may have to admit that we're a better side with Nasri in it than without.

And we weren't as good as we were against Newcastle in that first half. We really need to be more direct sometimes because we seem to love putting ourselves in a position of nearly getting it right in the ass. If we played like the first half against Newcastle (at least the bit when Nasri was on) we'd walk it. We clearly can, so fucking do!

Realistically it was a bit of a cobbled together team, but we were playing Reading, and that cobbled together team still had Sergio Aguero, Carlos Tevez, David Silva and Yaya Toure in it. They're bottom of the league for a reason. Again, a very late goal has saved some very awkward questions. I don't expect us to roll everyone 5-0, but we could make our lives a lot easier if we didn't persist in trying to take 30 touches in the 6 yard box before someone finally puts their fucking foot through it.

Well there it is for ya. Need Samir on the field to complete the foursome. Makes a huge difference as he is the one who keeps the ball moving, combines with other players, and makes runs. After all that more space opens up for the others.

Good analysis. Agree with pretty much all of it. I think Yaya was solid enough. I just think our expectations of him are so high. I mean we controlled the middle quite well, but we do need him to add that aggressive attacking side, which he has struggled to come up with as of late.
 
The only pleasing aspect of that performance is we didn't give up the ghost when it was looking not going our way. It is still 3 points.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top