Mancini

Status
Not open for further replies.
St Helens Blue (Exiled) said:
Exeter Blue I am here said:
St Helens Blue (Exiled) said:
Fuck it-lets just go back to the Alan Ball,Stuart Pearce days of utter mediocracy and winning jack shit hey because Mancini has made a few mistakes in europe and against the blue dippers.

Mancini gets unwarranted abuse on here. I know many a rag who hopes he does get the chop because they know he has rattled Fergie and they think with a little more backing he will come strong again next year.
This year hasn't exactly been a disaster has it?

I would say if a straw poll was taken re Mancini the outers would be approx 10% and the inners 90%

And I would say you're talking out of your arse

And a fantastic arse it is..Ask my wife.

LOL. I'm sure tis a thing of rare beauty! Perhaps a saucy pic for the readers?!
 
BoyBlue_1985 said:
St Helens Blue (Exiled) said:
Paulmcfc2703 said:
Surely you can see that consistantly failing in the champions league and consistantly failing in those fixtures shows that he cannot adjust his game and once plan A is found out that's it he's had it.

I have highlighted the error..We have been in the champions league for all of 2 seasons..not 20 like the rags...How long did it take the rags to get out of the group stage??? We are not consistently failing,just having to failed for 2 seasons..Last year we were unlucky with 10pts..This yr was a fucking tough group and Dortmund/Madrid were always favourites to get through and they are still in the last 8.
patience is a virtue..Not many on here have it
1 season

It's also worth pointing out that they didn't even qualify for the group stages first time around.
 
Skashion said:
Lucky Toma said:
Some superb posts in here amongst the shite.

If you feel strongly that Mancini should go at the end of this term does anyone fancy putting together a piece for the Daisy Cutter about it?

If so get in touch via PM.
Get someone who will actually write about the subject this time. Last time didn't go so well.

That's a dig at BS Skash right?

You know what they say mate.....money where yer mouth is :)
 
The Champions League has been a disappointment - however that's down to the groups we've been drawn in!
I'd go as far as to say that I don't believe any of the English teams would have qualified from either of our groups.
 
Paulmcfc2703 said:
Tim of the Oak said:
St Helens Blue (Exiled) said:
Drawing at Liverpool is not a bad result,yes losing at Sunderland and Everton perenially is most annoying but do these 2 games per season and a lack of cl knockout football really warrant a change of manager 3yrs into a 5yr project.

I am also frustrated by results and performamces against these teams. For the sake of balance - Spurs, Arsenal and Chelsea were also bogey teams and we have done OK against them in the last year or two. That is we are 2nd in the league and Champions.
Lets be honest we were beating Chelsea and Arsenal at home when Hughes was here.

In the odd game at home but not on a regular basis. Wins away at Arsenal and Spurs had been very rare also.

The two plausible criticisms of Mancini are his poor CL record (a fact) and that he falls out with people - including doctors and some players. Some argue this shows a lack of adapatabiliy but Khaldoon and the Sheikh knew we needed a stong character to challange the Rags. Yes our leadership needs to be flexible and this was shown in Roberto's mind games that battered Fergie and the Rags last year - as well as making mugs out of that great institution - the British press. Off course we had given up on the league.

To most fans who go to the game and sing his name (but vlearly mot all) these are more than offset at the moment by the domestic trophies we are winning. If we don't improve in the CL then no doubt the City hierarchy will review but please mo knee jerk reactions. As others have said, we are 2nd in the league and going to Wembley so there is plenty still to go for.
 
BillyShears said:
Zin 'messiah' Zimmer said:
BillyShears said:
He's a great architect. Unless he needs to build a building with more than one floor.

Absolutely tragic the way some people brush aside Mancini's incompetence in Europe as some inconsequential thing which isn't at all important.

Out of interest BS, how many campaigns has the man had in Europe?? Genuinely interested

I'd say the club in itself is far to wet behind the ears, however there's no doubt in my mind he'll win a champions league trophy within the next 6/7 years, the only problem is it probably won't be here!!!! A manager of his ilk improves because of the motivation they take from failure, he's made many mistakes this year granted but for achieving the ultimate goal of winning the league he should be afforded another crack, IMO he'll win the league if still here next year!!!!

Honestly his record is average. He might be a relative novice, but just as City weren't prepared to wait for Mark Hughes how to figure out how to manage at the level they wanted at the time, I'm not sure they will wait for Mancini to grow into a top European manager.

I've also said quite a few times that he probably will win the CL one day. He's not a shit coach, far from it. He's a very good manager who's record of trophies speaks for itself. He's just not at that level required to make an impact both domestically and in Europe. This was proven at Inter, and has subsequently been proven at City so far.

Fiorentina
01/02 – Uefa Cup R3 (Beaten by Lille 3-0 on agg)

Lazio
02/03 – Uefa Cup SF (Beaten by Porto 4-1 on agg)
03/04 – CL Group Stage (Finished bottom with a W1 D2 L3 record)

Inter Milan
04/05 – CL QF (Beaten by AC Milan 3-0 on agg)
05/06 – CL QF (Beaten by Villarreal on away goals)
06/07 – CL R2 (Beaten by Valencia on away goals)
07/08 – CL R2 (Beaten by Liverpool 3-0 on agg)

Man City
10/11 – Europa League R16 (Beaten by Dinamo Kiev 2-1 on agg)
11/12 – CL Group Stage (Finished 3rd)
11/12 – Europa League (Beaten by Sporting Lisbon on away goals)
12/13 – CL Group Stage (Finished bottom of Group)

So that’s 11 European campaigns in total. The highlights are a Uefa Cup SF and 2x CL QF’s. Considering that he won Serie A 3x with Inter, he couldn’t get past the QF’s once. The following year, when Mourinho took over Inter, the starting line up in the final against Bayern had 6 players from Mancini’s era.

Mancini is by no means a bad manager, certainly on the Domestic front. But in Europe, his record says otherwise.
 
dario2739 said:
The Champions League has been a disappointment - however that's down to the groups we've been drawn in!
I'd go as far as to say that I don't believe any of the English teams would have qualified from either of our groups.
the thing is we didnt win a single game, we should of beaten ajax twice.
 
Prestwich_Blue said:
The cookie monster said:
Prestwich_Blue said:
Of the dozen or so I'll be going down to Wembley with I don't know one who doesn't have significant doubts about Mancini.
Yes but do they hate him p.b.
Do they call him a ****,clown,waste of space & stealing for a living?
You mean like many on here did with Hughes?

I don't believe they hate him and why should they after winning the PL and FA cup? But they think that he isn't good enough to take us to the next (and ultimate) level of regularly being in serious contention for the PL and CL.

PB....

I remember having a number of 'discussions' with you previously...
when we just missed out to Spurs for CL... you said we'll never win anything with RM...

then we won the Cup and qualified for CL... you said he still needs to be replaced as you 'Didn't believe he had the ability to take us to the next level' ...

then we won the Championship... but he still can't take us to the next level....

Eventually you will be right! :-)
 
Tim of the Oak said:
Paulmcfc2703 said:
Tim of the Oak said:
I am also frustrated by results and performamces against these teams. For the sake of balance - Spurs, Arsenal and Chelsea were also bogey teams and we have done OK against them in the last year or two. That is we are 2nd in the league and Champions.
Lets be honest we were beating Chelsea and Arsenal at home when Hughes was here.

In the odd game at home but not on a regular basis. Wins away at Arsenal and Spurs had been very rare also.

The two plausible criticisms of Mancini are his poor CL record (a fact) and that he falls out with people - including doctors and some players. Some argue this shows a lack of adapatabiliy but Khaldoon and the Sheikh knew we needed a stong character to challange the Rags. Yes our leadership needs to be flexible and this was shown in Roberto's mind games that battered Fergie and the Rags last year - as well as making mugs out of that great institution - the British press. Off course we had given up on the league.

To most fans who go to the game and sing his name (but vlearly mot all) these are more than offset at the moment by the domestic trophies we are winning. If we don't improve in the CL then no doubt the City hierarchy will review but please mo knee jerk reactions. As others have said, we are 2nd in the league and going to Wembley so there is plenty still to go for.
So you believe his continued failure to beat certain teams in the league which as more teams figure us out that number ever increases isn't a plausible criticism?
 
Grieffymcfcctid said:
dario2739 said:
The Champions League has been a disappointment - however that's down to the groups we've been drawn in!
I'd go as far as to say that I don't believe any of the English teams would have qualified from either of our groups.
the thing is we didnt win a single game, we should of beaten ajax twice.


And a scratch Dortmund.
 
Paulmcfc2703 said:
Tim of the Oak said:
Paulmcfc2703 said:
Lets be honest we were beating Chelsea and Arsenal at home when Hughes was here.

In the odd game at home but not on a regular basis. Wins away at Arsenal and Spurs had been very rare also.

The two plausible criticisms of Mancini are his poor CL record (a fact) and that he falls out with people - including doctors and some players. Some argue this shows a lack of adapatabiliy but Khaldoon and the Sheikh knew we needed a stong character to challange the Rags. Yes our leadership needs to be flexible and this was shown in Roberto's mind games that battered Fergie and the Rags last year - as well as making mugs out of that great institution - the British press. Off course we had given up on the league.

To most fans who go to the game and sing his name (but vlearly mot all) these are more than offset at the moment by the domestic trophies we are winning. If we don't improve in the CL then no doubt the City hierarchy will review but please mo knee jerk reactions. As others have said, we are 2nd in the league and going to Wembley so there is plenty still to go for.
So you believe his continued failure to beat certain teams in the league which as more teams figure us out that number ever increases isn't a plausible criticism?

maybe the players should be held a little more accountable? Everton and Sunderland are bogey teams.It does not justify sacking Mancini
 
BlueDejong said:
Manchester City are lining up Malaga manager Manuel Pellegrini as a potential replacement for Roberto Mancini according to El Pais.

<a class="postlink" href="http://deportes.elpais.com/deportes/2013/03/14/champions/1363288505_684925.html" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;">http://deportes.elpais.com/deportes/201 ... 84925.html</a>

What do you think ?

Get fucked! That's what I think!

Not an 'upgrade' on Mancini... and if the barca boys think so... then they should pack their bags as well!
 
St Helens Blue (Exiled) said:
Paulmcfc2703 said:
Tim of the Oak said:
In the odd game at home but not on a regular basis. Wins away at Arsenal and Spurs had been very rare also.

The two plausible criticisms of Mancini are his poor CL record (a fact) and that he falls out with people - including doctors and some players. Some argue this shows a lack of adapatabiliy but Khaldoon and the Sheikh knew we needed a stong character to challange the Rags. Yes our leadership needs to be flexible and this was shown in Roberto's mind games that battered Fergie and the Rags last year - as well as making mugs out of that great institution - the British press. Off course we had given up on the league.

To most fans who go to the game and sing his name (but vlearly mot all) these are more than offset at the moment by the domestic trophies we are winning. If we don't improve in the CL then no doubt the City hierarchy will review but please mo knee jerk reactions. As others have said, we are 2nd in the league and going to Wembley so there is plenty still to go for.
So you believe his continued failure to beat certain teams in the league which as more teams figure us out that number ever increases isn't a plausible criticism?

maybe the players should be held a little more accountable? Everton and Sunderland are bogey teams.It does not justify sacking Mancini
Course the players are partly to blame. But it starts at the top. Playing Everton away 4 times & Sunderland away 3 times and losing every time shows along with the CL Mancini is unable to adapt once he is found out. The same can be said for the draw each year at Stoke and Liverpool.
 
levets said:
BlueDejong said:
Manchester City are lining up Malaga manager Manuel Pellegrini as a potential replacement for Roberto Mancini according to El Pais.

<a class="postlink" href="http://deportes.elpais.com/deportes/2013/03/14/champions/1363288505_684925.html" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;">http://deportes.elpais.com/deportes/201 ... 84925.html</a>

What do you think ?

Get fucked! That's what I think!

Not an 'upgrade' on Mancini... and if the barca boys think so... then they should pack their bags as well!

This whole post just made me LOL
 
St Helens Blue (Exiled) said:
Paulmcfc2703 said:
Tim of the Oak said:
In the odd game at home but not on a regular basis. Wins away at Arsenal and Spurs had been very rare also.

The two plausible criticisms of Mancini are his poor CL record (a fact) and that he falls out with people - including doctors and some players. Some argue this shows a lack of adapatabiliy but Khaldoon and the Sheikh knew we needed a stong character to challange the Rags. Yes our leadership needs to be flexible and this was shown in Roberto's mind games that battered Fergie and the Rags last year - as well as making mugs out of that great institution - the British press. Off course we had given up on the league.

To most fans who go to the game and sing his name (but vlearly mot all) these are more than offset at the moment by the domestic trophies we are winning. If we don't improve in the CL then no doubt the City hierarchy will review but please mo knee jerk reactions. As others have said, we are 2nd in the league and going to Wembley so there is plenty still to go for.
So you believe his continued failure to beat certain teams in the league which as more teams figure us out that number ever increases isn't a plausible criticism?

maybe the players should be held a little more accountable? Everton and Sunderland are bogey teams.It does not justify sacking Mancini

I agree. We have missed a lot of chances in those Sunderland games and I am afraid that Joe has not distinguished himself in goals.

There is probably a combination of factors including player performances, missing key players and yes you can argue the Roberto hasn't got the best out of the 11 on the pitch every time. Not many managers do. Rags were calling for Baconface's head at the end of last season
 
levets said:
BlueDejong said:
Manchester City are lining up Malaga manager Manuel Pellegrini as a potential replacement for Roberto Mancini according to El Pais.

<a class="postlink" href="http://deportes.elpais.com/deportes/2013/03/14/champions/1363288505_684925.html" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;">http://deportes.elpais.com/deportes/201 ... 84925.html</a>

What do you think ?

Get fucked! That's what I think!

Not an 'upgrade' on Mancini... and if the barca boys think so... then they should pack their bags as well!

This really is hard to credit.
So it makes sense to replace the only manager of a Manchester club to win two trophies in his first three years with a man who spent £250 million on four players at Real and has won nothing?
Can anyone please explain,in laymans terms,exactly why this would be a good idea?
 
Disappointed Mancini still hasn't put anything out about the game, i'm a big fan of him but it would be nice if only for the fans to hear his take on the weekend.
 
levets said:
BlueDejong said:
Manchester City are lining up Malaga manager Manuel Pellegrini as a potential replacement for Roberto Mancini according to El Pais.

<a class="postlink" href="http://deportes.elpais.com/deportes/2013/03/14/champions/1363288505_684925.html" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;">http://deportes.elpais.com/deportes/201 ... 84925.html</a>

What do you think ?

Get fucked! That's what I think!

Not an 'upgrade' on Mancini... and if the barca boys think so... then they should pack their bags as well!
Get double fucked is what I think!
 
nijinsky's fetlocks said:
levets said:
BlueDejong said:
Manchester City are lining up Malaga manager Manuel Pellegrini as a potential replacement for Roberto Mancini according to El Pais.

<a class="postlink" href="http://deportes.elpais.com/deportes/2013/03/14/champions/1363288505_684925.html" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;">http://deportes.elpais.com/deportes/201 ... 84925.html</a>

What do you think ?

Get fucked! That's what I think!

Not an 'upgrade' on Mancini... and if the barca boys think so... then they should pack their bags as well!

This really is hard to credit.
So it makes sense to replace the only manager of a Manchester club to win two trophies in his first three years with a man who spent £250 million on four players at Real and has won nothing?
Can anyone please explain,in laymans terms,exactly why this would be a good idea?

As someone who believes there's better options out there than Mancini, I don't really understand this link either.

I know his style of play is highly thought of but, to me, this wouldn't be an "upgrade" as such.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top