Mancini

Status
Not open for further replies.
Dethred said:
smithy167 said:
Dethred said:
I actually don't think you get it. Managers are judged on what they accomplish with what they have.

If they were judged on trophies, there would be, at most, three or four incumbent managers each season. Now we know why your logic is so flawed, you have a totally backwards view of reality.
Managers at top clubs are judged on what they win no flawed logic, no reality bullshit thats how it is.

Ah, I see what you did there. Nice try in saving your irrational argument. You added "top" before "clubs". But your argument still is just as flawed, as Everton isn't a "top club", therefore you cannot compare the winners medals of Moyes and Mancini.

Again:



If a 1000 quid second hand Fiesta can consistently beat a Ferrari Enzo around a circuit, you need to look at whose driving.


what if it uses NOS?
 
Dethred said:
smithy167 said:
Dethred said:
I actually don't think you get it. Managers are judged on what they accomplish with what they have.

If they were judged on trophies, there would be, at most, three or four incumbent managers each season. Now we know why your logic is so flawed, you have a totally backwards view of reality.
Managers at top clubs are judged on what they win no flawed logic, no reality bullshit thats how it is.

Ah, I see what you did there. Nice try in saving your irrational argument. You added "top" before "clubs". But your argument still is just as flawed, as Everton isn't a "top club", therefore you cannot compare the winners medals of Moyes and Mancini.

Again:



If a 1000 quid second hand Fiesta can consistently beat a Ferrari Enzo around a circuit, you need to look at whose driving.

Let me spell out for you you thick twat managers at top clubs like us are judged on trophies won not individual games, Trophies.
 
No point in complaining about lack of quality players bought in. You cant tell me he had nothing to do with garcia, rodwell and sinclair coming in. Besides even if he did bring in the players he wants there's enough evidence to say he'd still make diabolical team selections. For me that performance today showed he hasn't improved as a coach. As for Kidd and platt im still confused on what they actually do for the club.
 
Balotelli on Mancini vs. Mourinho: "Who do I prefer between Mancini and Mourinho? As a person Mancini, in football terms Mourinho."

just thought i'd share.
 
smithy167 said:
Dethred said:
smithy167 said:
Managers at top clubs are judged on what they win no flawed logic, no reality bullshit thats how it is.

Ah, I see what you did there. Nice try in saving your irrational argument. You added "top" before "clubs". But your argument still is just as flawed, as Everton isn't a "top club", therefore you cannot compare the winners medals of Moyes and Mancini.

Again:



If a 1000 quid second hand Fiesta can consistently beat a Ferrari Enzo around a circuit, you need to look at whose driving.

Let me spell out for you you thick twat managers at top clubs like us are judged on trophies won not individual games, Trophies.

Less of the abuse. Does your arguments no good.

LoveCity, if that quote is real then it's going to hurt a lot of feelings.
 
Blue Heaven said:
smithy167 said:
BillyShears said:
Mancini left St Mary's without talking to a single player or going in the dressing room. That's tragic.
Prove it then.

No, you prove him wrong, and your sourcing for your info had better be impeccable.

Yeah because that makes sense, make the guy who laughs of silly rumours with no evidence what so ever prove himself... your world must be so much fun..
 
Dethred said:
smithy167 said:
Dethred said:
I actually don't think you get it. Managers are judged on what they accomplish with what they have.

If they were judged on trophies, there would be, at most, three or four incumbent managers each season. Now we know why your logic is so flawed, you have a totally backwards view of reality.
Managers at top clubs are judged on what they win no flawed logic, no reality bullshit thats how it is.

Ah, I see what you did there. Nice try in saving your irrational argument. You added "top" before "clubs". But your argument still is just as flawed, as Everton isn't a "top club", therefore you cannot compare the winners medals of Moyes and Mancini.

Again:



If a 1000 quid second hand Fiesta can consistently beat a Ferrari Enzo around a circuit, you need to look at whose driving.


What the fuck is this shite ?? so flawed its stupid.
 
Pam said:
smithy167 said:
sniff said:
Its not really a realistic comparison is it... in fact its just plain silly.. Everton are an outside chance if they play at the top of their game and a genuine top side has an off day, they are in with a shout... on the other hand you have imo the best team in the leauge...

see the point
Managers are judged on trophies won, not individual losses, get it?

A very good point.
That just is not true. Would you class Inter as a big club. They had won countless domestic league titles under Mancini but sacked him because of Europe. Then Mourinho came in and won them the treble. The first time they had ever done it

Similar happened at Barca when they sacked Rijkaard
 
smithy167 said:
sniff said:
smithy167 said:
While Mancini has been in charge, how many trophies have we won?

Its not really a realistic comparison is it... in fact its just plain silly.. Everton are an outside chance if they play at the top of their game and a genuine top side has an off day, they are in with a shout... on the other hand you have imo the best team in the leauge...

see the point
Managers are judged on trophies won, not individual losses, get it?


I think the point you cant get is..its all relative.. If moyes fails to win a trophy he hasnt failed !!! If Tottenham only finish top four thats a huge result.. still no trophy.. if Reading, southampton etc.. stay up they dont get a shiny trophy but have still done well and earned respect...

If your not really in the shout for a trophy because your squad isnt up to it.. how can his manager be called a failure by anyone with a working brain... if aguably the best team in the leauge fails to win a trophy then hes not done well...

We have to win something every year, so in this case its all about results... trophies are a minimum expectation... now i went to lengths to explain that... get It ????
 
That was shocking. No excuses for the muppet today. Starting with a back three against Everton was tactical suicide. We won 6-1 at the Swamp by playing 4-4-2 and using the industry of Milner & Silva to support the full-backs in nullifying the rags' threat from wide positions.

Everton play pretty much the same way yet he managed to give their wide players the run of the park. It didn't help that Barry must have found more Everton players with his passes than Everton players did but Garcia & Milner were just chasing shadows all afternoon. It's not like we had any reason to believe that we'd have an easy afternoon at Goodison.
 
smithy167 said:
Let me spell out for you you thick twat managers at top clubs like us are judged on trophies won not individual games, Trophies.

Oh, I just repeated it back to you and you're trying to explain it again? Reading comprehension isn't your strong-suit either, is it?

See, the irony here "you thick twat", is that you were originally presenting an argument as to why Mancini is a better manager than Moyes simply due to the number of trophies won. I recommended you looked at the reasons why Mancini has trophies, and Moyes does not. That would be the more reasonable approach to judging a manager's success... looking at their resources instead of their trophy cabinet.

Instead of looking at the reasons for their varied successes, you came back and said "Managers at "top" clubs judged by their trophies". So you went from insinuating that Mancini is a better manager because of his trophies, to simply stating the obvious fact that managers of top clubs should win trophies to be considered good managers.

Since we know that's total bullshit, and that not all managers have several hundred million to spend on a squad, that how well a manager does against an opposing manager over a span of time is a more appropriate measure of their effectiveness.

SO I'LL DUMB IT DOWN FOR YOU, WISE ONE:

IF THE MANAGERS TODAY SWITCHED TEAMS, WOULD THE RESULT HAVE BEEN THE SAME? IF MANCINI HAD EVERTON'S BUDGET AT CITY, WOULD WE STILL BE WAITING FOR A TROPHY TO END OUR DROUGHT?


(I suggest you answer honestly to avoid humiliation. The answer is pretty fucking clear).<br /><br />-- Sat Mar 16, 2013 1:01 pm --<br /><br />
Prestwich_Blue said:
That was shocking. No excuses for the muppet today. Starting with a back three against Everton was tactical suicide. We won 6-1 at the Swamp by playing 4-4-2 and using the industry of Milner & Silva to support the full-backs in nullifying the rags' threat from wide positions.

Everton play pretty much the same way yet he managed to give their wide players the run of the park. It didn't help that Barry must have found more Everton players with his passes than Everton players did but Garcia & Milner were just chasing shadows all afternoon. It's not like we had any reason to believe that we'd have an easy afternoon at Goodison.

That's really the most well reasoned and well-written account of what happened today. Cheers!
 
Dethred said:
smithy167 said:
Let me spell out for you you thick twat managers at top clubs like us are judged on trophies won not individual games, Trophies.

Oh, I just repeated it back to you and you're trying to explain it again? Reading comprehension isn't your strong-suit either, is it?

See, the irony here "you thick twat", is that you were originally presenting an argument as to why Mancini is a better manager than Moyes simply due to the number of trophies won. I recommended you looked at the reasons why Mancini has trophies, and Moyes does not. That would be the more reasonable approach to judging a manager's success... looking at their resources instead of their trophy cabinet.

Instead of looking at the reasons for their varied successes, you came back and said "Managers at "top" clubs judged by their trophies". So you went from insinuating that Mancini is a better manager because of his trophies, to simply stating the obvious fact that managers of top clubs should win trophies to be considered good managers.

Since we know that's total bullshit, and that not all managers have several hundred million to spend on a squad, that how well a manager does against an opposing manager over a span of time is a more appropriate measure of their effectiveness.

SO I'LL DUMB IT DOWN FOR YOU, WISE ONE:

IF THE MANAGERS TODAY SWITCHED TEAMS, WOULD THE RESULT HAVE BEEN THE SAME? IF MANCINI HAD EVERTON'S BUDGET AT CITY, WOULD WE STILL BE WAITING FOR A TROPHY TO END OUR DROUGHT?


(I suggest you answer honestly to avoid humiliation. The answer is pretty fucking clear).
Dethred said:
You're flogging a dead horse, Dethred. He insists that managers should and can only be evaluated in a vacuum, without reference to context. After all, a pub league manager with 15 trophies is surely a better manager than Bobby, right?!
 
After just reading the reply to dethred... smithy is either a wum..12 years old or a nob head.. i quite work out what he is yet... im sure he will break cover and out himself soon enough
 
Prestwich_Blue said:
That was shocking. No excuses for the muppet today. Starting with a back three against Everton was tactical suicide. We won 6-1 at the Swamp by playing 4-4-2 and using the industry of Milner & Silva to support the full-backs in nullifying the rags' threat from wide positions.

Everton play pretty much the same way yet he managed to give their wide players the run of the park. It didn't help that Barry must have found more Everton players with his passes than Everton players did but Garcia & Milner were just chasing shadows all afternoon. It's not like we had any reason to believe that we'd have an easy afternoon at Goodison.

All the more staggering when you factor in that we've been defending well recently, Kolo and Nastasic, with Zab and Clichy have looked solid. Why you would rip that up to go with a system that has caused us problems all season, fuck knows. Actually manages to make us weaker both defensively and offensively.
 
Blue Heaven said:
You're flogging a dead horse, Dethred. He insists that managers should and can only be evaluated in a vacuum, without reference to context. After all, a pub league manager with 15 trophies is surely a better manager than Bobby, right?!

Well if he doesn't realize it after my poorly worded attempt at explaining it, then maybe sniff's will make him wake up. Its incredibly poor logic. Absolutely dire.
 
sh249 said:
Prestwich_Blue said:
That was shocking. No excuses for the muppet today. Starting with a back three against Everton was tactical suicide. We won 6-1 at the Swamp by playing 4-4-2 and using the industry of Milner & Silva to support the full-backs in nullifying the rags' threat from wide positions.

Everton play pretty much the same way yet he managed to give their wide players the run of the park. It didn't help that Barry must have found more Everton players with his passes than Everton players did but Garcia & Milner were just chasing shadows all afternoon. It's not like we had any reason to believe that we'd have an easy afternoon at Goodison.

All the more staggering when you factor in that we've been defending well recently, Kolo and Nastasic, with Zab and Clichy have looked solid. Why you would rip that up to go with a system that has caused us problems all season, fuck knows. Actually manages to make us weaker both defensively and offensively.
the only poss reason i can think of is no yaya in the side he went for the change what a complete fuck up in my opinion
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top