Mancini

Status
Not open for further replies.
Vienna_70 said:
sh249 said:
forevermancity said:
shafted haha fuck me

he had a title winnng team and spent over £35m

im sure the vast majorityof manages would like to be shafted every year

he is showing himself to be a chequebook manager

Got to say, it's pretty daft to suggest that we needed to sign the most sought after striker, winger and/or midfielder in European football to compete for the title.

But it's true that in order to compete the year after you win the title, you must reinforce the squad strongly.

And with respect to Garcia, Nastasić, Rodwell and the other Summer buys, they were not At the top of Mancini's list of targets.


so if you cant sign your 1st choice players then we dnt have a chance?

what happens in the summer when mancini wants messi and we can sign him? do we have to endure this season again?

he went from plan a to plan z
 
Dethred said:
zark said:
rather than Dzecko heading over from 6 yards out????

or silva for not picking up osman?

so should bobby bring on nasri? oh wait, he did.
so should he have left on the field the strikers ? oh wait he did

You tell me, what should bobby have done at the sending off?

Not wait 10 minutes to swap a defensive midfielder for an attacking midfielder???

Not wait another 10 minutes to throw on a SECOND leftback and a guy everyone forgot about???

Maybe those are brilliant tactical changes in some parallel universe... but not in this one.

We need to find a formation that gets the best from Silva as he makes us tick. With him out wide away from home we leave ourselves open to the opponents attacking full back. Play him off the striker and then he doesn`t have the responsibility to have to defend. If Silva doesn`t have a good game he becomes a passenger, and at Woodison Park you can not carry anyone.
 
Vienna_70 said:
sh249 said:
forevermancity said:
shafted haha fuck me

he had a title winnng team and spent over £35m

im sure the vast majorityof manages would like to be shafted every year

he is showing himself to be a chequebook manager

Got to say, it's pretty daft to suggest that we needed to sign the most sought after striker, winger and/or midfielder in European football to compete for the title.

But it's true that in order to compete the year after you win the title, you must reinforce the squad strongly.

And with respect to Garcia, Nastasić, Rodwell and the other Summer buys, they were not At the top of Mancini's list of targets.

I could dominate world football is if I managed a team where then would sign me all my targets.

Not signing enough quality players is not a valid excuse in my book, we are the team who can complain the least about not signing quality players.

In your opinion when do we start to blame the manager for our shortcomings and not the excuse of not buying a player?
 
zandvoort blue said:
We need to find a formation that gets the best from Silva as he makes us tick. With him out wide away from home we leave ourselves open to the opponents attacking full back. Play him off the striker and then he doesn`t have the responsibility to have to defend. If Silva doesn`t have a good game he becomes a passenger, and at Woodison Park you can not carry anyone.

But do you concede that he might not be having a good game because the entire setup of the team is not aligned with how he plays, or how he can benefit a team?
 
Vienna_70 said:
sh249 said:
forevermancity said:
shafted haha fuck me

he had a title winnng team and spent over £35m

im sure the vast majorityof manages would like to be shafted every year

he is showing himself to be a chequebook manager

Got to say, it's pretty daft to suggest that we needed to sign the most sought after striker, winger and/or midfielder in European football to compete for the title.

But it's true that in order to compete the year after you win the title, you must reinforce the squad strongly.

And with respect to Garcia, Nastasić, Rodwell and the other Summer buys, they were not At the top of Mancini's list of targets.[/]

to be honest, I think the idea that you have to improve to retain the title is, in and of itself, something of an empty platitude,as it obviously depends on what your rivals do.

This year, Utd went out and strengthened, we should have done better too, no doubt about it. But we're not even talking about necessarily retaining the title, rather just competiting for it which, frankly, we haven't done this season. And with the squad we have, we should be a hell of a lot closer.

As for the signings, agreed, clearly not RM's first choices. But if he felt we needed radical strenghtening, he should have had better second choices, rather than putting all hope in being able to go out and get Van Persie, Hazard, De Rossi etc. Whether we could/should have done more to go for those players, no one really knows; one thing's for sure, though, we can't just go out and outbid all rivals every summer to get the best. It simply isn't sustainable.
 
Matt the Giant said:
I'm not overly happy with Mancini, never have been, feeling he hasn't made us play as good as we should be bale to do. However I think we're okay with him in charge.

If we continue to be among the top three clubs in the PL, playing regular Cl football we should all be content with that. The club will continue to work towards the FFP regualtions, work on the youth set-up and academy, bringing in the tip young toddlers of the football world.

Mancini's contract expires, if I'm not mistaken, around the same time Pep will end his Munich tenure. From then on, a mere top three PL place and decent CL runs won't be sufficient. We'll be a dominant force in European football and will be so for decades to come.

Pep isn't the answer, and as you'll see with Bayern - he's a spent force.

Mancini is psychologically much stronger than Guardiola, and no matter what anyone says about Roberto, he's a proven and enduring winner.

I'm not complaining about what's been achieved at the club, although I probably shouldn't be surprised at those who flap on here.
 
Dethred said:
zandvoort blue said:
We need to find a formation that gets the best from Silva as he makes us tick. With him out wide away from home we leave ourselves open to the opponents attacking full back. Play him off the striker and then he doesn`t have the responsibility to have to defend. If Silva doesn`t have a good game he becomes a passenger, and at Woodison Park you can not carry anyone.

But do you concede that he might not be having a good game because the entire setup of the team is not aligned with how he plays, or how he can benefit a team?

Totally correct, so Mancini need to find a formation and a position for Silva to get the best from him. Mancini seems to think because the formation works at the Etihad, it will work away from home. Away from home Silva has been a disappointing as the opposition have him sussed in his out wide position.
 
LoveCity said:
Here is what bothers me. I watched Swansea (lose to Arsenal) and Southampton (beat Liverpool) side by side at 3pm today. Neither team has the individual quality or squad depth we do (because they hardly have any money to spend) but they played a similar style, both moving the ball and attacking with more fluidity and pace than we usually do (except when we really turn it on). Especially Southampton today who outplayed Liverpool as they outplayed us.

Teams greater than the sum of their parts... we seem the very opposite, barely a team at times and heavily reliant on individual greatness to get us through matches. We only rarely appear like a real team to me... there is so much dysfunctional football from the midfield to the attack, so much running into tight spaces, so much wasted time in going backwards and sideways because we have no ideas.

And I'm sorry but that comes down to not just Mancini but his coaching staff as a whole. We focus too much on square pegs to fill round holes instead of creating a great football TEAM. And I'm having serious doubts about whether Mancini is really capable of creating a truly great team as opposed to a great set of players who will always challenge but have a certain inconsistency and will be found out at the highest level (CL).

Only our defence ever seems truly linked and on the same wave length to me, that's where I think Mancini's strengths lie (creating a strong, disciplined defensive unit).


I didn't see those games but I'm sure the point about being greater than the sum of the parts is well made and City do not fall into that bracket. We didn't even fall into that category when we won the league, which we made much harder work of than we should have.

When we click, as we did for a spell last season and occasionally have done recently, one of our strengths seems to be the almost random movement of the team going forward, which bewilders opponents. I thought at one point that was a sign of our team's greater sophistication but perhaps it belies a lack of necessary structure and shape, a rather hit and miss approach that relies on the intuition of players rather than well coached movement?
 
No one called for his head 10months ago. No one questioned his tactics when he placed Fergusun and the rags on a skewer that they can never wriggle off. 1-6 And yet on this forum he struggles to find a friend. Spoilt two faced bastards thats what some of you have become
 
BillyShears said:
smithy167 said:
Dethred said:
Ah, I see what you did there. Nice try in saving your irrational argument. You added "top" before "clubs". But your argument still is just as flawed, as Everton isn't a "top club", therefore you cannot compare the winners medals of Moyes and Mancini.

Again:



If a 1000 quid second hand Fiesta can consistently beat a Ferrari Enzo around a circuit, you need to look at whose driving.

Let me spell out for you you thick twat managers at top clubs like us are judged on trophies won not individual games, Trophies.

Less of the abuse. Does your arguments no good.

LoveCity, if that quote is real then it's going to hurt a lot of feelings.

Not sure why it should hurt anybody's feelings - I think even the most vocal Mancini supporters will admit that at this moment in time Mourinho is a better manager in purely football terms.
It comes down (for me anyway) to wherever you believe Mancini can improve his methods and push the club forward next year after a very disappointing campaign this time around.
I'd like to see him given the chance as would an awful lot of others. As it is there are also a growing number wanting him out - both sides of the argument have their reasons and in many ways both are valid in there own ways.
It's the constant belittling of him on here that's unfair in my eyes - the way people make out that he's a terrible manager when he's far from it is a bit of a joke.
 
tiggsywiggsywoo said:
No one called for his head 10months ago. No one questioned his tactics when he placed Fergusun and the rags on a skewer that they can never wriggle off. 1-6 And yet on this forum he struggles to find a friend. Spoilt two faced bastards thats what some of you have become

i think you will find that there were plent of blues who hae always questioned his ability to manage at the highest level
 
tiggsywiggsywoo said:
No one called for his head 10months ago. No one questioned his tactics when he placed Fergusun and the rags on a skewer that they can never wriggle off. 1-6 And yet on this forum he struggles to find a friend. Spoilt two faced bastards thats what some of you have become
I couldn't have put it better myself.
 
our "fans" need to realise that we arent going to win every game, we arent going to win the league every year, and the best team doesnt always win.....

but none of the above is a reason to change the manager every time we dont.....

back next year, challenge again.....utd will sign players and be stronger, so will chelski and so will the likes of spurs.

keep the manager regardless of the end of season and what happens......we look like spoit brats wanting the manager out evertime we dont get what we want........

if we were to win everything all the time it would be boring....so would the premiership

the manager (and his backroom staff...and people seem to forget that they have input as well and therefore deserve criticism as well as accolades) should be given time to see if we can answer the challenge that has now been set for next season. ......
 
tiggsywiggsywoo said:
No one called for his head 10months ago. No one questioned his tactics when he placed Fergusun and the rags on a skewer that they can never wriggle off. 1-6 And yet on this forum he struggles to find a friend. Spoilt two faced bastards thats what some of you have become

No one criticised his tactics after the 6-1 because he got them right.

mancini must be the only person on the planet that thought it would be a good idea to play the way we did today. Obvious prior to kick off that it wouldn't work, and it didn't. Hence the criticism.
 
Pablo1 said:
BillyShears said:
smithy167 said:
Let me spell out for you you thick twat managers at top clubs like us are judged on trophies won not individual games, Trophies.

Less of the abuse. Does your arguments no good.

LoveCity, if that quote is real then it's going to hurt a lot of feelings.

Not sure why it should hurt anybody's feelings - I think even the most vocal Mancini supporters will admit that at this moment in time Mourinho is a better manager in purely football terms.
It comes down (for me anyway) to wherever you believe Mancini can improve his methods and push the club forward next year after a very disappointing campaign this time around.
I'd like to see him given the chance as would an awful lot of others. As it is there are also a growing number wanting him out - both sides of the argument have their reasons and in many ways both are valid in there own ways.
It's the constant belittling of him on here that's unfair in my eyes - the way people make out that he's a terrible manager when he's far from it is a bit of a joke.
Dethred, or maybe the engine needs looking at instead of the driver!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top