Mancini

Status
Not open for further replies.
peoffrey said:
Skashion said:
Are you fucking serious? He was up against the rags. Hughes record against the rags as City manager was played three, lost three, and we're supposed to believe Hughes would have got us through over two legs? Comparing Hughes' record in the FA Cup is even more laughable. Hughes got us knocked out to struggling Championship side Nottingham Forest, 3 fucking nil at HOME!

Mourinho: Not coming
Klopp: Not coming, 20 points behind leaders, done nothing in Europe anyway.
Pellgerini: Won fuck all of any note.

Rijkaard and Bielsa, two more sensible suggestions at least but I haven't heard their names connected with us yet.

So, assuming none of these came, you'd back keeping Mancini, yes?

You've misunderstood what I was saying about the League Cup exit when Mancini came in. I think a better Manager would've got us through. I've not actually advocated keeping Hughes on - more indicated it wasn't the disaster many would have us believe. Let's face facts here... He's ex-U****d and too many Blues would never accept him. I know far too many who took that stance. I know two who returned their Seasoncards.

Klopp's done nothing in Europe? That Dortmund team were exceptional at City and they've got a perfectly winnable tie against Malaga in the Quarter Finals. That's easily the Semi Finals and then who knows? Chelsea and Liverpool have won the trophy in recent seasons.

I'd back keeping Mancini if we can be convinced that things will improve. I'm pained to see us so far being U****d in the Premiership and think the FA Cup run has been flattering. There's got to be changes somewhere.

-- Fri Mar 29, 2013 7:15 pm --

Rammy Blue said:
If we can't get Moyes then Rafa would be my next choice.

You're a wind up tonight, Rammy. I'd actually recommend Martin Foyle at Hereford United. He's doing a sterling job with a low budget. Chris Sharp was a bargain at £3000.
Someone will bite.
 
peoffrey said:
You've misunderstood what I was saying about the League Cup exit when Mancini came in. I think a better Manager would've got us through. I've not actually advocated keeping Hughes on - more indicated it wasn't the disaster many would have us believe. Let's face facts here... He's ex-U****d and too many Blues would never accept him. I know far too many who took that stance. I know two who returned their Seasoncards.

Klopp's done nothing in Europe? That Dortmund team were exceptional at City and they've got a perfectly winnable tie against Malaga in the Quarter Finals. That's easily the Semi Finals and then who knows? Chelsea and Liverpool have won the trophy in recent seasons.

I'd back keeping Mancini if we can be convinced that things will improve. I'm pained to see us so far being U****d in the Premiership and think the FA Cup run has been flattering. There's got to be changes somewhere.
It's been very easy to mistake your posts as an exoneration of Hughes to be honest, as you seem to think him getting to a a two-legged semi-final in a lowly valuded competition, represented some kind of achievement.

Yes, Klopp has done nothing in Europe. Quite easy to say. He's got a 50% record of getting through the group stages (lower than Mancini's), and has got to a quarter-final, which Mancini has done twice. So forgive me if I'm not yet overwhelmed by this as I'm not by Mancini's European record either. Mancini's done nothing in Europe either but at this point he's done more than Klopp. When he's won something, then you can talk him up. However, I'm interested in what you said when you said our next manager should be able to sustain a title challenge and progress in Europe, I think that's a fair point, but that's not what Klopp has done is it? He's 20 points behind. So why is he to be our next manager?

It just seems this thread is full of people who want Mancini out but I haven't seen many achievable suggestions with an undoubtedly superior record. Strangely, although most of the Outers, understandably so, have listed European prowess as a must, suggestions for those managers are running very thin on the ground. Benitez certainly hasn't been a popular name and yet look at his European record. It's one of the very very best.
 
peoffrey said:
Skashion said:
Are you fucking serious? He was up against the rags. Hughes record against the rags as City manager was played three, lost three, and we're supposed to believe Hughes would have got us through over two legs? Comparing Hughes' record in the FA Cup is even more laughable. Hughes got us knocked out to struggling Championship side Nottingham Forest, 3 fucking nil at HOME!

Mourinho: Not coming
Klopp: Not coming, 20 points behind leaders, done nothing in Europe anyway.
Pellgerini: Won fuck all of any note.

Rijkaard and Bielsa, two more sensible suggestions at least but I haven't heard their names connected with us yet.

So, assuming none of these came, you'd back keeping Mancini, yes?

You've misunderstood what I was saying about the League Cup exit when Mancini came in. I think a better Manager would've got us through. I've not actually advocated keeping Hughes on - more indicated it wasn't the disaster many would have us believe. Let's face facts here... He's ex-U****d and too many Blues would never accept him. I know far too many who took that stance. I know two who returned their Seasoncards.

Klopp's done nothing in Europe? That Dortmund team were exceptional at City and they've got a perfectly winnable tie against Malaga in the Quarter Finals. That's easily the Semi Finals and then who knows? Chelsea and Liverpool have won the trophy in recent seasons.

I'd back keeping Mancini if we can be convinced that things will improve. I'm pained to see us so far being U****d in the Premiership and think the FA Cup run has been flattering. There's got to be changes somewhere.

I'm afraid some people have short memories peoffrey

I remember this board blaming him and going in to meltdown when he played Boyata in front of Onuoha in both legs of the Semi
 
Skashion said:
gordondaviesmoustache said:
A rare night off the booze tonight.

The world seems such a boring place.
So much like Mark Twain, Groucho Marx and Oscar Wilde, you're only a great wit if inebriated.
Don't compare me with Oscar Wilde, Skash. jma will be calling you one of my "lickspittles".

Which is exactly what you are.
 
Skashion said:
peoffrey said:
Zabaleta, Kompany, Tevez and De Jong were all signed by Hughes whilst Silva and Yaya Toure were on our radar long before Mancini was. Hughes took us so far (in 6th when he left) and now Mancini will take us so far too. The next Manager needs to take us forwards in Europe whilst also earning domestic success as Premiership Champions again. This 15 point gap could get bigger by the end of the season and is simply unacceptable.
You're clearly not following the thread as I ripped a big hole in the giving credit to Hughes argument earlier, although from 8th to 6th for £212m net whilst having Kompany warming the bench is probably a very quick summary of Hughes taking us nowhere at all. I've also pointed out that it's quite plausible for Mancini to finish with a very respectable 83 points this season. However, who's coming in to replace him? People are quick to demand that Mancini should lose his job but specifying who is going to fill his shoes is rapidly becoming a mute subject on this thread.

Not only did Hughes take us nowhere at all, but his ridiculous buys have had a lasting and damaging effect as we strive to comply with Twatini's big club charter.

On the subject of Mancini, he may indeed finish the season with a 'respectable' 83 points, but that would entail us having to win 8 of our remaining 9 games, including at least 2 out of the rags, Spuds and Swansea away. A more likely total would probably be around the 77 mark, a full dozen down on last season, having spent £60 odd million adding to last year's title winning squad. Sacking him might be a gamble, if Mourinho or Klopp is not available, but I genuinely don't think Laudrup, Martinez or even Rodgers would have fared any worse with the players at our disposal, let alone Pellegrini, Ancelotti, De Boer or Hiddink. That enough names for you?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top