Mancini

Status
Not open for further replies.
nijinskybell said:
Blue Heaven said:
squirtyflower said:
but it is just your opinion, an interesting opinion, but it isn't based on fact therefore has no relevance

would my opinion that the players love playing for Mancini and enjoy his management style have equal stature to yours?

however how my opinion is derived?

It's not a question of the relative 'stature' of opinions, but rather it is simply down to whether any particular opinion is an accurate description of what it is intended to describe.

You opine that truth is 'based on fact' but what is 'fact' if not an accurate representation of something? Which brings us right back to my original answer.

-- Mon Apr 01, 2013 2:22 am --

nijinsky's fetlocks said:
Ok,I'll humour you awhile longer,seeing as it's a slow bank holiday Monday.
How can your prediction that Mancini will be gone soon be validated with the actual evidence and facts that would render it true,rather than pure,baseless speculation?

Deary me, have we run out of windmills already? Or did trusty Sancho forget to bring your lance?

And for the record, my "prediction" will be validated at season's end, when Bobby is sacked. I should think that would have been rather obvious!

-- Mon Apr 01, 2013 2:24 am --

nijinskybell said:
Motivation varies from person to person. I trust Mancini to do it his way, for each individual. None of us know what has been said privately about this.

No, but thanks to Bobby, everyone on the planet knows what has been said publicly about this.

And maybe that's what was eventually needed? He criticised him, Samir played well, he said why did I have to do that - I know he has the talent but he's so frustrating. We simply don't know what had been tried behind the scenes prior to the initial public criticism.

This is hardly the first time he's gone after Samir in the media. Third time, if memory serves. Based on Samir's form, I don't think it worked the first two times, but I guess Bobby believes that now that Samir has had one of his best performances for us, this is the right time to humiliate him again publicly.

-- Mon Apr 01, 2013 2:38 am --

squirtyflower said:
blueinsa said:
squirtyflower said:
but it is just your opinion, an interesting opinion, but it isn't based on fact therefore has no relevance

would my opinion that the players love playing for Mancini and enjoy his management style have equal stature to yours?

however how my opinion is derived?

Whats with the sudden need for facts when its an opinion that doesn't blow smoke up Bobs arse?

Ive seen it used more and more recently by those wanting to stifle any debate on Bob and frankly its ridiculous.
i haven't asked for facts
I just pointing out that an opinion is just that, an opinion
there's nothing wrong with opinions, we all have them, and there's many been effused on this thread

however it is disingenuous to state opinion as fact, or to base future happenings on opinions, it becomes speculation and should be treated as such

so in answer to your seemingly angry
Whats with the sudden need for facts when its an opinion that doesn't blow smoke up Bobs arse?

Ive seen it used more and more recently by those wanting to stifle any debate on Bob and frankly its ridiculous

I have neither:
a) blown smoke up bob's arse, ever
b) tried to stifle debate

yesterday several of you complained that the thread was put in the transfer forum, it's baseless facts and speculation that got it there in the first place

therefore i think, in my opinion, i'm entitled to pint out speculation and opinion peddled as facts

I NEVER stated my opinion as fact, so stop lying about my posts.<br /><br />-- Mon Apr 01, 2013 2:39 am --<br /><br />
grim up north said:
Italian in sense of humour shocker.

Taken literally by a few dullards

What is shocking is that Bobby thinks it's funny. What is also shocking is that you do, too.
 
Blue Heaven said:
nijinskybell said:
Blue Heaven said:
It's not a question of the relative 'stature' of opinions, but rather it is simply down to whether any particular opinion is an accurate description of what it is intended to describe.

You opine that truth is 'based on fact' but what is 'fact' if not an accurate representation of something? Which brings us right back to my original answer.

-- Mon Apr 01, 2013 2:22 am --



Deary me, have we run out of windmills already? Or did trusty Sancho forget to bring your lance?

And for the record, my "prediction" will be validated at season's end, when Bobby is sacked. I should think that would have been rather obvious!

-- Mon Apr 01, 2013 2:24 am --



No, but thanks to Bobby, everyone on the planet knows what has been said publicly about this.

And maybe that's what was eventually needed? He criticised him, Samir played well, he said why did I have to do that - I know he has the talent but he's so frustrating. We simply don't know what had been tried behind the scenes prior to the initial public criticism.

This is hardly the first time he's gone after Samir in the media. Third time, if memory serves. Based on Samir's form, I don't think it worked the first two times, but I guess Bobby believes that now that Samir has had one of his best performances for us, this is the right time to humiliate him again publicly.

-- Mon Apr 01, 2013 2:38 am --

squirtyflower said:
blueinsa said:
Whats with the sudden need for facts when its an opinion that doesn't blow smoke up Bobs arse?

Ive seen it used more and more recently by those wanting to stifle any debate on Bob and frankly its ridiculous.
i haven't asked for facts
I just pointing out that an opinion is just that, an opinion
there's nothing wrong with opinions, we all have them, and there's many been effused on this thread

however it is disingenuous to state opinion as fact, or to base future happenings on opinions, it becomes speculation and should be treated as such

so in answer to your seemingly angry
Whats with the sudden need for facts when its an opinion that doesn't blow smoke up Bobs arse?

Ive seen it used more and more recently by those wanting to stifle any debate on Bob and frankly its ridiculous

I have neither:
a) blown smoke up bob's arse, ever
b) tried to stifle debate

yesterday several of you complained that the thread was put in the transfer forum, it's baseless facts and speculation that got it there in the first place

therefore i think, in my opinion, i'm entitled to pint out speculation and opinion peddled as facts

I NEVER stated my opinion as fact, so stop lying about my posts.

-- Mon Apr 01, 2013 2:39 am --

grim up north said:
Italian in sense of humour shocker.

Taken literally by a few dullards

What is shocking is that Bobby thinks it's funny. What is also shocking is that you do, too.


grow up and get a life
 
Blue Heaven said:
nijinskybell said:
Blue Heaven said:
It's not a question of the relative 'stature' of opinions, but rather it is simply down to whether any particular opinion is an accurate description of what it is intended to describe.

You opine that truth is 'based on fact' but what is 'fact' if not an accurate representation of something? Which brings us right back to my original answer.

-- Mon Apr 01, 2013 2:22 am --



Deary me, have we run out of windmills already? Or did trusty Sancho forget to bring your lance?

And for the record, my "prediction" will be validated at season's end, when Bobby is sacked. I should think that would have been rather obvious!

-- Mon Apr 01, 2013 2:24 am --



No, but thanks to Bobby, everyone on the planet knows what has been said publicly about this.

And maybe that's what was eventually needed? He criticised him, Samir played well, he said why did I have to do that - I know he has the talent but he's so frustrating. We simply don't know what had been tried behind the scenes prior to the initial public criticism.

This is hardly the first time he's gone after Samir in the media. Third time, if memory serves. Based on Samir's form, I don't think it worked the first two times, but I guess Bobby believes that now that Samir has had one of his best performances for us, this is the right time to humiliate him again publicly.

-- Mon Apr 01, 2013 2:38 am --

squirtyflower said:
blueinsa said:
Whats with the sudden need for facts when its an opinion that doesn't blow smoke up Bobs arse?

Ive seen it used more and more recently by those wanting to stifle any debate on Bob and frankly its ridiculous.
i haven't asked for facts
I just pointing out that an opinion is just that, an opinion
there's nothing wrong with opinions, we all have them, and there's many been effused on this thread

however it is disingenuous to state opinion as fact, or to base future happenings on opinions, it becomes speculation and should be treated as such

so in answer to your seemingly angry
Whats with the sudden need for facts when its an opinion that doesn't blow smoke up Bobs arse?

Ive seen it used more and more recently by those wanting to stifle any debate on Bob and frankly its ridiculous

I have neither:
a) blown smoke up bob's arse, ever
b) tried to stifle debate

yesterday several of you complained that the thread was put in the transfer forum, it's baseless facts and speculation that got it there in the first place

therefore i think, in my opinion, i'm entitled to pint out speculation and opinion peddled as facts

I NEVER stated my opinion as fact, so stop lying about my posts.
in my opinion you did

and my response, that you have quoted was in response to another poster, not you
 
squirtyflower said:
blueinsa said:
squirtyflower said:
but it is just your opinion, an interesting opinion, but it isn't based on fact therefore has no relevance

would my opinion that the players love playing for Mancini and enjoy his management style have equal stature to yours?

however how my opinion is derived?

Whats with the sudden need for facts when its an opinion that doesn't blow smoke up Bobs arse?

Ive seen it used more and more recently by those wanting to stifle any debate on Bob and frankly its ridiculous.
i haven't asked for facts
I just pointing out that an opinion is just that, an opinion
there's nothing wrong with opinions, we all have them, and there's many been effused on this thread

however it is disingenuous to state opinion as fact, or to base future happenings on opinions, it becomes speculation and should be treated as such

so in answer to your seemingly angry
Whats with the sudden need for facts when its an opinion that doesn't blow smoke up Bobs arse?

Ive seen it used more and more recently by those wanting to stifle any debate on Bob and frankly its ridiculous

I have neither:
a) blown smoke up bob's arse, ever
b) tried to stifle debate

yesterday several of you complained that the thread was put in the transfer forum, it's baseless facts and speculation that got it there in the first place

therefore i think, in my opinion, i'm entitled to pint out speculation and opinion peddled as facts

I have no problem with most of that and agree that the boards are for opinions, no matter how different. It just makes me laugh that on Bob, a few have decided to demand proof of any opinion daring to criticise when they know full well its just an opinion and proof is never going to be forth coming.

As for the thread being moved because of it being rumour, gossip and speculation.....bollox and its what I said yesterday as well.

The fact its back up here shows it was a bollox decision in the first place.<br /><br />-- Mon Apr 01, 2013 10:50 am --<br /><br />It must be quiet down in the celler this morning.........

Barm or Muffin?

Prove it I say or its just meaningless speculation surely?

Maybe that thread should be moved to the transfer forum?
 
squirtyflower said:
Blue Heaven said:
nijinskybell said:
And maybe that's what was eventually needed? He criticised him, Samir played well, he said why did I have to do that - I know he has the talent but he's so frustrating. We simply don't know what had been tried behind the scenes prior to the initial public criticism.

This is hardly the first time he's gone after Samir in the media. Third time, if memory serves. Based on Samir's form, I don't think it worked the first two times, but I guess Bobby believes that now that Samir has had one of his best performances for us, this is the right time to humiliate him again publicly.

-- Mon Apr 01, 2013 2:38 am --

squirtyflower said:
i haven't asked for facts
I just pointing out that an opinion is just that, an opinion
there's nothing wrong with opinions, we all have them, and there's many been effused on this thread

however it is disingenuous to state opinion as fact, or to base future happenings on opinions, it becomes speculation and should be treated as such

so in answer to your seemingly angry
Whats with the sudden need for facts when its an opinion that doesn't blow smoke up Bobs arse?

Ive seen it used more and more recently by those wanting to stifle any debate on Bob and frankly its ridiculous

I have neither:
a) blown smoke up bob's arse, ever
b) tried to stifle debate

yesterday several of you complained that the thread was put in the transfer forum, it's baseless facts and speculation that got it there in the first place

therefore i think, in my opinion, i'm entitled to pint out speculation and opinion peddled as facts

I NEVER stated my opinion as fact, so stop lying about my posts.
in my opinion you did

and my response, that you have quoted was in response to another poster, not you

Sorry, but I'm entitled to point out speculation and opinion peddled as fact...

You reference to the other poster was to my earlier post.
 
blueinsa said:
squirtyflower said:
blueinsa said:
Whats with the sudden need for facts when its an opinion that doesn't blow smoke up Bobs arse?

Ive seen it used more and more recently by those wanting to stifle any debate on Bob and frankly its ridiculous.
i haven't asked for facts
I just pointing out that an opinion is just that, an opinion
there's nothing wrong with opinions, we all have them, and there's many been effused on this thread

however it is disingenuous to state opinion as fact, or to base future happenings on opinions, it becomes speculation and should be treated as such

so in answer to your seemingly angry
Whats with the sudden need for facts when its an opinion that doesn't blow smoke up Bobs arse?

Ive seen it used more and more recently by those wanting to stifle any debate on Bob and frankly its ridiculous

I have neither:
a) blown smoke up bob's arse, ever
b) tried to stifle debate

yesterday several of you complained that the thread was put in the transfer forum, it's baseless facts and speculation that got it there in the first place

therefore i think, in my opinion, i'm entitled to pint out speculation and opinion peddled as facts

I have no problem with most of that and agree that the boards are for opinions, no matter how different. It just makes me laugh that on Bob, a few have decided to demand proof of any opinion daring to criticise when they know full well its just an opinion and proof is never going to be forth coming.

i feel that if wild speculation is made it is only right that questions should be asked, from either inners or outers, however from your side of the fence you see it only one way
as i'm sat on the fence i see it both ways and therefore ask for some factual information on the odd occasion


As for the thread being moved because of it being rumour, gossip and speculation.....bollox and its what I said yesterday as well.

The fact its back up here shows it was a bollox decision in the first place.
well that's your opinion based on your speculation on what happened and why, and something i do have factual knowledge of
 
Personally Mancini has gone up in my estimation for saying what he said. He wants warriors in the team that give 100% every week. He wanted De Rossi for that reason.

Nasri has been missing in action this season. Every fan knows it. Every fan knows that Nasri needs to grow a pair.

I don't blame Mancni in the slightest for saying what he said. Nasri needed to hear it.
 
blueinsa said:
squirtyflower said:
blueinsa said:
Whats with the sudden need for facts when its an opinion that doesn't blow smoke up Bobs arse?

Ive seen it used more and more recently by those wanting to stifle any debate on Bob and frankly its ridiculous.
i haven't asked for facts
I just pointing out that an opinion is just that, an opinion
there's nothing wrong with opinions, we all have them, and there's many been effused on this thread

however it is disingenuous to state opinion as fact, or to base future happenings on opinions, it becomes speculation and should be treated as such

so in answer to your seemingly angry
Whats with the sudden need for facts when its an opinion that doesn't blow smoke up Bobs arse?

Ive seen it used more and more recently by those wanting to stifle any debate on Bob and frankly its ridiculous

I have neither:
a) blown smoke up bob's arse, ever
b) tried to stifle debate

yesterday several of you complained that the thread was put in the transfer forum, it's baseless facts and speculation that got it there in the first place

therefore i think, in my opinion, i'm entitled to pint out speculation and opinion peddled as facts

I have no problem with most of that and agree that the boards are for opinions, no matter how different. It just makes me laugh that on Bob, a few have decided to demand proof of any opinion daring to criticise when they know full well its just an opinion and proof is never going to be forth coming.

As for the thread being moved because of it being rumour, gossip and speculation.....bollox and its what I said yesterday as well.

The fact its back up here shows it was a bollox decision in the first place.

-- Mon Apr 01, 2013 10:50 am --

It must be quiet down in the celler this morning.........

Barm or Muffin?

Prove it I say or its just meaningless speculation surely?

Maybe that thread should be moved to the transfer forum?
i think you may find it's in the cellar, which is full of meaningless speculation
 
squirtyflower said:
As for the thread being moved because of it being rumour, gossip and speculation.....bollox and its what I said yesterday as well.

The fact its back up here shows it was a bollox decision in the first place.
well that's your opinion based on your speculation on what happened and why, and something i do have factual knowledge of
[/quote]

Its back where it belongs. Bill fucked up moving it, just my opinion of course ;-)
 
jollylescott said:
Nasri needed to hear it.

Here's what I don't get about this "Bobby knows best" and the players need to get used to it. Has it previously been effective ? Can someone point me in the direction of a player who Mancini's publicly criticised who has subsequently gone on to improve, excel, and reach a level of performance which is acceptable to him ?

I think I'd have more time for the tough guy routine if I didn't think most of the time it's knee jerk anger rather than calculated management.
 
gordondaviesmoustache said:
"Day twenty on the Mancini thread"

Sounds better if you say it with a Geordie accent.

This thread's a walk in the park compared to some?

A Thread on the Sunderland forum has just hit 303 pages in 24hrs about their manager ;-)
 
squirtyflower said:
blueinsa said:
squirtyflower said:
i haven't asked for facts
I just pointing out that an opinion is just that, an opinion
there's nothing wrong with opinions, we all have them, and there's many been effused on this thread

however it is disingenuous to state opinion as fact, or to base future happenings on opinions, it becomes speculation and should be treated as such

so in answer to your seemingly angry
Whats with the sudden need for facts when its an opinion that doesn't blow smoke up Bobs arse?

Ive seen it used more and more recently by those wanting to stifle any debate on Bob and frankly its ridiculous

I have neither:
a) blown smoke up bob's arse, ever
b) tried to stifle debate

yesterday several of you complained that the thread was put in the transfer forum, it's baseless facts and speculation that got it there in the first place

therefore i think, in my opinion, i'm entitled to pint out speculation and opinion peddled as facts

I have no problem with most of that and agree that the boards are for opinions, no matter how different. It just makes me laugh that on Bob, a few have decided to demand proof of any opinion daring to criticise when they know full well its just an opinion and proof is never going to be forth coming.

As for the thread being moved because of it being rumour, gossip and speculation.....bollox and its what I said yesterday as well.

The fact its back up here shows it was a bollox decision in the first place.

-- Mon Apr 01, 2013 10:50 am --

It must be quiet down in the celler this morning.........

Barm or Muffin?

Prove it I say or its just meaningless speculation surely?

Maybe that thread should be moved to the transfer forum?
i think you may find it's in the cellar, which is full of meaningless speculation

Squirty mate, the whole fucking place is full of meaningless speculation and its what attracts us here.

If we wanted facts, Bluemoon would not be the place to find them......imo ;-)
 
blueinsa said:
squirtyflower said:
blueinsa said:
I have no problem with most of that and agree that the boards are for opinions, no matter how different. It just makes me laugh that on Bob, a few have decided to demand proof of any opinion daring to criticise when they know full well its just an opinion and proof is never going to be forth coming.

As for the thread being moved because of it being rumour, gossip and speculation.....bollox and its what I said yesterday as well.

The fact its back up here shows it was a bollox decision in the first place.

-- Mon Apr 01, 2013 10:50 am --

It must be quiet down in the celler this morning.........

Barm or Muffin?

Prove it I say or its just meaningless speculation surely?

Maybe that thread should be moved to the transfer forum?
i think you may find it's in the cellar, which is full of meaningless speculation

Squirty mate, the whole fucking place is full of meaningless speculation and its what attracts us here.

If we wanted facts, Bluemoon would not be the place to find them......imo ;-)
hahahahaha
i think there's been the odd fact in eight years
 
My respect for Mancini erodes by the week. I fully respect those who want him to stay and their reasons for doing so.

I'm just sick of him starting unnecessary fires, it's every week.

His comments about Nasri are old ground, we've heard it before. I happen to agree with the sentiments, but doing so in public was not for me.

Mancini's comments today, however, are the last straw for me.

Apparently we have a 100 year history but have only been born for two.

He continues to be derogatory about our club.

Someone should tell him Joe Mercer won five trophies in two years just a few decades back and that's something Mancini can't now match.

It was those tales from my dad which kept me going, when I thought what was all this shit from the beginning of the 80s.

More importantly, his comments about Vinny.

Apparently, he was in the wrong to play for Belgium now, having first pointed the finger at the Belgium national doctors on Thursday.

I don't need him questioning the club I love, regardless of our history, and certainly a captain who I will always proud to lead us.
 
blueinsa said:
nijinskybell said:
How many times have you said "I could have killed/punched/kicked him"? It's just Italian for Nasri can be really frustrating, it doesn't mean he literally wanted to punch him. Lost in translation.

You don't really believe that do you?

"Its just Italian" pmsl

He might of watched the Sopranos last night? ;-)
 
tolmie's hairdoo said:
My respect for Mancini erodes by the week. I fully respect those who want him to stay and their reasons for doing so.

I'm just sick of him starting unnecessary fires, it's every week.

His comments about Nasri are old ground, we've heard it before. I happen to agree with the sentiments, but doing so in public was not for me.

Mancini's comments today, however, are the last straw for me.

Apparently we have a 100 year history but have only been born for two.

He continues to be derogatory about our club.

Someone should tell him Joe Mercer won five trophies in two years just a few decades back and that's something Mancini can't now match.

It was those tales from my dad which kept me going, when I thought what was all this shit from the beginning of the 80s.

More importantly, his comments about Vinny.

Apparently, he was in the wrong to play for Belgium now, having first pointed the finger at the Belgium national doctors on Thursday.

I don't need him questioning the club I love, regardless of our history, and certainly a captain who I will always proud to lead us.
Was you crying while typing that out?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top