M11 3FF said:
OB1 said:
I have to wonder just how many people on here have ever managed other people? (I'm not looking for people to answer that question).
I also wonder how many people actually know any top class professional footballers and found that, aside from their sporting gifts, they are just like the rest of us? Thanks to the fact that my kid brother and his family became very good friends with a (now former) City player and his family when they moved to the club, I met said footballer, heard lots of stories from the reigns of three different managers and even chatted at some length a couple of times (in the Players' Lounge) with the sports psychologist that City had employed.
The long and the short of it is that if anyone on this forum is under the impression that how a manager treats his staff - be they footballers or not - does not make a difference, they are deluded.
People my love their profession but it does not mean that they will love their workplace; indeed a bad manager can make people hate their workplace and that will inevitably affect their performance and I know that can apply to top footballers.
Creative tension, my arse.
Spot on
Unusually agree with OB1 on this, however, you can only judge management on its outcomes and the outcomes have been pretty good in anyone's book.
It would be great if Harry Redknapps arm round the shoulder approach worked but with today's footballers, many of whom are arrogant beyond belief, the softly softly approach will not work, it is simply a license for players to run the dressing room JohnTerry style.
Mancini is tough, no nonsense and is not afraid to show who is the boss, he is not there to be liked he is there to get results and he has done a bl**dy good job to date. Plus none of us have the inside track on how he manages at an individual level in the dressing room or the role the coaches play in installing confidence.
Plus, you place far too much credence on what you read in the press and the spin they put on everything. When will you understand that these journo's want to stoke up division and disharmony? I have seen nothing from any of the players to suggest they have an axe to grind with Mancini.
It would be nice if you took the same standards as you expect of the manager with the fans -
indeed bad fans can make players hate their workplace and that will inevitably affect their performance and I now that can apply to top footballerspot and kettle me thinks.
It seems to me that the Mancini outers have lost the argument based on what Mancini has achieved. It's obvious they just don't like his managerial 'style' and that is a pathetic reason to replace any manager, it has to be based on achievement.