Mata vs Silva (Who would you pick)

[citymad]

Silva by far, Cazorla is twice the player Mata is.

Have to disagree. All three are great players but mata is equal if not better than carzola. He's been brilliant for Chelsea this year.

 

[trevorriley]

silva...........

but would like to have mata in squad !

 

[sir baconface]

I'll go for Dave. I love his silky skills and vision even though Mata is really good and has a better end product.

Why don't we unearth bargains like Corzola? Say what you like about Wenger but he's a far better spotter of young talent than anyone at the Etihad.

 

[MeatnSpudsMCFC]

Silva, when he's in form... he runs the entire show, which is exactly what he did last season. I've still not forgotten that ridiculous pass at the 6-1 to Dzeko.

"I decree today that Silva is simply a magician and he's City's ... the City is ours, oh Fergie, are you listening... does his body rule the mind or the mind rule the body? Who knows".

 

[mcfc_nick]

its really not even close.

 

[brotherblue]

To be honest i would rather have silva, he is much more intelligent

Just imagine if silva, mata and david villa all played in the same team how scary would that forward line be . oh wait a minute...

 

[BatleyBlue]

100% Silva.

 

[Matty]

Mata is more of a goal threat than Silva, at times Silva's seeming unwillingness to shoot can be infuriating, but Silva is a far better passer of the ball and can run the game on his own. I'd have Silva over Mata, something the Spanish national coach seems to agree with me on....

 

[GazC]

I'll go for Dave. I love his silky skills and vision even though Mata is really good and has a better end product.

Why don't we unearth bargains like Corzola? Say what you like about Wenger but he's a far better spotter of young talent than anyone at the Etihad.

Cazorla's 28 mate and has 50 caps for Spain, I don't think this one can be put down to Wenger's network of youth scouts.

 

[WNRH]

Put it this way, if they both played for us and we needed a goal and one of them had to come off it would be Silva.