Match of the Day - 2022/23

[exiled-blue]

In the Forest game how can they give a penalty to Brentford after turning down 2 Forest claims where there was more contact, baffling

 

[unicorn]

Jenas very complimentary about us tonight.

There were more "highlights" of the match in the Jenas analysis than in the actual match highlights beforehand. That move that Phil couldn't quite get on the end of near the end was special.

 

[jimharri]

In the Forest game how can they give a penalty to Brentford after turning down 2 Forest claims where there was more contact, baffling

For me, none of them were penalties.

 

[eversince 76]

None of them were penalties.

If they weren’t, was the foul on KdB a penalty?
Not saying they were all penalties. Just compare the incidents.

It’s constant inconsistency with referees and VARs. And because the latter keeps showing inconsistency every other week, I’d keep saying get rid. I can’t at some point accept a refs decision if it turns out to be wrong. A VAR making a very debatable decision for me is totally unacceptable.

 

[exiled-blue]

For me, none of them were penalties.

Agree, none were, but as they just said, give 1 you have to give them all. Which is part of the issue with Var, fouls are all subjective

 

[chris85mcfc]

There were more "highlights" of the match in the Jenas analysis than in the actual match highlights beforehand. That move that Phil couldn't quite get on the end of near the end was special.

Also don't recall them showing Kevs strike in the 1st half where the keeper made a great save, but then showed a counter attack from Fulham which resulted in the winger firing the shot 10 yards wide (and he was offside!)

 

[Hayley Croppers chopper]

Also don't recall them showing Kevs strike in the 1st half where the keeper made a great save, but then showed a counter attack from Fulham which resulted in the winger firing the shot 10 yards wide (and he was offside!)

They did show Kev strike from about 30 yards out.

 

[El_george]

All offsides are technically on or offside.

Haaland was offside.

Haaland is going to be offside more often than not, because he is 7ft tall and bendy!

Oh and he plays for Man City also.

 

[Alan Harper's Tash]

Haaland is going to be offside more often than not, because he is 7ft tall and bendy!

Oh and he plays for Man City also.

Haaland is hardly ever offside. That could be the first time he has been for us.

I don’t do conspiracy theories, so will disregard your second sentence.

 

[cheekybids]

All offsides are technically on or offside.

Haaland was offside.

I missed MOTD but was wondering about the tv angle they’d use as the live TV showed it behind KDB so you can’t see the ball, therefore how can you make a judgement. However I realise that could be TV & VAR may see multiple angles.