Most overrated City player ever?

[Dr Jacoby]

Kante

 

[citymad]

Balo wasn't over rated, he had so much talent but just didn't have the drive or motivation to produce it consistently.

 

[Dr Jacoby]

Can’t believe I’ve seen Silva and Kompany mentioned on here.

 

[J.G.Blue.]

Isn't it pretty much accepted wisdom that he heard a whistle and thought he was offside?

Play the footage back and you can actually hear it.

Dead on 00:10, you can hear a whistle or a high-pitched scream.

I think he thought he was offside (it did look close) & Dzeko certainly didnt help his cause, Mario should have just pointed at the linesman & there probably wouldnt have been the same fuss?

 

[eastmanc]

Each to there own mate , it’s just opinions enjoy you’re evening

Nice reply .

 

[burning blue soul]

Robinho. Too much, too soon, I fear. The wrong player at the wrong time, for the wrong reasons.

 

[eastmanc]

Imagine if Kinky and the magician were both coached by Pep in the same team

Gio was brilliant.

 

[RiversideBlue]

Gio was brilliant.

Much as I love the players of the last 10 years and understand all of his weaknesses, Kinkladze is the only time I've felt like I was watching a god play football. The team was shit, but the excitent of going to watch kinky play is something I've never had since.

 

[eastmanc]

Much as I love the players of the last 10 years and understand all of his weaknesses, Kinkladze is the only time I've felt like I was watching a god play football. The team was shit, but the excitent of going to watch kinky play is something I've never had since.

The suggestion that he wouldn't have got in this side to me is ridiculous. If the the likes of Raz could get in it regularly, a player who didn't have anywhere near the ability that Kinky did. Then surely Gio would have. He had god given talent.

 

[TheKippaxM14Blue]

The idea that Gio gets in the current side is bollocks. Fantastic as he was on he shouldn't have been starting week in week out in that shower of shit.
He was a fish out of water at the time & extremely talented but lacks 80% of the things it takes to be a pro at the level Pep has people playing at.

 

[bluealf]

Nice reply .

We have been at it for years lol

 

[franksinatra]

Frank save us

Sorry mate I loved David Silva

 

[gordondaviesmoustache]

Imagine if Kinky and the magician were both coached by Pep in the same team

Kinkladze would never be in a Pep team. To suggest otherwise is absurd.

 

[CPPSC]

Imagine if Kinky and the magician were both coached by Pep in the same team

Loved Kinky but it was because of where we were at the time . He would be nowhere near this team .

 

[jma]

To me Dibble and Dunne?

I've never met anyone who rated Dibble

 

[Tolmie scores]

To me Dibble and Dunne?

Kevin Reeves....i had such high hopes..most underated..same era ish..gerry gow

 

[Brightwell Bros.]

David Silva, fuck me. I don't think he's rated nearly highly enough and the lad has got a statue.

 

[dickie davies]

Tony Coton
If you watch videos of our matches where he's in goal and we concede, his positioning is terrible
Yes, he made some good saves, but don't all keepers!

 

[stan bowles]

The suggestion that he wouldn't have got in this side to me is ridiculous. If the the likes of Raz could get in it regularly, a player who didn't have anywhere near the ability that Kinky did. Then surely Gio would have. He had god given talent.

But he expected everyone else to win the ball back and give it to him while he stood still waiting for it - like the rest of the team were his supporting cast. How does that attitude promote team unity ? He was brilliant for his first season no doubt but overweight and lazy for the rest of his time - though still produced amazing moments albeit with greater infrequency. Pep wouldn't have him anywhere near the current team.

 

[dronefromsector7G]

Each to there own mate , it’s just opinions enjoy you’re evening

Enjoy you are evening?