mancity2012_eamo
Well-Known Member
Lloyd Cole - good call. Had considered him myself.Morrissey / Marr
Difford / Tilbrook
Bob Dylan
Lloyd Cole
Pete Shelley
Springsteen
Lloyd Cole - good call. Had considered him myself.Morrissey / Marr
Difford / Tilbrook
Bob Dylan
Lloyd Cole
Pete Shelley
Springsteen
I was going to mention them earlier along with Gord Downie but I couldn't be arsed coming up with any more at the time.My takeaway is that apparently there have only been about 20 artists in music history, and the last ones who ever wrote anything were Rivers Cuomo and J Mascis :)
JK. For me:
Neil Young
Walter Becker/Donald Fagan (that I am the first to mention these guys is sad)
Neil Tennant/Chris Lowe
Adam Schlesinger/Chris Collingwood
Corin Tucker/Carrie Brownstein
Eric Bachmann
Haha, so your top 6 is actually 10 ;-)My takeaway is that apparently there have only been about 20 artists in music history, and the last ones who ever wrote anything were Rivers Cuomo and J Mascis :)
JK. For me:
Neil Young
Walter Becker/Donald Fagan (that I am the first to mention these guys is sad)
Neil Tennant/Chris Lowe
Adam Schlesinger/Chris Collingwood
Corin Tucker/Carrie Brownstein
Eric Bachmann
Only named five.Jon Anderson
Kate Bush
Amy Lee
Neil Finn
Jem Godfrey
I'd remove Fountains of Wayne and Sleater-Kinney and keep Young, Steely Dan, Pet Shop Boys and Archers of Loaf.Haha, so your top 6 is actually 10 ;-)
Go on, be brave, go for it, gimme your top 6!
They are my favo(u)rites of all time; I just put Young first because he's on so many lists. Best combination of music, lyrics, longeveity and consistency of any artist IMO. Many others on these lists have a flaw -- they also wrote some really BAD songs. Steely Dan wrote, effectively, none IMO, at least up through Gaucho.I was going to mention them earlier along with Gord Downie but I couldn't be arsed coming up with any more at the time.
Brill - and original too - I can’t imagine many others putting Neil’s Tennant and Young in there together- though I agree both are excellent.I'd remove Fountains of Wayne and Sleater-Kinney and keep Young, Steely Dan, Pet Shop Boys and Archers of Loaf.