Nasri Appeal (merged).

[Ducado]

Re: Appeal or not? SN.

thought Bassong won the ball to be honest,and Vincent was lucky with his 2 footed tackle and several other offences after getting a yellow

All except Vincent's tackle was not a foul!

 

[SWP's back]

Re: Appeal or not? SN.

thought Bassong won the ball to be honest,and Vincent was lucky with his 2 footed tackle and several other offences after getting a yellow

Sniff sniff.

And Kompany didn't get a yellow raggy

 

[tonea2003]

Re: Appeal or not? SN.

thought Bassong won the ball to be honest,and Vincent was lucky with his 2 footed tackle and several other offences after getting a yellow

he did but in doing so took samir out which was reckless and could of injured him

a straight red for me

 

[taffytheblue]

Re: Appeal or not? SN.

raggy? grow up just because someone has a different opinion there a rag?

 

[Paladin]

Re: Appeal or not? SN.

Graham Poll in the Daily Mail says the sending off was correct. He says going head to head with each other should attract a caution to each player. He goes on to say the withdrawal of the head by Nasri, and the flick that followed it constitutes a head butt and a red card. No arguments there, and pointless appealing IMO.

The same article says Bassong was cautioned for the tackle. So by the same logic the head posturing should have been a second yellow card for him, and dismissal also. That is the injustice Mancini is rightly annoyed about. Blinkered Poll fails to address this.

Addressing other points discussed in this thread, Nasri should not have reacted, and Mancini needs to know he has players he can trust on the pitch. Hence Balo's limited deployment this season. Nasri deserves to face club discipline if he has broken the high standards of behaviour expected of our players, because stupidity like that could easily cost us points.

It looks like that article has been amended now to remove the part about Bassong being booked for the tackle. Seems to me to be a journalistic integrity thing, he wants to make this about Mancini being wrong so quickly remove all of the evidence that he was actually justified to complain about Bassong not being sent off as well.

The bit about Bassong being cautioned for the tackle is in the picture caption. But this is seen on cameras as well as Jones marches in reaching for his cards before Nasri confronts Bassong.

 

[SWP's back]

Re: Appeal or not? SN.

raggy? grow up just because someone has a different opinion there a rag?

Where did you get Kompanys yellow from rag?

And a quick look at your posting history confirms the rest.

 

[Deleted member 52846]

Re: Appeal or not? SN.

thought Bassong won the ball to be honest,and Vincent was lucky with his 2 footed tackle and several other offences after getting a yellow

It wasn't two footed.<br /><br />-- Mon Dec 31, 2012 11:44 am --<br /><br />

Graham Poll in the Daily Mail says the sending off was correct. He says going head to head with each other should attract a caution to each player. He goes on to say the withdrawal of the head by Nasri, and the flick that followed it constitutes a head butt and a red card. No arguments there, and pointless appealing IMO.

The same article says Bassong was cautioned for the tackle. So by the same logic the head posturing should have been a second yellow card for him, and dismissal also. That is the injustice Mancini is rightly annoyed about. Blinkered Poll fails to address this.

Addressing other points discussed in this thread, Nasri should not have reacted, and Mancini needs to know he has players he can trust on the pitch. Hence Balo's limited deployment this season. Nasri deserves to face club discipline if he has broken the high standards of behaviour expected of our players, because stupidity like that could easily cost us points.

It was NOT a head butt.

 

[Pigeonho]

Re: Appeal or not? SN.

raggy? grow up just because someone has a different opinion there a rag?

It's the Bluemoon way, you'll get used to it.
To be honest when Kompany went in I thought he was in trouble as we've all seen those given. The referees decisions after that, for me, say he thinks he fucked up and tried to make up for that error, Kompany's 'foul' afterwards being the main focus of that. As for Nasri, well you can't do what he did so an appeal would be fruitless for me.
Good result though and a sublime display from the team at times.

 

[oakiecokie]

Re: Appeal or not? SN.

thought Bassong won the ball to be honest,and Vincent was lucky with his 2 footed tackle and several other offences after getting a yellow

It wasn't two footed.

-- Mon Dec 31, 2012 11:44 am --

Graham Poll in the Daily Mail says the sending off was correct. He says going head to head with each other should attract a caution to each player. He goes on to say the withdrawal of the head by Nasri, and the flick that followed it constitutes a head butt and a red card. No arguments there, and pointless appealing IMO.

The same article says Bassong was cautioned for the tackle. So by the same logic the head posturing should have been a second yellow card for him, and dismissal also. That is the injustice Mancini is rightly annoyed about. Blinkered Poll fails to address this.

Addressing other points discussed in this thread, Nasri should not have reacted, and Mancini needs to know he has players he can trust on the pitch. Hence Balo's limited deployment this season. Nasri deserves to face club discipline if he has broken the high standards of behaviour expected of our players, because stupidity like that could easily cost us points.

It was NOT a head butt.

He said it constitutes a head butt.

 

[Anonymous]

Re: Appeal or not? SN.

thought Bassong won the ball to be honest,and Vincent was lucky with his 2 footed tackle and several other offences after getting a yellow

Sniff sniff.

And Kompany didn't get a yellow raggy

He's not a rag. You should really check yourself occasionally. You're arguably the busiest **** on the forum.