JoeMercer'sWay said:
sjk2008 said:
Lauren, Vieira, Henry, Sagna, Vermaelen, Song, Fabregas, Nasri, RVP are all recent(ish) examples of half decent/never done it players when they were bought. Some weren't even half decent at the time!
first 3 were donkeys years ago, and the rest of them since the old generation ended have won the square root of fuck all, apart from Sami who came to us.
Plus, there's a difference from buying from Ajax, Marseille and Barca to buying from Montpellier, a Bayern reject from Koln and a lad from Rennes, you always wonder why like M'Vila they haven't had a big move already or if they're a 1 season wonder.
Lauren, Vieira & Henry were years ago yes. They were also half decent at the time of purchase but they went on to win Premier League titles and Vieira & henry went on to be World Class players.
Giroud moved to Montpellier in 2010 from a lower league club and has spearheaded his unfancied team to the title ahead of PSG, Lyon & the like. As a result he's earned himself a big move to the Premiership. Yes, he's unproven in the Premiership, so was Kompany. Look how that turned out?
Podolski has a great scoring record in the Bundesliga and for Germany where he has nearly a 1 in 2 ratio. He's had arguably a better career than Lavezzi, who's a similar age, yet people were creaming over the thought of him to City.
As for M'Vila, well he's young, played at every level for France from the U16's and wouldn't surprise me if he ends up at City in 4 years if past experience of Arsenal being City's feeder club is anything to go by.
My point being in response to you saying "Typical buying half decent but 'never done it' players" Yes, it's not a Ronaldo or a Messi or an Iniesta, but they all have the potential to be very good players just like a lot of the City targets we have mentioned in the transfer forum and it doesn't have to be a superstar signing to be a success.