non city topic but who's better Gerrad or Scholes.........

[Kippax.]

in there prime?

i am having an debate about this on another forum and want to know your views.

 

[Kippax.]

WELL?

 

[WickyWain]

Gerrard :)

 

[The Invisible_Man]

The ginger rat. Gerrard is vastly overated Imho.

 

[blue 1992]

who cares?

 

[JOGAMIGMOG]

Gerrard. Scholes is a Rag, ginger, can't tackle, has deserted his country, been a sub too often, been injured too often.

Gerrard starts games, is a talisman, wins games on his own, captain, leader, commited to his country, scores brilliant goals, can tackle, hates the Rags

Do I win a prize?

 

[blue jim]

scholes in his day was one of the best in europe

 

[PaleBlue]

Gerrard still plays for England, though it's hard to tell at times. Any help?

 

[browny33]

There was a debate on talkshite today about Scholes. Can't remember which numpty sided that Scholes was better than Pele and which one didn't, but thats talk radio for you.

Tomorrow,Stan Collymore is arguing that Windowleen is best for cleaning steamed up car windows on cold winter nights in deserted car parks, whilst Mike Parry thinks that window licking is best.

For what its worth, they are different types of players so it's difficult to compare them, but Jamie Pollock was better than both of them

 

[kidash]

if it's overall player.

easily gerrard, can tackle, commited, great vision, killer goals, leads his team with passion and always pops up with the most important goals in his teams history

scholes can pass and score.