I'll pass on that. If another mod wants to take it on, and deal with the inevitable whinges, so be it.Just put up the players who are mentioned most on here.
Depending on where that line is drawn it really could be a bloody long list. It’s is a 130 year long list afterall.We could do, if the op didn't mind. But where do you draw the line? Having a poll of, say, thirty players would be unwieldy, not to mention silly. If you limit it to, for example, 10 players, which 10 make the cut? I'm just not sure it'd work. You'll get posters saying "my personal choice isn't in there. Why not?". My choice would be Ousmane Dabo, and I'd personally include him in the poll. But that could well be at the expense of KDB, and Kev's fans would be up in arms.
Billy Meredith? Frank Swift? Don Revie? "ever" is a long time.This depends on what era you actually watched the team.
My Grandfather would definitely have said Max Woosnam.
That was my point. In my opinion, it's just not practical.Depending on where that line is drawn it really could be a bloody long list. It’s is a 130 year long list afterall.
Here is my all-time City squad:
G: Ederson Moraes, Frank Swift, Bert Trautmann
D: Sam Cowan, Ruben Dias, Mike Doyle, Vincent Kompany, Roy Paul, John Stones, Kyle Walker, Max Woosnam
M: Colin Bell, Kevin de Bruyne, Rodrigo ‘Rodri’ Cascante, Peter Doherty, Ílkay Gündoğan, Fernando ‘Fernandinho’ Roza, Bernardo Silva, David Silva, Yaya Touré
F: Kun Agüero, Eric Brook, Erling Håland, Joe Hayes, Tommy Johnson, Francis Lee, Billy Meredith, Mike Summerbee
Coaching staff: Pep Guardiola, Malcom Allison
DoF: Txiki Bergistain, Joe Mercer
But putting that in a pole may be a bit ‘overkill’.
Think Trevor Francis and Dave Watson would walk into that squad, mate.Depending on where that line is drawn it really could be a bloody long list. It’s is a 130 year long list afterall.
Here is my all-time City squad:
G: Ederson Moraes, Frank Swift, Bert Trautmann
D: Sam Cowan, Rúben Dias, Mike Doyle, Vincent Kompany, Roy Paul, John Stones, Kyle Walker, Max Woosnam
M: Colin Bell, Kevin de Bruyne, Rodrigo ‘Rodri’ Cascante, Peter Doherty, Ílkay Gündoğan, Fernando ‘Fernandinho’ Roza, Bernardo Silva, David Silva, Yaya Touré
F: Kun Agüero, Eric Brook, Erling Haaland, Joe Hayes, Tommy Johnson, Francis Lee, Billy Meredith, Mike Summerbee
Coaching staff: Pep Guardiola, Malcom Allison
DoF: Txiki Bergistain, Joe Mercer
But putting that in a poll may be a bit ‘overkill’.
Xavi and Iniesta are considered better players than Dave and neither of them won it.Dave and kev are tied , how they never won the barn door is beyond me
I thought I’d put Dave Watson in.Think Trevor Francis and Dave Watson would walk into that squad, mate.