Our Vincent

Ahh. I didn’t like it one bit. I really like komapny and hopes he does well at Burnley but for me that was a bit to much of a show. The whole you won’t like me when I get mad rubbish. All felt a bit contrived and digging out the players like that. Not sure he has to go down that route if shouting and digging players out like that.

I imagined he would be more constructive and a bit more intelligent with a team talk. Felt a bit division four/conference type managing. Kompany is better than that.

Then to be be fair I guess he has only just started in management so may be trying to find his feet.
 
Last edited:
Bobby the blue said:
Ahh. I didn’t like it one bit. I really like komapny and hopes he does well at Burnley but for me that was a bit to much of a show. The whole you won’t like me when I get made rubbish. All felt a bit contrived and digging out the players like that. Not sure he has to go down that route if shouting and digging players out like that.

I imagined he would be more constructive and a bit more intelligent with a team talk. Felt a bit division four/conference type managing. Kompany is better than that.

Then to be be fair I guess he has only just started in management so may be trying to find his feet.
Click to expand...

It wasn't exactly revolutionary, was it?

That sort of rhetoric is in the armoury of even the shitest, least qualified football manager. It isn't exactly awe inspiring. The players wl have heard it all before.

I hold Vincent in higher regard than that. He obviously judged that the situation required that sort of show but if it did, it probably means that his club was struggling at the time.
 
jma said:
It wasn't exactly revolutionary, was it?

That sort of rhetoric is in the armoury of even the shitest, least qualified football manager. It isn't exactly awe inspiring. The players wl have heard it all before.

I hold Vincent in higher regard than that. He obviously judged that the situation required that sort of show but if it did, it probably means that his club was struggling at the time.
Click to expand...
A good leader will have a plan. That’s one side of the story, what followed in the next time he saw them?

From what I remember, Burnley are top of the league?
 
Bobby the blue said:
Ahh. I didn’t like it one bit. I really like komapny and hopes he does well at Burnley but for me that was a bit to much of a show. The whole you won’t like me when I get mad rubbish. All felt a bit contrived and digging out the players like that. Not sure he has to go down that route if shouting and digging players out like that.

I imagined he would be more constructive and a bit more intelligent with a team talk. Felt a bit division four/conference type managing. Kompany is better than that.

Then to be be fair I guess he has only just started in management so may be trying to find his feet.
Click to expand...
I find with my team in work that a bollocking is better delivered like a disappointed father who expects better and feels let down
 
Straight out of the Pep playbook that one. Not angry, just disappointed. Will protect them in front of the media, take the blame for them, but in the changing room he'll be honest.
 
Don't get this hankering for ex City players to become our future managers.
It's been Vierra and Rosler in the past ( I'm sure there have been plenty more suggestions) and now it's Vinny.
Personally, I think it should be the most experienced and able man that will fit our needs at the time.
Which club they played for (if any) shouldn't even be a consideration.
 
goalmole said:
Don't get this hankering for ex City players to become our future managers.
It's been Vierra and Rosler in the past ( I'm sure there have been plenty more suggestions) and now it's Vinny.
Personally, I think it should be the most experienced and able man that will fit our needs at the time.
Which club they played for (if any) shouldn't even be a consideration.
Click to expand...

I agree - its a bit of a raggy/dipperish approach in my book. However what if Arteta won the PL this year and continued to be Pep's biggest challenger. Do we not try and prise him away from Arsenal simply because he was part of the City set up previously?
 
bluethrunthru said:
I agree - its a bit of a raggy/dipperish approach in my book. However what if Arteta won the PL this year and continued to be Pep's biggest challenger. Do we not try and prise him away from Arsenal simply because he was part of the City set up previously?
Click to expand...

He said ex players to be fair.

Kompany needs a couple more clubs before coming to City I think. Burnley will always be relegation fodder, needs to be tested somewhere.
 
Mr Kobayashi said:
He said ex players to be fair.

Kompany needs a couple more clubs before coming to City I think. Burnley will always be relegation fodder, needs to be tested somewhere.
Click to expand...

Yeah I was just being Devils Advocate in many ways - I just feel that in many ways the dippers obsession with the boot room succession and some ex-[layers of managers in part contributed to their wilderness years and we all saw the rags with Olly at the wheel.......................we do just need to focus on the best available coach for the job and only think about what their past looks like at recruitment time
 
manchester-city-manchester-united-vincent-kompany-premiere-leaguecropped-2.jpg

UnacceptableSomberBigmouthbass-size_restricted.gif
 
bluethrunthru said:
I agree - its a bit of a raggy/dipperish approach in my book. However what if Arteta won the PL this year and continued to be Pep's biggest challenger. Do we not try and prise him away from Arsenal simply because he was part of the City set up previously?
Click to expand...
Prise him away because we think he's the best man for the job and for that reason only.
The fact that he has a previous link to City should be purely coincidental.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top