Trouble with deciding who looks like they should be good on pens, so often proves to be inaccurate in real life. Take DeBruyne. Surely to fuck with the skills he’s got you’d imagine he’d be able to pop them in all four corners at will and never give a ‘keeper a change? He’s actually 8-2 which isn’t too bad but I’m pretty sure he’s made it clear that he isn’t interested in taking them for some reason.
Back in the 70s, the two best penalty takers I can remember were Phil Neale and Ray Stewart. Both old fashioned full backs who’d you never pick out as potential penalty takers. And what can you say about Steve Bruce? He could hardly pass a ball two yards without sending a telegram ahead but I think he scored 11 in that season where he scored 19 in total.
I guess the vast majority of professional footballers should be capable of slotting home 80% of pens in a no pressure situation. All comes down to confidence I expect.