PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

A follow up for you: why has it been deemed that straight up owner investment - I own this business, I have this money, I will put this money into this business - is somehow worse than everything you mention?
It became worse the minute we had more money than “them”. We are the lottery winners who have built a fabulous new house on some old “private road” in Wilmslow and that has pissed our new neighbours off so so much. Each day sitting there in their decrepit old house, up to the eyeballs in debt, twitching the curtains and muttering “bastards” to themselves. Of course back in the day the rich thought that wealth was fine but according to “them” it’s not for everyone.
Green eyed fuckers.
 
I think d

I think you work in finance and accounting Colin? Do you know how long BDO have been our auditors and is it of any surprise that we don’t use one of the “Big 4” as our auditors? Which of course used to be a “Big 5” with Arthur Andersen (pre Emron)?
I don't work in the accountancy sector and haven't for many years but when I did it was for a company that eventually was absorbed into BDO. Along with Grant Thornton, they're the next biggest behind the likes of EY, PWC, KPMG and Deloitte. They operate in over 150 countries so they're certainly far from the one-man band I worked for just after leaving them.

They became our auditors in 2006, as they audited the 2007 accounts, so pre-date either takeover.
 
The UEFA case had certain issues 'time barred, also the illegally obtained evidence like hacked emails were inadmissible. This won't be the case with the PL case.
The illegally hacked emails weren't inadmissible, where did you get that from?
 
It's part of the unfortunate hysteria of reporting.

Because there's no obvious rules around punishments, people let their imaginations run wild. There's a report in one paper about United staff wondering about getting winners medals for 2017/18.

The punishment could be a fine, points reduction, relegation, expulsion from the football system - even forcing the season to be replayed is theoretically within the Premier League's powers.

It's what makes people think they've been cheated when the club only gets a fine.

Agreed, the hysteria will die down in a few days anyway and people move onto something else. By the time this gets resolved it will have fizzled out imo.
 
Timely reminder that the person who’s signed off on the United deal with Chevrolet was fired for giving them too much money. And the same thing happened again recently.

If I didn’t already know the answer I’d ask why isn’t that being investigated? The whole place needs burning down, fumigating and exorcised. Here’s hoping city can do a number on them.
 
I think City desperately need to try and go on a PR offensive. The charges are complex enough but the narrative is simply City cheated therefore relegate them, strip them of titles, deduct points and give them a transfer ban.

As long as that’s the pervading narrative our name is mud. It will damage us in negotiations with players, sponsors and coaches. It will tarnish any of the clubs achievements. If the charges, or the majority and most serious of them, are dismissed that will be a footnote. The damage will have been done. Our club will have suffered such reputational damage that couldn’t be undone.

The City PR department need to do something that never seem to have done before, get very aggressive. We could warn journalists to temper their articles, tell them if they condemn us now, we’ll ban them for life if the charges are dismissed. Warn newspapers, Sky, Talksport to be accurate and neutral or lose all access if we’re cleared. It might stop the condemnation and move towards factual reporting.

They will somehow spin this as banning for free speech, it's only getting worse if we do this.
 
Arsenal, bankrolled by the mythical Rwandan tourist board, where even illegal economic migrants won’t go and who blew 72million on Pepe are now pontificating to us about financial frugality
Ha ha,

Did you miss the episode of "Wish you were here" from Rwanda with Judith Chalmers being chased by gun toting guerrillas.
 
Wow what a couple of days. I’ve been inactive because of work and trying to catch up on this all. No shock though PL been coming after us for years what was it 9 teams that signed against us. I love that Pep even bought that up the other day. Unfortunately your everyday person isn’t going to read into this or understand what’s happening so the club’s reputation is going to really suffer. Let’s stick it to them like we did UEFA. One rule for some, different for others isn’t it? Entitled pricks.
 
I don't work in the accountancy sector and haven't for many years but when I did it was for a company that eventually was absorbed into BDO. Along with Grant Thornton, they're the next biggest behind the likes of EY, PWC, KPMG and Deloitte. They operate in over 150 countries so they're certainly far from the one-man band I worked for just after leaving them.

They became our auditors in 2006, as they audited the 2007 accounts, so pre-date either takeover.

Would I be right in thinking that BDO's own reputation will take a giant hit should these charges be upheld? Given, the PL are essentially implying that we as a club have successfully duped BDO over a sustained period and they didn't notice?

That just sounds ridiculously inconceivable.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.