PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

[Chris in London]

Perhaps another point is that the 3 on the CAS panel still managed to make it 2 to 1 in our favor rather than 3 to 0 despite being all legally qualified and presumably been guided by the Chairman.

I don't think that's quite right. There were a series of issues that CAS had to decide, and whilst I don't think they were all 3-0, I don't think they were all 2-1 either. There were certainly areas where the CAS ruling points out that a majority of the panel thought X, Y or Z. However that was not said in relation to every issue. It seems to follow that in other areas the panel was unanimous.

It's some time since I've looked at the ruling in detail, I should add, that's just my recollection.

 

[Kakhaber The Great]

You certainly live up to your name.

 

[SilverFox2]

My impression of that is that it was a face-saving exercise and they did not want to make it seem like a complete humiliation to UEFA.

If so I wonder if any of the PL appointed panel will dare to vote in our favour to stop our annihilation?

 

[ricky77]

I don't think that's quite right. There were a series of issues that CAS had to decide, and whilst I don't think they were all 3-0, I don't think they were all 2-1 either. There were certainly areas where the CAS ruling points out that a majority of the panel thought X, Y or Z. However that was not said in relation to every issue. It seems to follow that in other areas the panel was unanimous.

It's some time since I've looked at the ruling in detail, I should add, that's just my recollection.

It would be great to get clarification of that.

I’m sick of hearing other fans say that the whole case was 2 1. And that it’s only because we picked 2 of the panel.

 

[Bluewonder]

It would be great to get clarification of that.

I’m sick of hearing other fans say that the whole case was 2 1. And that it’s only because we picked 2 of the panel.

Why do you care what other fans think? They're mostly imbeciles!

 

[Jacko1956]

Why do you care what other fans think? They're mostly imbeciles!

Mostly ! Everyr fan who has voiced their vitriol about us will have no idea what we're are illedged to have done wrong !!!

 

[Iassel]

One thing for certain is 95% is certainly not off the table. City might be happy to out on a fake smile and let that be leaked but 95% not being on the table is nonsense.

Indeed, as is the idea that City intend to ‘finally clear their name’……

If an immaterial punishment were offered in exchange for a guilty finding on all charges, City would snap your cock off for it.

 

[ricky77]

Why do you care what other fans think? They're mostly imbeciles!

I know mate. Difficult living in a City were you are ‘the’ City fan and everyone you know supports Liverpool or United.

 

[Chris in London]

It would be great to get clarification of that.

I’m sick of hearing other fans say that the whole case was 2 1. And that it’s only because we picked 2 of the panel.

here you go.

https://www.tas-cas.org/fileadmin/user_upload/CAS_Award_6785___internet__.pdf

contrast para 240 or 253 on the one hand with para 273 on the other.

otherwise fill your boots.

 

[ricky77]

here you go.

https://www.tas-cas.org/fileadmin/user_upload/CAS_Award_6785___internet__.pdf

contrast para 240 or 253 on the one hand with para 273 on the other.

otherwise fill your boots.

Brilliant. I’d never thought of it like that at all. Good to know. Thanks for your efforts.