Player ratings for the season

[ninjamonkey]

If you're going to do this, at least use the whole 10 point scale ffs, otherwise it's just a list of 6/7/8's with 1 or 2 stand outs for the worst/best. Or better still, use the 100 point scale,.

 

[elano's right foot]

Hart 7 (inc champ lge)
Pants 6
zab 9
Clichy 8
Richards 6
Maicon 5
Kolorov 6
Lescott 7
Kompany 8
Nastasic 8
Kolo 7
Silva 7
Nasri 6
Garcia 5
Barry 7
Yaya 7
Sinclair 4
Milner 8
Rodwell 6

Tevez 8
Aguero 7
Dzeko 6
Balotell 4

 

[E_Dzeko 9]

Hart - 7
Pantillimon - 7

Zabaleta - 9
Richards - 4
Kompany - 7
Lescott - 6
Nastasic - 8
K.Toure -7
Clichy - 7
Kolarov - 5

Barry - 7
Yaya - 8
Garcia - 6
Silva - 6
Nasri - 6
Milner - 8
Rodwell - 7

Dzeko - 5
Aguero - 7
Tevez -8

 

[MadchesterCity]

Hart - 7
Pantillimon - 7.5

Zabaleta - 8.5
Richards - 5
Maicon - 5
Reiki - 6
Kompany - 7.25
Lescott - 6.75
Nastasic - 8.25
K.Toure -6.25
Clichy - 7.25
Kolarov - 5.75

Barry - 7.25
Yaya - 7.5
Garcia - 5
Silva - 7.25
Nasri - 6.75
Milner - 7.75
Rodwell - 5.75
Sinclair - 3

Dzeko - 6.5
Aguero - 7
Tevez - 7.75
Mario - 6.5

 

[johnbmcr]

I'd like to wait for the final before giving my ratings...

even on the forgotten players lol

 

[GTJGWilding]

All these eights for Tevez surprise me. He was shocking for the first half of the season. Seven at best thanks to his much-improved form over the last few months. The rest I generally agree with.

Hart 7
Pantilimon 7
Zabman 9
Clichy 8
Richards 6
Maicon 5
Kolarov 6
Lescott 7
Kompany 8
Nastasic 8
K Toure 7
Silva 7
Nasri 6
Garcia 5
Barry 7
Y Toure 7
Sinclair 4
Milner 8
Rodwell 6
Tevez 7
Aguero 7
Dzeko 6
Balotell 4

 

[Zabbasbeard]

Hart - 7
Pantillimon - 7

Zabaleta - 9 _Player of the season, comfortably
Richards - 6
Kompany - 7
Lescott - 7
Nastasic - 8
K.Toure -7
Clichy - 7
Kolarov - 5

Barry - 7
Yaya - 8
Garcia - 5
Silva - 8
Nasri - 6
Milner - 8
Rodwell - 6

Dzeko - 6
Aguero - 8
Tevez -8

 

[yatesy94]

Just going to do regular starters:

Hart - 7 (Above average season for Joe, however still tops the clean-sheet table)
Pantillimon - 8 (Almost flawless in FA cup so far)

Zabaleta - 10 (Outstanding, couldn't of asked for more. Been a machine.)
Kompany - 7 (Gone missing a few games this season not as solid in previous years)
Lescott - 7
Nastasic - 9 (Unbelievable for his age. Difficult to fault him.)
Clichy - 8 (Another good season for us, Mr reliable.)


Garcia - 4 (Slow and looks scared of his own shadow. Doesn't look suited to this league.)
Barry - 7
Yaya - 7
Silva - 7
Nasri - 7 (Redeemed himself at the end of this season. Looked lazy and uninterested at the start though)
Milner - 7


Dzeko - 6 (Despite being our top goalscorer rarely contributes anything to our build-up play)
Aguero - 8 (Been injured for the majority but still effective)
Tevez - 8 (Gives 100% every game)

 

[Kenney_The_Blue]

A bit early Kenny, we have 5 games left yet.

I think performances good or bad from individuals in those matches will certainly have a bearing on their final scores from me.

My ratings are still the same pal and tbh even if somebody is amazing for the last 3 games it wouldn't really effect my opinion on how i've rated them over the last sort of 45/50.

 

[Deleted member 52846]

Zabaleta 9
Nastasić 9
Clichy 8
Milner 8
Agüero 7

Everybody else a 5 or 6.