Player ratings

[balkanno]

Rate the Performance of each Player here.

10 EXCELLENT – best possible performance
1 MISERABLY - worst possible performance

Info:You just the list of the Players (if its correct) in the Post above and set your Rating.

-- Fri Mar 11, 2011 12:16 am --

Im going to start first:

J. Hart = 7.5
V. Kompany = 5.0
M. Richards = 6.5
J. Lescott = 5.0
P. Zabaleta = 5.5
A. Kolarov = 4.0
G. Barry = 5.0
D. Silva = 4.0
Y. Toure = 3.5
M. Balotelli = 4.0
E. Džeko = 5.0

C. Tévez = 4.5
S. Wright-Phillips = 5.0

 

[Cheadle Blue]

bit generous imo. they were all pretty bad. not sure any would make 5 for me

 

[Dax777]

Really? Yaya was the worst player you saw on the field. :?

 

[mancityscot]

How is joe hart 7.5, he was hardly great. Thought lescott and richards played well

 

[Cheadle Blue]

Really? Yaya was the worst player you saw on the field. :?

Dzeko was probably the worst, but yaya was terrible mate

 

[Deleted member 14625]

Lescott = 8
Richards = 7
Kompany = 5
Everybody else = 3 or 3.5 at a stretch

 

[Fame Monster]

Hart - 5 - Could have done better with first goal
Richards - 6 - Could have done better with first goal
Lescott - 7 - Not to blame.
Kompany - 5 - Worst game for a while.
Kolarov - 6 - Better going forward. Could have done better with first goal.
Zabaleta - 6 - Tired.
Barry - 6 - Tired.
Yaya - 5 - Tired and non-existent for large parts.
Silva - 6 - Tired and primarily at fault for the first goal. Poor by every standard.
Dzeko - 6 - Zero service.
Balotelli - 1 - Poor first half and didn't fancy playing for this club tonight. Let the away fans down who spent hundreds of pounds, let the fans at home down, let the manager down and staff down as evidenced by their reactions, let the team down (Tevez shook his head), let Manchester City down, and most importantly, let me down. 'Pride in Battle' is our motto. This boy has no heart. Get rid.

Mancini - 4 - Players who needed vital rest were on the pitch tonight in an effort to kill the tie. Dzeko was up front with no Kolarov at left wing. Balotelli played. And we set up entirely the wrong way. Poor show Bobby.

 

[LongsightM13]

Richards 6, Lescott 5. Kompany 3. The rest get zero.
Mario gets minus a million for craven cowardice. Fucking outrageous display.

 

[Anonymous]

Hart - 5 - Could have done better with first goal
Richards - 6 - Could have done better with first goal
Lescott - 7 - Not to blame.
Kompany - 5 - Worst game for a while.
Kolarov - 6 - Better going forward. Could have done better with first goal.
Zabaleta - 6 - Tired.
Barry - 6 - Tired.
Yaya - 5 - Tired and non-existent for large parts.
Silva - 6 - Tired and primarily at fault for the first goal. Poor by every standard.
Dzeko - 6 - Zero service.
Balotelli - 1 - Poor first half and didn't fancy playing for this club tonight. Let the away fans down who spent hundreds of pounds, let the fans at home down, let the manager down and staff down as evidenced by their reactions, let the team down (Tevez shook his head), let Manchester City down, and most importantly, let me down. 'Pride in Battle' is our motto. This boy has no heart. Get rid.

Richards could certainly have done better with the 2nd goal ..... he was half asleep as their guy took control of kompanys misdirected header!

 

[FantasyIreland]

Really? Yaya was the worst player you saw on the field. :?

Can someone please tell me what qualities this fella has that are superior to the majority of midfielders in the prem that cost a tenth of the price?