Players season ratings

[Adidas Barry Silkman]

Clichy is woeful. Terrified in possession of the ball like its a hot potato. No end product in the final third. Average at defending. His only asset is he's quick. I think Kolarov may not be a world beater but he is far better than Clichy in defence and attack and is much more comfortable on the ball and better able to retain possession which is crucial.

 

[pee dubya]

Hart - 8 - Most consistent player along with Fernandinho.
Willy - 5 - Would be a 3 but for the cup final.

Zab - 4 - Just never got into it, fitness and form.
Sagna - 7 - Most consistent defender, lacking going forward but much needed reliability.
Kompany - 6 - Played well when fit, showed his importance yet again.
Mangala - 6 - When he gets a run together he shows his ability, but always prone to errors.
Otamendi - 6 - Did pretty well for first season and in a poorly organised team, rash decisions and some shockingly bad moments though.
Demichelis - 3 - Past it, got a soft spot for him but shouldn't have been around this season.
Kolarov - 2 - Wank
Clichy - 6 - Similar to Sagna, but with a few more iffy moments.

Fernando - 6 - Grew into the season, same score as Clichy, limited player, generally played well, a few iffy moments.
Fernaninho - 8 - Player of the season
Toure - 5 - Attitude and fitness not there, still showed his ability at times
Delph - 4 - Meh, maybe with a run of games and injury he'd be a bit more settled

Navas - 6 - Just lets himself down at the key moments, but still made a valuable contribution
Sterling - 5 - Started off well, then just faded. Fresh start next season.
Silva - 5 - No where near his best, still a quality player. Playing through pain maybe, but we'd have been better off just letting him recover.
Nasri - NA
KDB - 8 - Important goals, ruthless at the key moments. Needs to maybe be more involved in the general play more often to really step up to next level.

Bony - 2 - Wank
Kelechi - 8 - Young player of the season, desire and quality, if he'd been used more often in the middle period of the season i have no doubt we'd be significantly closer to Leicester.
Aguero - 7 - Clinical, but looked a bit jaded at times, especially in the CL never made an impact. Needs a rest i reckon.

 

[bennyboy]

Hart - 8 - Most consistent player along with Fernandinho.
Willy - 5 - Would be a 3 but for the cup final.

Zab - 4 - Just never got into it, fitness and form.
Sagna - 7 - Most consistent defender, lacking going forward but much needed reliability.
Kompany - 6 - Played well when fit, showed his importance yet again.
Mangala - 6 - When he gets a run together he shows his ability, but always prone to errors.
Otamendi - 6 - Did pretty well for first season and in a poorly organised team, rash decisions and some shockingly bad moments though.
Demichelis - 3 - Past it, got a soft spot for him but shouldn't have been around this season.
Kolarov - 2 - Wank
Clichy - 6 - Similar to Sagna, but with a few more iffy moments.

Fernando - 6 - Grew into the season, same score as Clichy, limited player, generally played well, a few iffy moments.
Fernaninho - 8 - Player of the season
Toure - 5 - Attitude and fitness not there, still showed his ability at times
Delph - 4 - Meh, maybe with a run of games and injury he'd be a bit more settled

Navas - 6 - Just lets himself down at the key moments, but still made a valuable contribution
Sterling - 5 - Started off well, then just faded. Fresh start next season.
Silva - 5 - No where near his best, still a quality player. Playing through pain maybe, but we'd have been better off just letting him recover.
Nasri - NA
KDB - 8 - Important goals, ruthless at the key moments. Needs to maybe be more involved in the general play more often to really step up to next level.

Bony - 2 - Wank
Kelechi - 8 - Young player of the season, desire and quality, if he'd been used more often in the middle period of the season i have no doubt we'd be significantly closer to Leicester.
Aguero - 7 - Clinical, but looked a bit jaded at times, especially in the CL never made an impact. Needs a rest i reckon.

Mangala....5....Mistake every game and still lies too far off an attacker.
Kolarov.....5.....Decent first half of the season,poor second.
Same as Sterling.
Rest pretty much spot on

 

[capiloton]

this forum needs poll or rating option.
especially in post match thread.

and last but not least, please upgrade your server.
i hate to reload many times during peak hour, especially during match thread is active.