POLL ....... Hart or Given
- Thread starter Daz_Blue
- Start date
Chris@Mcfc
Member
- Joined
- 18 Sep 2005
- Messages
- 23
Shay
SWPISHOME
Well-Known Member
Shay Give...But we definetly shouldnt sell Joe Hart to Brum, He will be our NO.1 for years after Given.
GOATERS HEAD GROOVES
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 30 Mar 2010
- Messages
- 86
We all know that Shay will be in net next season and none of us want to lose Joe. But how is our manager who ever it may be, going to keep Joe happy if he is not getting game time. Dont know about you but i dont feel happy about keeper rotation other than possibly the Carling cup games next season.
Chippy_boy
Well-Known Member
Hart
Given is single handedly, all on his own, responsible for us losing possession 10+ times per game.
We must keep the ball better if we want to win things and we can't do that with a keeper who is hell bent on hoofing it all over the park at every opportunity. When was the last time you saw Cech or Vds hoof it all over the ground? They don't do it.
And I should also add, Given is rubbish at commanding his area and coming off his line. Brillant saver, yes. But half the time he shouldn't be having to make the save because he should have come and claimed the ball in the first place. And anyway Hart is just as brilliant a saver.
In his younger years Hart's flaw was he came for the ball too much and ended up flapping around a lot. Now he's matured and learned and has much better judgment. Hart is now just a better keeper than Given, period.
Given is single handedly, all on his own, responsible for us losing possession 10+ times per game.
We must keep the ball better if we want to win things and we can't do that with a keeper who is hell bent on hoofing it all over the park at every opportunity. When was the last time you saw Cech or Vds hoof it all over the ground? They don't do it.
And I should also add, Given is rubbish at commanding his area and coming off his line. Brillant saver, yes. But half the time he shouldn't be having to make the save because he should have come and claimed the ball in the first place. And anyway Hart is just as brilliant a saver.
In his younger years Hart's flaw was he came for the ball too much and ended up flapping around a lot. Now he's matured and learned and has much better judgment. Hart is now just a better keeper than Given, period.
mcfcnorthstand
Well-Known Member
Graham Poll is shite in net and even worse when he was a ref.
MadchesterCity
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 12 Sep 2009
- Messages
- 17,974
On paper Hart makes the most saves and has double the amount of catches on crosses.
Hart would have been busier at Birmingham then Given here but the stats make interesting reading
Hart is bigger and the better all round keeper, dominant in the air and Shay has better distribution
calculated
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 26 Jul 2009
- Messages
- 221
Hart at it again, wants away if he's not GUARANTEED a starting place. Well Joe NOBODY is guaranteed that in this squad. Who does this kid think he is? He's not good for team spirit, get rid.