Question Time

That is not the point, whether she is looked at with mirth, to actually do a routine to an audience ridiculing and singling out a member of the upcoming debating panel and then the host to also take the piss, it has set an acceptable tone against one of the opinions on the panel.

It would be the same if they did it to a tory, snp, lib dem or anyone else, poor in my opinion from the national broadcasters news team

Doesn't matter where your stance is politically or brexit wise piss poor from the bbc on this.

The audience last night generally mocked a lack of coherent Labour policy rather than Diane in my opinion.

You can’t stop that I’m afraid.
 
I’m not screaming bias i’m talking about professionalism. If it’s true that Fiona Bruce stood in front of the audience for ten minutes before the show and made jokes about Abbott, who then received dogs abuse for the whole show, there should be serious questions.

If you believe that then what can I do?

I don’t for a second think she would have done that.

These reports? On twitter I’m guessing?
 
Reports by people in the audience, sorry if it isn't in the mail or express to make it fact enough.
I think we know that each QT audience has "certain" members placed in there by "certain" parties/unions. Until I know it's from a truly independent source, probably bullshit. Sounds more like she got pulled up by FB because she came across as Corbyn's mouthpiece. Next time, Labour should just print a big card with 5 pre-defined answers on it and have a monkey point to one of them.
 
Reports by people in the audience, sorry if it isn't in the mail or express to make it fact enough.

I couldn’t find it on Google or on any reputable site or newspaper, that’s why I asked. No need to get like that just because I asked for a source.

For what it’s worth, I don’t actually think it was Abbott who took the brunt of the criticism last night bar a jibe from the audience and bar being told she was wrong on the polling figures (maybe incorrectly?). It was Corbyn’s position on not meeting May. Nevertheless, if Bruce did do that then it was unprofessional even though I thought her in-show performance and questioning was very good.
 
Last edited:
That is not the point, whether she is looked at with mirth, to actually do a routine to an audience ridiculing and singling out a member of the upcoming debating panel and then the host to also take the piss, it has set an acceptable tone against one of the opinions on the panel.

It would be the same if they did it to a tory, snp, lib dem or anyone else, poor in my opinion from the national broadcasters news team

Doesn't matter where your stance is politically or brexit wise piss poor from the bbc on this.
The BBC lost all credibility of being a neutral unbiased political output a very long time ago. I’m surprised that you are surprised by this behaviour. It’s stuffed full of ex Tory mates of call me Dave.
 
The audience last night generally mocked a lack of coherent Labour policy rather than Diane in my opinion.

You can’t stop that I’m afraid.

This isn't about that though, if and again I say if it is true that prior to broadcast the bbc deliberately targeted it's warm up gags a specific pannelist and if the presenter also went on a 10 minute monologue criticalof said panelists, well that is poor from the national broadcaster.

Seperate the politics and party from it and it shouldn't be done towards any panelist at any time.
 
This isn't about that though, if and again I say if it is true that prior to broadcast the bbc deliberately targeted it's warm up gags a specific pannelist and if the presenter also went on a 10 minute monologue criticalof said panelists, well that is poor from the national broadcaster.

Seperate the politics and party from it and it shouldn't be done towards any panelist at any time.

I dont for a second think Abbott would have took part if that was true, i know i wouldn't have and I'm going to say this would be all over the news right now and not twitter if it happened.

It was an uncomfortable night for both Labour and remain last night so its natural to go on the defensive from some of their supporters i guess.
 
I couldn’t find it on Google or on any reputable site or newspaper, that’s why I asked. No need to get like that just because I asked for a source.

For what it’s worth, I don’t actually think it was Abbott who took the brunt of the criticism last night bar a jibe from the audience and bar being corrected on the polling figures. It was Corbyn’s position on not meeting May. Nevertheless, if Bruce did do that then it was unprofessional even though I thought her in-show performance and questioning was very good.

Yeah bruce is fine only time she was wrong was when she backed up okeshots polling remark, which is inacurate as labour are leading or level with the tories in 4 of the 5 polls conducted this week only in yuogovs are they behind so to remark they are behind in the polls is factually incorrect they are behind in one.

Sorry btw if the remark annoyed you, just my faith in half the stuff that happens politically being reported is very low
 
Last edited:
I dont for a second think Abbott would have took part if that was true, i know i wouldn't have and I'm going to say this would be all over the news right now and not twitter if it happened.

It was an uncomfortable night for both Labour and remain last night so its natural to go on the defensive from some of their supporters i guess.

I don't give a toss if it was labour, tory, ukip, monster raving looney part, brexit, remain etc.
I am not defending labour or abbots ability just saying IF it happened then it is bad for a national broadcaster to do it.

Also it wouldn't be reported if it happened except by the audience there, were the torie councilors and tgw originator of the gamon remark prior to the GE on there reported? No it only came out on social media about them.
 
Yeah bruce is fine only time she was wrong was when she backed up okeshots polling remark, which is inacurate as labour are leading or level with the tories in 4 of the 5 polls conducted this week only in yuogovs are they behind so to remark tgey are bhins i the polls is factually incorrect they are behind in one.

I didn’t know that. That’s very misleading if true and she should have corrected herself or clarified the situation.
 
I don't give a toss if it was labour, tory, ukip, monster raving looney part, brexit, remain etc.
I am not defending labour or abbots ability just saying IF it happened then it is bad for a national broadcaster to do it.

Also it wouldn't be reported if it happened except by the audience there, were the torie councilors and tgw originator of the gamon remark prior to the GE on there reported? No it only came out on social media about them.

Mate, you're wasting your time.
 
Mate, you're wasting your time.

So are you without proof other than a few tweets im afraid.

Justice wont be found on Bluemoon and those who feel she was bullied and have the proof should contact the BBC and report it.
 
I think deflection tactics by supporters of a party or person are hardly new but back in the real world abbot did badly due to the incoherent stance of her party and her total lack of honesty.
 
I think deflection tactics by supporters of a party or person are hardly new but back in the real world abbot did badly due to the incoherent stance of her party and her total lack of honesty.

People are not deflecting or saying Abbot is any good, this mornings conversation was about bbc practices, not trying to defend labour or bash tories, problem is there is no objectivity on here or anywhere atm.
 
I think deflection tactics by supporters of a party or person are hardly new but back in the real world abbot did badly due to the incoherent stance of her party and her total lack of honesty.

Well three different people have come forward so far with photo evidence of being there from tv shots.

I'm sure we'll find out soon enough, but it's interesting to see which posters are so quick to put out the flames. Of course, when I say interesting what I really mean is bloody obvious.

Let's wait and see.
 
People are not deflecting or saying Abbot is any good, this mornings conversation was about bbc practices, not trying to defend labour or bash tories, problem is there is no objectivity on here or anywhere atm.

Agreed. No-one is trying to make it about Diane Abbot, or Labour, or Tories, or vote or leave etc. It's about the conduct of the BBC.

Edit: Of course it's 'about Abbott' but not about her ability as a pm or to answer questions on a panel show.
 
Well three different people have come forward so far with photo evidence of being there from tv shots.

I'm sure we'll find out soon enough, but it's interesting to see which posters are so quick to put out the flames. Of course, when I say interesting what I really mean is bloody obvious.

Let's wait and see.

Can you share the tweets mate?

Im not on twitter.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top