Rate Mancini out of 5 in catergories

[Nelly's Left Foot]

Please could you explain a good example of his man management which makes him 5 out of 5. Or maybe you have misunderstood the marking system.

Sure, i think Mancini is seriously good emotional and mental Coach. He can build and lead a Team with 26+ Players, difficult Characters included. Roberto simply has these "talking" qualities, guess you got a picture of what I mean.

Therefore, the Topic Starter separates Tactics from Man management i can give 5 of 5 for it. The tactics, subs are something else.

Sorry but I asked for an example and all you have done is generalise. I believe you are totally wrong and there are no examples of where he has shown himself to be a good man manager. Getting rid of every player who doesn't agree with his approach is not imo good man management.

 

[King Geedorah]

Lol whereas having your Captain hand in a transfer request, SWP's treatment, Balotelli not giving a fuck all season and now Milner (known as a true professional) throwing a wobbler shows Mancini does?

Tevez left his old club in similar circumstances (One minute happy the next not), SWP was treated the same at his old club and Balotelli was the same at his old club. Milner is frustrated with himself more than anything.

 

[Dave Ewing's Back 'eader]

Tactics 4
Substitutions 4
Man management skills 4
Media skills 5

17/20

Just left him with a route to improvement next season.

 

[King Geedorah]

Sorry but I asked for an example and all you have done is generalise. I believe you are totally wrong and there are no examples of where he has shown himself to be a good man manager. Getting rid of every player who doesn't agree with his approach is not imo good man management.

- Adam Johnson has actually become a serious goal threat under Mancini's man management
- Richards has regained his confidence and largely cut out the mistakes that have plagued his past
- Tevez was integrated BACK into the team very well with minimal fuss
- Hart no longer has doubts about his future at the club
- Boyata came back after the Arsenal game without losing confidence in his own ability and was well managed through the semi finals last year
- Balotelli hasn't turned against him after his comments and still maintains he's like a father

There's probably more aswell.

 

[Nelly's Left Foot]

Sorry but I asked for an example and all you have done is generalise. I believe you are totally wrong and there are no examples of where he has shown himself to be a good man manager. Getting rid of every player who doesn't agree with his approach is not imo good man management.

- Adam Johnson has actually become a serious goal threat under Mancini's man management
- Richards has regained his confidence and largely cut out the mistakes that have plagued his past
- Tevez was integrated BACK into the team very well with minimal fuss
- Hart no longer has doubts about his future at the club
- Boyata came back after the Arsenal game without losing confidence in his own ability and was well managed through the semi finals last year
- Balotelli hasn't turned against him after his comments and still maintains he's like a father

There's probably more aswell.

Ok now I know why you gave him 5.I disagree with all of those but never mind that's what opinions are about.

AJ has always been a goal threat and was before we got him
Micah is just getting older.All his mistakes before were down to his immaturity and lack of concentration
Tevez hasn't actually been integrated back into the team imo and still seems very anti Mancini
Hart (your closest) was loaned out correctly before Mancini came.He did make the correct decision to have him as number one.Not actually a tough decision
Boyata not convinced at all.Poorly managed imo including last night where he picked him for a position he is not suited to
Don't get me started on Balo.Allowing him to do what he does and get away with it and still pick him is bordering on negligence

Next he will pick his son in the first team

 

[blueunit]

Tactics - 1
Substitutions - fooking 0
Man management skills- 2
Media skills - 2 sometimes he is good but this is normal

 

[balkanno]

Sure, i think Mancini is seriously good emotional and mental Coach. He can build and lead a Team with 26+ Players, difficult Characters included. Roberto simply has these "talking" qualities, guess you got a picture of what I mean.

Therefore, the Topic Starter separates Tactics from Man management i can give 5 of 5 for it. The tactics, subs are something else.

Sorry but I asked for an example and all you have done is generalise. I believe you are totally wrong and there are no examples of where he has shown himself to be a good man manager. Getting rid of every player who doesn't agree with his approach is not imo good man management.

Well yes i do, thats because i keep my Rating realstic. You cant rate "Man management" every Week different, it must be generalised to the Point.

Example: Last night at Anfield. He had belived in his Squad, putted it arround and tryed to rotate, whats the best Sing of an good "Man management".

He was aible to form a TEAM, thats something with this Players. I belive i can separate this 4 Categories, so i do rate him High at this one.
And getting rid of some Players (Adebayor for Example, huge Payment and high Weekly earnings, no Sport-Money Vault quality) can bring some positive Things for a the other Players who are in the Team.

I allways seen Mancini fair, i belive is the guy who ask the Players how their Kids are doing, how they do live and stuff, which connects People and thats the most important Thing at this Categorie. Like i sayd he is really a good mental and emotional Coach, thats not questionable.

But, the Tactical Setup and the Gameplan doesnt have a stright line, the Players are playing for 18 Mo. together and didnt managed to build automatics, that a working Squad has to have. The missing line in the Midfield is just bolding that Point.

Once again, you have to separate booth, "Man management" is hard to rate, harder than Tactics or something whats obivous at the Telescreen.

However, whats your critic at that Point? Describe your Opinion there, it cant be just because he didnt wanted a Player.

 

[Didsbury Dave]

Sorry but I asked for an example and all you have done is generalise. I believe you are totally wrong and there are no examples of where he has shown himself to be a good man manager. Getting rid of every player who doesn't agree with his approach is not imo good man management.

- Adam Johnson has actually become a serious goal threat under Mancini's man management
- Richards has regained his confidence and largely cut out the mistakes that have plagued his past
- Tevez was integrated BACK into the team very well with minimal fuss
- Hart no longer has doubts about his future at the club
- Boyata came back after the Arsenal game without losing confidence in his own ability and was well managed through the semi finals last year
- Balotelli hasn't turned against him after his comments and still maintains he's like a father

There's probably more aswell.

You don't know what you are talking about.

If you asked all of those players what they think of Mancini what do you think they'd say?

 

[King Geedorah]

You don't know what you are talking about.

If you asked all of those players what they think of Mancini what do you think they'd say?

Doesn't matter what they think of him because it's not a popularity contest.

I have however seen Johnson add goals to his game, Richards go from strength to strength, Tevez come back into the team, Hart no longer question his future, Boyata go into two huge games and perform. Of course we can argue whether this is down to Mancini or just the players but equally that argument lifts the blame off his shoulders when players go wrong.

Ok now I know why you gave him 5.I disagree with all of those but never mind that's what opinions are about.

AJ has always been a goal threat and was before we got him
Micah is just getting older.All his mistakes before were down to his immaturity and lack of concentration
Tevez hasn't actually been integrated back into the team imo and still seems very anti Mancini
Hart (your closest) was loaned out correctly before Mancini came.He did make the correct decision to have him as number one.Not actually a tough decision
Boyata not convinced at all.Poorly managed imo including last night where he picked him for a position he is not suited to
Don't get me started on Balo.Allowing him to do what he does and get away with it and still pick him is bordering on negligence

Next he will pick his son in the first team

I haven't given him a 5 at all, keep up. I acknowledge he man managed Adebayor god awfully and could've dealt with some of the dissidents poorly.

Like I said to Dave hard to argue when anything positive is down to the player and anything negative to the manager. I will concede Balo is highly debateable and could have a whole sub section about possible interpretations of things. I will say however it took balls to bring him in and that decision alone shows how forward thinking the man is.

 

[Jackson-ctid]

There's only 2 managers in the league I'd rather have over Mancini and thats baconface and wenger.