You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
re: the penalty appeals tonight
- Thread starter pardoe
- Start date
mcfc_die_hard
Well-Known Member
nothing wrong with a dive now and again
buckshot
Well-Known Member
When a player handles the ball and intercepts a pass in the box it should be a penalty.
blumoonrisen
Well-Known Member
I had a good view of 2 def handballs, prob not intentional but I've seen em given for less.
Nothin wrong with appealing anyway, you never know.
Nothin wrong with appealing anyway, you never know.
Carl_Man_City
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 2 Jan 2009
- Messages
- 1,932
There isn't a team in the league who would have appealed for them
A
A
Anonymous
Guest
There were defo two pens tonight. The hand ball by Cauldwell and the trip on Tevez both in the second half.
smithy167 said:Give it a rest, who gives a fuck if its a pen or not get behind the team shout for every pen or hand ball, i do, we all should, you ever been away for a game?
Grow up, you absolute plum.
Who cares if it's a penalty, i do. Though i'm sure we'd all turn a blind eye every now and again, and officiating inconsistencies can effect our judgement, i'd like us to win and lose fairly. If we deserve a pen i'd like to see them given, when we concede them i hope the ref made the right call and we learn from our mistakes.
Overall, as with lots of people, i just want to see good, fair football. If you're one of these sorts who wants us to win at any costs then i feel a bit sorry for you.
Been going home and away for fifteen years, not that that's any real business of yours. First impressions of you is that you're one of this new breed of gobby and undeserving Blues. Have a look at yourself, ffs.
super_city_si
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 29 Dec 2007
- Messages
- 54,372
I thought 3 of them were good shouts. 2 definite handballs and scharner left his leg up to trip Tevez.
Put it this way, at 3 or 4 other grounds in the league there would have been at least 1 pen if not 2.
Put it this way, at 3 or 4 other grounds in the league there would have been at least 1 pen if not 2.
law74
Well-Known Member
But the tug on Ade's shirt inside the box wasnt?Immaculate Pasta said:There were defo two pens tonight. The hand ball by Cauldwell and the trip on Tevez both in the second half.
A
A
Anonymous
Guest
law74 said:But the tug on Ade's shirt inside the box wasnt?Immaculate Pasta said:There were defo two pens tonight. The hand ball by Cauldwell and the trip on Tevez both in the second half.
Three then, forgot about that.
Carlos would of had 6 tonight then!!
ardwickboy
Well-Known Member
Give over, the teams at the top always appeal, that's the reason they get all them penalties and free kicks just outside the area.pardoe said:bloody embarrasing.
at a push one might've been worthy of a spot-kick.
Your full of shit, fair football lol dream world comes to mind, you the sort of fan we need to shake off imo.pardoe said:smithy167 said:Give it a rest, who gives a fuck if its a pen or not get behind the team shout for every pen or hand ball, i do, we all should, you ever been away for a game?
Grow up, you absolute plum.
Who cares if it's a penalty, i do. Though i'm sure we'd all turn a blind eye every now and again, and officiating inconsistencies can effect our judgement, i'd like us to win and lose fairly. If we deserve a pen i'd like to see them given, when we concede them i hope the ref made the right call and we learn from our mistakes.
Overall, as with lots of people, i just want to see good, fair football. If you're one of these sorts who wants us to win at any costs then i feel a bit sorry for you.
Been going home and away for fifteen years, not that that's any real business of yours. First impressions of you is that you're one of this new breed of gobby and undeserving Blues. Have a look at yourself, ffs.
Bluemoon115
Well-Known Member
Oh shut up.
Any set of fans would appeal for them, stop being so bloody dramatic.
Any set of fans would appeal for them, stop being so bloody dramatic.
Bluemoon115 said:Oh shut up.
Any set of fans would appeal for them, stop being so bloody dramatic.
I counted nine.
Any set of fans would appeal for nine pens in one game? Hmmmm.
Bluemoon115
Well-Known Member
Don't blame others, it's not their fault you can't count.pardoe said:I counted nine.
smithy167 said:Your full of shit, fair football lol dream world comes to mind, you the sort of fan we need to shake off imo.
Daft c*nt, can't spell.
Some of us still believe in the beautiful game. Seriously. I want every side that City put out to play in the right spirit, and for that attitude to be true of our support, too. That doesn't mean I'm not annoyed when opposition don't play by the rules or officials make errors.
Maybe I'm just not of this generation whose opinions change with the wind and who pride themselves on being professional nobheads, but I'd rather we go about our business with dignity. Cheers.
blumoonrisen
Well-Known Member
pardoe said:smithy167 said:Give it a rest, who gives a fuck if its a pen or not get behind the team shout for every pen or hand ball, i do, we all should, you ever been away for a game?
Grow up, you absolute plum.
Who cares if it's a penalty, i do. Though i'm sure we'd all turn a blind eye every now and again, and officiating inconsistencies can effect our judgement, i'd like us to win and lose fairly. If we deserve a pen i'd like to see them given, when we concede them i hope the ref made the right call and we learn from our mistakes.
Overall, as with lots of people, i just want to see good, fair football. If you're one of these sorts who wants us to win at any costs then i feel a bit sorry for you.
Been going home and away for fifteen years, not that that's any real business of yours. First impressions of you is that you're one of this new breed of gobby and undeserving Blues. Have a look at yourself, ffs.
I agree with smithy167.. that make me a new breed of gobby and undeserving Blue...?!!
markbmcfc
Well-Known Member
pardoe said:smithy167 said:Give it a rest, who gives a fuck if its a pen or not get behind the team shout for every pen or hand ball, i do, we all should, you ever been away for a game?
Grow up, you absolute plum.
Who cares if it's a penalty, i do. Though i'm sure we'd all turn a blind eye every now and again, and officiating inconsistencies can effect our judgement, i'd like us to win and lose fairly. If we deserve a pen i'd like to see them given, when we concede them i hope the ref made the right call and we learn from our mistakes.
Overall, as with lots of people, i just want to see good, fair football. If you're one of these sorts who wants us to win at any costs then i feel a bit sorry for you.
Been going home and away for fifteen years, not that that's any real business of yours. First impressions of you is that you're one of this new breed of gobby and undeserving Blues. Have a look at yourself, ffs.
For some reason your a little short of support in this thread.
Personally I totally agree with you. I'd 'take' getting a dodgy pen now and again but id rather us play good, fair football and win the game that way.
Quite agree with your perception of that Smithy fellow as well, he strikes me as a silly little chav with a big mouth.
I wouldnt say the appeals were pathetic however, the only point of yours I disagree with, there were a couple that at first glance I thought we're pens, until i got home and watched them again and was proved wrong in a few cases.