Rock Evolution – The History of Rock & Roll - Rock & Roll (pg 47)

RobMCFC said:
That's OK, we'll just re-organise everything behind your back :)

Looks like it's going to be a quiet week in here!
Click to expand...
Ha I feel very unqualified to comment. I do like the earlier stuff you've posted as opposed to the Nashville sound later stuff. The earlier work feels more real because it lacks the polish of the Reeves and Cline stuff. It sounds better but is less appealing

It's not super relevant to the discussion but I did wonder if the advance of technology shaped the sound or if the sound demanded the technology? For example the Beatles seemed to be inspired by the technology they used but they also inspired some of the technology to be created. Same with Bing Crosby who kind of created non-live TV because he didn't want to have to film his show twice. It also meant they could fake audience interaction and edit the bad takes out.

Then because the technology allows more polish does it make it more accessible to casual fans of the genre but ultimately less loved?
 
mrbelfry said:
Ha I feel very unqualified to comment. I do like the earlier stuff you've posted as opposed to the Nashville sound later stuff. The earlier work feels more real because it lacks the polish of the Reeves and Cline stuff. It sounds better but is less appealing

It's not super relevant to the discussion but I did wonder if the advance of technology shaped the sound or if the sound demanded the technology? For example the Beatles seemed to be inspired by the technology they used but they also inspired some of the technology to be created. Same with Bing Crosby who kind of created non-live TV because he didn't want to have to film his show twice. It also meant they could fake audience interaction and edit the bad takes out.

Then because the technology allows more polish does it make it more accessible to casual fans of the genre but ultimately less loved?
Click to expand...
Yes, that's a good observation Re: the difference between the original country sound and Nashville Sound. It's something the roots musicians have been trying to get back to over the last 30 or 40 years - a subject that will no doubt crop up in our discussions of future years.

I find the Jimmie Rodgers and Woody Guthrie songs fascinating from a historical perspective, but they are not the kind of thing that I could listen to too often. Now Bill Monroe's music on the other hand sounds fresh and exciting even though it is nearly 80 years old.

As for the technology, I think it's great when it's used to produce a clearer recording but not so great when it starts to overwhelm the music. Again, something else that will be interesting to listen out for as the thread progresses.
 
RobMCFC said:
That's OK, we'll just re-organise everything behind your back :)

Looks like it's going to be a quiet week in here!
Click to expand...

I'm afraid I'm back!

I had quite an enjoyable time listening to a greatest 50's Country music playlist last night as it's an era I have limited familiarity with.

One person I was very familiar with though was the Man in Black who I don't think has actually come up yet?

As a youngster I didn't really get him or his voice but now I think it's one of the great elemental sounds of post war popular music.

The late 50s were his first big era and tbh we could pick virtually anything off his debut but I'm going to be obvious:

Folsom Prison Blues - Johnny Cash

Though in fairness it wasn't a single and it would be a few years before we'd hear that famous 'Hello, I'm Johnny Cash' intro to it at Folsom.

Is rockabilly really country ? Not sure, but don't care! What a voice, what a performer, what a life!
 
I've been toying with buying the book 26 Songs in 30 Days for a while so this thread has tipped me over the edge.

I've always thought Woodie Guthrie's stint employed by the BPA to write about all things related to the Grand Coulee Dam and all things Hydro, was a slightly bizarre way to end with a number of folk classics but at another level it makes total sense.
Gets great reviews but I will report back as and when I'm done.
 
threespires said:
I'm afraid I'm back!

I had quite an enjoyable time listening to a greatest 50's Country music playlist last night as it's an era I have limited familiarity with.

One person I was very familiar with though was the Man in Black who I don't think has actually come up yet?

As a youngster I didn't really get him or his voice but now I think it's one of the great elemental sounds of post war popular music.

The late 50s were his first big era and tbh we could pick virtually anything off his debut but I'm going to be obvious:

Folsom Prison Blues - Johnny Cash

Though in fairness it wasn't a single and it would be a few years before we'd hear that famous 'Hello, I'm Johnny Cash' intro to it at Folsom.

Is rockabilly really country ? Not sure, but don't care! What a voice, what a performer, what a life!
Click to expand...
The Man in Black was indeed in an earlier cut of my list but I thought I'd leave the door open for somebody.

I always thought that this song was from the late 60s but I guess that's just me associating it with the At Folsom Prison live album.

This is definitely country - I think that rockabilly crosses over between country and Rock and Roll and is therefore fair game for this week. Great choice. Listening to this highlights the difference between "original country" (for want of a better term) and "The Nashville Sound".
 
RobMCFC said:
The Man in Black was indeed in an earlier cut of my list but I thought I'd leave the door open for somebody.

I always thought that this song was from the late 60s but I guess that's just me associating it with the At Folsom Prison live album.

This is definitely country - I think that rockabilly crosses over between country and Rock and Roll and is therefore fair game for this week. Great choice. Listening to this highlights the difference between "original country" (for want of a better term) and "The Nashville Sound".
Click to expand...
JC's musical origins were probably in Gospel / folk, which is maybe ' original country?...Gospel should sit in here somewhere perhaps as an 'origin' music rather than a flok offshoot?
 
RobMCFC said:
The Man in Black was indeed in an earlier cut of my list but I thought I'd leave the door open for somebody.

I always thought that this song was from the late 60s but I guess that's just me associating it with the At Folsom Prison live album.

This is definitely country - I think that rockabilly crosses over between country and Rock and Roll and is therefore fair game for this week. Great choice. Listening to this highlights the difference between "original country" (for want of a better term) and "The Nashville Sound".
Click to expand...

Yeah, that album and moment is so iconic but the song itself was written in '55. Cash wanted to go into Folsom much earlier but Colombia Records weren't having it I think.

On the subject of his prison concerts did you know that Granada TV was responsible for the San Quentin show?!
 
I've been having a root around to find some examples of British Folk Music from this period - to see how it was developed from the time when Cecil Sharp and others were collecting and the 1950's Folk Revival led by people like Ewan MacColl and AL Lloyd. I thought at first that any playlist would need go via classical music - Henry Woods' Fantasia on British sea Songs that you will hear every year at the Last Night of the Proms or anything by Ralph Vaughan Williams.

The other place to look is in Hymn Tunes, many of which took standard folk tunes and set them to found or newly written words - although what this period of collecting did was standardise tunes. For instances once "Whilst Shepherds Watched" had been printed alongside the tune "Winchester Old" in 1861 it became the only tune that many people sang it to - even though in many places it was sung to a different tune in every village. A tradition maintained in Sheffield and North Derbyshire.

But then I came across the Carpenter archive https://archives.vwml.org/records/JMC/1 - filled with notes and original disc/cylinder recordings from 1928-1972. I haven't got a clue how you fit it into a playlist - but anyone wanting to hear how folk music had developed by mid-20th century - this is amazing.
 
Resurrection Joe... said:
JC's musical origins were probably in Gospel / folk, which is maybe ' original country?...Gospel should sit in here somewhere perhaps as an 'origin' music rather than a flok offshoot?
Click to expand...
Tricky - we weren’t attempting to cover every type of music pre-1960, just the main genres that contributed to what came next in the 1960. It feels to me that gospel would fit more in the blues/jazz genres, but as we’ve had these, maybe next week’s pop playlist?

threespires said:
Yeah, that album and moment is so iconic but the song itself was written in '55. Cash wanted to go into Folsom much earlier but Colombia Records weren't having it I think.

On the subject of his prison concerts did you know that Granada TV was responsible for the San Quentin show?!
Click to expand...
Well they did the documentary so it makes sense.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
✖
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.