Samir Nasri or David Silva

[Astuteboy]

Honestly Silva for me, although they are different players.

Nasri is having his best season yet in the PL by far, but in terms of overall class and quality, Silva wins.

How dare you say that?

Also, Joe Hart is clearly crap, he never scores... :(

Haha, so true. I find the blue-tinted specs thing a bit weird, it assumes people who rate Silva haven't seen him play before he joined us.

Like a lot of others on this thread I'm sure, I'd seen plenty of Silva both in and for Spain before he came here and that's one of the reasons I know he's a better player.

Would the current Nasri get in the Euro 2008 Spain team (best international team for a generation imo)? Not a chance.

Form is temporary, class is permanent and all that.

 

[binitd]

silva coz we are city fans