bluebean
Well-Known Member
The truth is at present nasri by a mile, however silva is in his first season and has all the attributes to be better than nasri
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Samir Nasri or David Silva
- Thread starter BlueSinceBirth
- Start date
GStar
Well-Known Member
Nasri had to be the focal point of the team when Cesc and RVP we're out of the side and he no doubt excelled.
I reckon he'll have a much quieter second half of the season now the other two are back in the starting XI.
Silva needs to add goals to his game on a more regular basis, as i think his range of passing and his vision is above Nasri's.
I reckon he'll have a much quieter second half of the season now the other two are back in the starting XI.
Silva needs to add goals to his game on a more regular basis, as i think his range of passing and his vision is above Nasri's.
GStar said:Nasri had to be the focal point of the team when Cesc and RVP we're out of the side and he no doubt excelled.
I reckon he'll have a much quieter second half of the season now the other two are back in the starting XI.
Silva needs to add goals to his game on a more regular basis, as i think his range of passing and his vision is above Nasri's.
I think you are right about Davids passing being better than Nasri but the rest if his game i.e the scoring and assists I dont think we should be expecting much more from our David.If you look at his record he has never been prolific and managed about the same as the rest of the team.For me he seems the type of player that can make sure we keep posession by making the odd killer pass but generally just keeping it simple.
Rag-hater said:GStar said:Nasri had to be the focal point of the team when Cesc and RVP we're out of the side and he no doubt excelled.
I reckon he'll have a much quieter second half of the season now the other two are back in the starting XI.
Silva needs to add goals to his game on a more regular basis, as i think his range of passing and his vision is above Nasri's.
I think you are right about Davids passing being better than Nasri but the rest if his game i.e the scoring and assists I dont think we should be expecting much more from our David.If you look at his record he has never been prolific and managed about the same as the rest of the team.For me he seems the type of player that can make sure we keep posession by making the odd killer pass but generally just keeping it simple.
Clearly you haven't even watch one little minute of Silva when he played with Villa at Valencia. I mean not even a single minute...
brooklandsblue2.0
Well-Known Member
I really don't seem to see all the fuss with Silva-he's anonymous in so many games, and exceptional in a few. I would like more consistency
BoyBlue_1985
Well-Known Member
Really not a debate, i believe Nasri will win player of the year the way he is going. Silva is only a few months in but given time to settle will match or maybe even surpass Nari but at the moment its not even a debate and anyone who thinks it is needs to take the blue tinted specs off
wanderer72
Well-Known Member
Astuteboy said:Honestly Silva for me, although they are different players.
Nasri is having his best season yet in the PL by far, but in terms of overall class and quality, Silva wins.
How dare you say that?
Also, Joe Hart is clearly crap, he never scores... :(
the blue panther
Well-Known Member
Absolutely no doubt whatsoever - it has to be Silva.
(But as soon as I take off my blue tinted specs and see the way that Nasri scores goals and can change a game - which Silva has hardly done so far, good player though he is, with better to come we hope - it has to be Nasri)
(But as soon as I take off my blue tinted specs and see the way that Nasri scores goals and can change a game - which Silva has hardly done so far, good player though he is, with better to come we hope - it has to be Nasri)