Scottish Football Thread | 2024/25

[No.8]

I’ve got to applaud the Hearts support. At Ibrox last night their large away support had just burst into song when over the tannoy the veterans from Erskine Hospital were introduced and were going to lead the teams out and the song ‘ Sing For The Boys’ came on. They immediately stopped their song and applauded with some joining in the ‘Jimmy Spears’ song. A credit to their club and I just wish this got the headlines rather than the shameful scenes from Rugby park.

 

[Magicpole]

I saw the Hatate challenge on Sportscene. I know we are conditioned to just accept this kind of thing when they are playing but that’s not even up for debate. As clear a Red card as you’ll see.

I did have a wee laugh at the ever impartial Beeb trying to even things up with the Killie player brushing his arm into the Celtic keepers chest. Why did the Keeper go down holding his face. Fucking pathetic and embarrassing.

What about Idah getting elbowed in the face? Did you miss that?

 

[eyalluvitt]

What about Idah getting elbowed in the face? Did you miss that?

Killie v Celtc, brief highlights

That’s After chanting IRA songs to halt a minutes silence yet again

 

[No.8]

What about Idah getting elbowed in the face? Did you miss that?

Didn’t see it.

I only wanted to see the Hatate challenge and whilst watching the summarising of that they showed incident with Celtic keeper.

 

[ayrshire_blue]

I saw the Hatate challenge on Sportscene. I know we are conditioned to just accept this kind of thing when they are playing but that’s not even up for debate. As clear a Red card as you’ll see.

I did have a wee laugh at the ever impartial Beeb trying to even things up with the Killie player brushing his arm into the Celtic keepers chest. Why did the Keeper go down holding his face. Fucking pathetic and embarrassing.

The keeper should have been booked for that. He's not even been touched and certainly not his face. Maeda had at least 2 fouls in the first half which were both worthy of a yellow card, but got off with both somehow. His foul on Kennedy in particular was a joke.

They've benefitted from so many big decisions against Killie over last few seasons - the cup semi final shove in injury time, Alastair Johnston playing basketball on his goal line, their opening goal at the end of last season when we had a man down with a head injury from an obvious foul.

The Hatate one is another to add to the ever growing list. I thought it was yellow from inside the ground, but I didn't have the benefit of VAR and having seen it back it's a very clear red.

 

[No.8]

The keeper should have been booked for that. He's not even been touched and certainly not his face. Maeda had at least 2 fouls in the first half which were both worthy of a yellow card, but got off with both somehow. His foul on Kennedy in particular was a joke.

They've benefitted from so many big decisions against Killie over last few seasons - the cup semi final shove in injury time, Alastair Johnston playing basketball on his goal line, their opening goal at the end of last season when we had a man down with a head injury from an obvious foul.

The Hatate one is another to add to the ever growing list. I thought it was yellow from inside the ground, but I didn't have the benefit of VAR and having seen it back it's a very clear red.

I remember the penalty in Cup game. Pretty sure it was Willie Collum but I could be wrong

The Johnstone one was actually a World class save if it’s the one where he dived full and twisted in midair to save the ball on the line

I can’t understand how Hagis the other week can be a Red and Hatates not. Neither player is intentionally trying to injure opponent but both are high ( Hatates much higher) and late and are endangering opponent. Both clear Reds

 

[Magicpole]

Didn’t see it.

I only wanted to see the Hatate challenge and whilst watching the summarising of that they showed incident with Celtic keeper.

Well it happened. Hatate was a booking. There wasn’t excessive force. There was with the elbow, deliberate, but, never mind that, just pile on to us. Just as well we know the form and don’t give a fuck as it lets us know how fucking sick of being utter shite themselves, they are. We move on.

 

[No.8]

Well it happened. Hatate was a booking. There wasn’t excessive force. There was with the elbow, deliberate, but, never mind that, just pile on to us. Just as well we know the form and don’t give a fuck as it lets us know how fucking sick of being utter shite themselves, they are. We move on.

Oh dear…..

 

[MadchesterCity]

I saw the Hatate challenge on Sportscene. I know we are conditioned to just accept this kind of thing when they are playing but that’s not even up for debate. As clear a Red card as you’ll see.

I did have a wee laugh at the ever impartial Beeb trying to even things up with the Killie player brushing his arm into the Celtic keepers chest. Why did the Keeper go down holding his face. Fucking pathetic and embarrassing.

Tasty tattle gets away with murder, Kyoto aswell, that **** should’ve been sent off for kicking out off the ball in semi final against Aberdeen, but instead he gets every decision, he’s a right little ****

 

[MadchesterCity]

Maybe we could bring in strict liability and actually punish clubs directly for their fan’s behaviour. Only then will you see things starting to improve.

If supporters thought their club was going to lose points / stand closures as a result of some attention seeking clown’s behaviour then self policing would kick in and that’s the only way to tackle the problems in our game!

Maybe then other clubs would be more accommodating. Magic is correct that half empty stadiums are not helping anybody and the more we can do to tackle that problem the better. Before you jump on me I want to see Rugby Park full of Killie fans, Dens full of Dundee fans , Easter Road burnt to the ground

I’d dock them 3 points every time they wave that terrorist supporting Palestine flag, keep politics and hate out of football