Scottish Football Thread | 2024/25

[MadchesterCity]

I remember the penalty in Cup game. Pretty sure it was Willie Collum but I could be wrong

The Johnstone one was actually a World class save if it’s the one where he dived full and twisted in midair to save the ball on the line

I can’t understand how Hagis the other week can be a Red and Hatates not. Neither player is intentionally trying to injure opponent but both are high ( Hatates much higher) and late and are endangering opponent. Both clear Reds

I don’t think he’s bent, he’s just a terrible referee

 

[No.8]

I’d dock them 3 points every time they wave that terrorist supporting Palestine flag, keep politics and hate out of football

Self policing is the only way supporters will change. There are so many self entitled wee Fannie’s and especially within the Old Firm supports who simply do not care if their actions result in a club fine

UBs recently held up a banner ‘You worry about thousands while wasting millions’ in reference to the club asking supporters not to use pyros during European games!

I’d add the fines onto their season tickets. Maybe if they were hit directly in the pocket they’d learn

 

[No.8]

I don’t think he’s bent, he’s just a terrible referee

There are two referees I believe are biased and they are Clancy and Robertson.

The rest are much of a muchness with possibly Nick Walsh being the pick of them

Collum is a Celtic supporter so it’s only natural that he’ll see certain subjective decisions differently than a Rangers fan would. I’m sure he did his best to keep it out his game

 

[ayrshire_blue]

Well it happened. Hatate was a booking. There wasn’t excessive force. There was with the elbow, deliberate, but, never mind that, just pile on to us. Just as well we know the form and don’t give a fuck as it lets us know how fucking sick of being utter shite themselves, they are. We move on.

Are you on about this? Red card my arse, he's not even looking at the guy. Sticks his arm up to jump as leverage and catches him. Deliberate elbow? Give me a break. The only thing that twitter guy's put up which is worthy of a red is Hatate, it's serious foul play every day of the week and twice on a Sunday. Just can't go in that high with studs up.

 

[MadchesterCity]

There are two referees I believe are biased and they are Clancy and Robertson.

The rest are much of a muchness with possibly Nick Walsh being the pick of them

Collum is a Celtic supporter so it’s only natural that he’ll see certain subjective decisions differently than a Rangers fan would. I’m sure he did his best to keep it out his game

Beaton is a Rangers fan also and shouldn’t be allowed to referee Aberdeen matches imho

 

[No.8]

Beaton is a Rangers fan also and shouldn’t be allowed to referee Aberdeen matches imho

According to his pal Tam Cowan he’s a Motherwell fan

His officiating of the Rangers 2-3 Hibs is the most blatantly biased I’ve seen in 50 + years

Google a picture of the Darren McGregor tackle on Morelos. Better still try and get a video of it and try explaining that one hahahaha. Morelos through on goal. McGregor flying rugby tackle round his neck = foul to Hibs

 

[No.8]

Are you on about this? Red card my arse, he's not even looking at the guy. Sticks his arm up to jump as leverage and catches him. Deliberate elbow? Give me a break. The only thing that twitter guy's put up which is worthy of a red is Hatate, it's serious foul play every day of the week and twice on a Sunday. Just can't go in that high with studs up.

There is certainly something about Killie and contentious decisions this season.

Idah one is a sore one but completely accidental. Similar to the Red given to a player recently in a game against Killie

High boot with Ralston again is a sore one but both players going for the ball and boot is not unnaturally high.

Scheimchel one gets more embarrassing every time you see it.

Hatate one is as straight forward a Red as you will see. I’m sure Collum will be a long shortly to apologise and if not I’ll be asking why Hagi was Red carded for a lesser challenge

 

[Magicpole]

Are you on about this? Red card my arse, he's not even looking at the guy. Sticks his arm up to jump as leverage and catches him. Deliberate elbow? Give me a break. The only thing that twitter guy's put up which is worthy of a red is Hatate, it's serious foul play every day of the week and twice on a Sunday. Just can't go in that high with studs up.

Did you ever play football? He knew he was there. We will agree to disagree about what he did. When you have to get height, you don’t push your elbow at a right angle. If you have played at any level you would know that.

 

[Magicpole]

According to his pal Tam Cowan he’s a Motherwell fan

His officiating of the Rangers 2-3 Hibs is the most blatantly biased I’ve seen in 50 + years

Google a picture of the Darren McGregor tackle on Morelos. Better still try and get a video of it and try explaining that one hahahaha. Morelos through on goal. McGregor flying rugby tackle round his neck = foul to Hibs

If Beaton is a Motherwell fan, I’m a Rangers fan. Motherwell fan my arse. His school year book tells a different story. Pity things like that still exist.

 

[No.8]

If Beaton is a Motherwell fan, I’m a Rangers fan. Motherwell fan my arse. His school year book tells a different story. Pity things like that still exist.

I’ve seen the year book. My accountant claims to know him and says he’s a ‘Hun’ … of course there is photoshop

I’m just going by what Tam Cowan said on Radio Scotland. I know they are friends and there is no reason for him to lie

The subject was brought up when Ross County complained a St Johnstone supporter had refereed an important game near the end of last season

Remember Bobby Madden was called Bobby Madhun and everyone , including myself , believing he was a Rangers fan only for him to retire and admit he’s a St Mirren supporter