Skashion said:
Not convinced at all Dave.
I promise if you spent a season sitting at the opposite end of the ground you would be. Or even just a big game; There are regular moments in a big game where songs naturally start, and both City ends, and often the opposition, start a different song at the same time.
That's why you often get better communal singing when there are fewer, or quiet, away fans. Or later in a game when songs are starting less frequently, so the two singing ends can actually hear each other.
The height of the roof, and the fact that the singing starts at ground level and not at that back, means the noise and sings lift and collect upwards, not outwards. They aren't anything like as audible from other parts of the stadium as you think. They don't "project" like they did at Maine Road or like you hear at places like Spurs and Stoke.
Wembley had the saqme problem actually. For large parts of our games there all you could hear was a wall of noise from the City fans rather than defined songs. Having tiers makes it much worse too.