Didsbury Dave said:
I'll tell you why the club don't do anything:
They don't understand the history of the stadium and the Maine Road stands. They don't realise that songs from the South Stand will never catch on around the grund because on the one side they have the old Main Stand, who aren't the singing types. On the other side they have the away fans who make sure that the other side of the ground don't hear them.
Also, the club don't believe the demand is there because of the people who actually sit in the singing ends. When you are in there you think the atmosphere is great. What you don't realise is that a great atmosphere is not 300 lads singing "WHo's the faggot in the pink?", it's a whole stadium booming a song.
So when this debate comes up, the people who are passionately for it are the ones who sit in the main stadium itself rather than the singing areas. These people realise that if a song starts up loud and defined enough it will drift downt he East Stand Side and often get the whole ground going. that's why the better atmospehres at COMS tend to be once the singing and excitement has died a bit. When things are at fever pitch in the stadium all you can hear is a mud of noise - "We are Not really standing alone till I die" from the 2 City ends, and the away fans together.
When both singing areas sing together it will not catch on round the ground.
But the people who sit in the singing areas don't realise this, they think that it's just the rest of the ground being "boring". It isn't.
Sorry, I could go on all day about this. This would make a big difference to our entire club, probably even the performacnes on the field.
You've absolutely nailed it there mate.
I've been banging the drum about the siting of the away fans since we moved from Maine Road.
It's only the blues in the singing section and half of the south stand that struggle to see the benefits of relocating the away fans. Most of them believe the atmosphere isn't an issue, but they only get an extremely narrow perspective of a sample of the atmosphere at each game. They can only hear their own voices.
It's the rest of us, who sit more centrally, or in the northern half of the ground, who get a true and accurate perception of the atmosphere on a match day.
90% of games at home consist of around 500 in the singing section consistently doing there bit for the entirety of the full 90. While the south stand stands in silence for long periods, until there's a point of interest on the pitch.
The noise rarely travels down the east stand, but when it does, and there are those periods where everyone stands up, the atmosphere improves ten fold. On some occasions it will travel as far as the west corner of the north stand and they'll and stand and sing.
But its too intermittent. All of our consistent noise on a match day comes from the southern half of the ground, and it's usually patchy and inconsistent. In the meantime the rest of us are forced to sit in relative silence until the noise travels the length of the east stand and then we're all jumping over each other to stand and sing.
The atmosphere at CoMS [Etihad], IMO is poor, very poor in fact. It's my single biggest bugbear about all things City, it genuinely frustrates me. Despite always being treated like subhuman scum and criminals wherever you visit when you attend an away fixture, I always greatly enjoy myself - certainly much more than I usually would've in a comparative home fixture, regardless of the result. Because it's authentic football. It's what we used to have at Maine Road, an authenticity. CoMS is sterile. It's essentially dived in two, and in recent seasons the club have began subjecting us to Hugh-fucking-Ferris, the Americanisms and the cheese. It frustrates me. Angers me.
With all the empty surveys City peddle out in an effort to 'improve match day experience', what they're actually continuing to do is make many fans match day 'experiences' close to fucking insufferable in some respects.
The first and most crucial thing the club could do to address our the atmosphere issue, and attract the younger kids is move the away fans. It would have a domino affect.
Ditching Hugh Ferris and the failed Wacky Warehouse Stand would help too.