No I didn't want them to fail! There was definitely a time yesterday where I thought we might not sell out, and I was absolutely furious about this and voiced it. However once the pep announcement came out, and they opened the criteria up we sold out, which I'm glad about.
I truly believe we've got a big enough fanbase in greater Manchester to fill a 65,000 seat stadium week in week out. But we've got to get as many people as possible into the habit of going, and I worry that the current strategy isn't enough to achieve this.
In terms of attendance growth, we peaked after the treble season. Things have been slowly on the decline since then. Anybody who pays close attention to this thread will tell you the exact same thing.
What you’re saying is not even a criticism of the club, it’s just that you care about the connection of the club to the fanbase and you know how important the core local fanbase is.
I’ve said for years that we have a Manchester-conurbation-and-surrounding-areas fanbase to fill a 65k stadium very easily every week. Tickets could easily be hard to come by at a 65k Etihad, if priced right. Yet, half of our games are a slog to sell out, and many don’t.
We expanded the stadium on the back of Pep and his 2017-2024 teams’ successes. The demand was there as we grew the countrywide and worldwide support they wanted to see the Centurions, Fourmidables, treble winners and four-in-a-row Champions. The club went down a route concentrating on ticket tout sites and tourist packages to cater for this influx of new fans but at the same time took the core local support for granted as they kept upping prices.
You can see why they did it; growing the wider fanbase while thinking the local core support would always be there. However, the core local support don’t have money trees in their back yards and thousands have fallen away from attending matches. It’s been especially hard for people with kids, seeing what other big North West clubs have set children’s ticket prices at for a long time: Liverpool £9 for juniors, United £13 for years, yet City had kid’s tickets ranging from £30-58. These younguns are the future of our support and if they are blocked from coming due to price, the future fanbase will be mostly armchair fans.
But we’re going to need these core local supporters.
Over the years, many City fans have commented on how there has been a distinct lack of ‘Manchester’ with City. There are areas of our conurbation (I live in Wythenshawe, and this area is a good example of this) where there are swathes of City fans yet, outside the online world, you wouldn’t know City existed because the club itself have no presence in the area at all. And I’d bet it’s the same in many areas across the conurbation.
At half time in a few games this season, they’ve gone to the big screen and Shauny, Dickov and Lescott are in China or somewhere watching the game at some big fan park event. Yet our non-attending locals get nothing like this around Manchester… and these locals aren’t at the Etihad because it’s been too expensive. Imagine what a Wythenshawe Park and/or Heaton Park fanzone for some select games through the season would do for priced out fans… making them feel like they haven’t just been cast aside by the club.
Over the coming years, with no Pep and a lower level quality of team to the 2017-2024 City team, we are in a precarious position and the club need to be careful. Thankfully, they took on board our protests in 2025 and our suggestions through the creation of the Citizens Trust in 2026, of doing more to help us afford to keep coming to games and to make it easier to transfer tickets to friends+family. But, with no fan movement on this, and left to their own devices, the club execs/board would probably have had two further ticket price rises and upheld restrictions, with even more fans falling by the wayside.
The priority for the club in the coming years needs to be to tap into the priced out lapsed local fanbase, with a larger stadium to fill. I know a few lads like this who just don’t bother coming to games anymore. They love the club no less than they ever did and were home+away lads with me for many years. But they have felt like, as soon as they hit their price threshold and had to stop attending, the club didn’t care about them any longer. A few of these lads never bother looking at coming to games anymore. Some still do, but only the early rounds of the domestic Cups.
We need to get into our local areas more, be more of a presence, have ideas like these fanzone screened games in local parks, think of things to get our priced out lapsed fans feeling pride in the club again that makes them want to attend games. Value Gold STs for PL games is a great thing the club do. Maybe they can introduce Value Gold Champions League STs as well? Or, at least, ticket bundles for the CL League Phase.
It’s going to be the core local support the club will need if we struggle a bit over the coming years. We’ve already seen a decline in the quality of the team while Pep has been here and it’s not outlandish to say that, after he’s gone, battles for CL spots may be the norm for a while. To get the fanbase behind this potentially lower level quality team in the stadium, we are going to need our core local support.